Fargo Engaging in a Riot Defense
North Dakota’s riot law draws a deliberate line between a participant and a person who is simply there. N.D.C.C. § 12.1-25-03 expressly says, “Mere…
North Dakota criminal defense guide
Fargo Engaging in a Riot Defense
North Dakota’s riot law draws a deliberate line between a participant and a person who is simply there. N.D.C.C. § 12.1-25-03 expressly says, “Mere presence at a riot is not an offense under this section.” The State therefore cannot prove guilt by showing only that someone attended a protest, stood near people who later became violent, remained on private property, linked arms, wore similar clothing, or appeared in a crowd video. Prosecutors must prove a statutory riot and the accused person’s willful engagement in it. The North Dakota Supreme Court’s leading decision, State v. Bearrunner, reversed a riot conviction because locking arms with protesters and resisting removal did not establish the violent conduct the statutory definition requires.
North Dakota’s current engaging-in-a-riot statute
Section 12.1-25-03(1) provides: “A person is guilty of a class A misdemeanor if the person engages in a riot, as defined in section 12.1-25-01.” Subsection (2) adds two protections. First, special imminence language applies to attempt, solicitation, and conspiracy. Second, the statute states without qualification that mere presence at a riot is not an offense under this section.
The incorporated definition supplies most of the State’s burden. Under § 12.1-25-01(2), “Riot” means a public disturbance involving an assemblage of five or more persons which by tumultuous and violent conduct creates grave danger of damage or injury to property or persons or substantially obstructs law enforcement or other government function. Every phrase matters. The definition does not say “an unlawful gathering,” “a noisy crowd,” “an unauthorized protest,” or “a group that refuses commands.”
The North Dakota Criminal Code Hornbook, an official historical research resource hosted by the Court System, explains why the Legislature added the presence limitation. The revised code sought to distinguish leaders and active participants from people at the scene by accident or for legitimate purposes and to prevent indiscriminate roundups. That history is consistent with the text now in force: individual participation must be proved.
Element-by-element analysis
1. A public disturbance
The event must be public in character. A disturbance may occur on public or private property, but it must extend beyond a wholly private disagreement in the ordinary sense of the statutory phrase. Location, accessibility, visibility, number of people affected, and the nature of the event can matter. The State should identify the disturbance it alleges, not simply use the name of a broader demonstration that lasted hours or days.
2. An assemblage of at least five people
The numerical threshold applies to the assemblage involved in the alleged riot. Five people need not be separately charged, but the proof should show at least five identifiable or reliably countable people assembled in the relevant public disturbance. Video may establish crowd size while still failing to prove who joined violent conduct. A crowd of hundreds does not relieve the State of its duty to prove the qualitative elements.
3. Tumultuous conduct
“Tumultuous” is not specially defined in chapter 12.1-25. North Dakota decisions generally give undefined words their plain and commonly understood meaning. In a later disorderly-conduct case, State v. Vetter identified dictionary senses involving loud noise, disorderly commotion, or agitation, while recognizing that the factual setting matters. Riot requires tumultuous and violent conduct; commotion alone is not sufficient.
4. Violent conduct
This word did the decisive work in Bearrunner. Violence ordinarily involves physical force used to injure, damage, abuse, or destroy. The State must prove violence by the assemblage, not merely force later used by police to move or arrest passive participants. Throwing dangerous objects, assaulting people, setting fires, deliberately driving into persons, or physically destroying property may qualify. Sitting, chanting, filming, holding a sign, refusing to walk, or locking arms does not become violent simply because officers must use force to overcome noncompliance.
5. Grave danger or substantial obstruction
Tumultuous and violent conduct must produce at least one statutory consequence. One alternative is grave danger of property damage or injury to people or property. “Grave” signals seriousness, not a minor or speculative possibility. The other is substantial obstruction of law enforcement or another government function. “Substantially” excludes ordinary inconvenience. The prosecution should show how the group’s violent conduct—not unrelated traffic, police strategy, or routine event management—created the specified result.
6. The defendant engaged in the riot
To “engage” ordinarily means to participate or take part. The statutory presence sentence confirms that something beyond location is required. The State should identify the defendant’s act and explain how it joined the tumultuous and violent group activity. A person may trespass, disobey an order, or obstruct an officer without necessarily engaging in the riot defined by § 12.1-25-01. Conversely, direct violent participation can support the element even when the person did not organize the gathering.
7. The conduct was willful
Section 12.1-25-03 does not state a culpability word and does not expressly create strict liability. Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-02-02(2), the default is “willfully,” meaning intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly. Unless the law indicates otherwise, the culpability requirement applies to each conduct element and attendant circumstance. A person unexpectedly caught as a gathering changes character, trying to leave, helping an injured participant, or unaware of violence elsewhere has a materially different case from someone deliberately joining destructive group conduct.
State v. Bearrunner: the controlling North Dakota riot decision
In State v. Bearrunner, 2019 ND 29, protesters gathered in a pasture near the Dakota Access Pipeline. Law enforcement told them they were on private property and ordered them to leave. Some protesters, including Julian Bearrunner, sat and locked arms. Officers used force to separate and remove them. A jury convicted Bearrunner of criminal trespass and engaging in a riot.
The Supreme Court affirmed the trespass conviction but reversed the riot conviction. At paragraph 13, the Court held that locking arms and resisting arrest did not rise to the commonly understood definition of violence. The critical force was used by law enforcement to overcome noncompliance; that did not transform the protesters’ own conduct into statutory violence. The record also lacked evidence that anyone in the group engaged in violent conduct. Without violence, the State had not proved a riot.
The distinction is exact and practical. Bearrunner does not announce a general right to trespass, resist arrest, block work, or disregard lawful commands. It holds that those facts do not automatically satisfy a separate riot statute requiring tumultuous and violent conduct. Prosecutors and courts must respect the Legislature’s choice of elements even when another offense may be supported.
The decision also rejects guilt by atmosphere. A large protest involving police, private property, resistance, and forcible arrests may look disorderly. Criminal liability for engaging in a riot nevertheless depends on proof of the defined riot and the defendant’s participation in it. That is why defense counsel should separate each person, act, location, and minute rather than let a montage substitute for an element-by-element case.
Evidence that separates participation from presence
A synchronized event timeline
Large events generate overlapping recordings with clocks that may not match. Counsel should align body cameras, vehicle cameras, fixed surveillance, drone video, news footage, livestreams, phone files, dispatch audio, and radio traffic. The central questions are when violent conduct began, where it occurred, when the defendant arrived, what the defendant could see, what the defendant did, and whether the defendant moved toward, away from, or around the violence.
Continuous identification evidence
A short clip may show a person in distinctive clothing without proving what happened before or after. Officers may lose sight of a subject, confuse similarly dressed people, or receive custody from another arrest team. Original-resolution video, booking photographs, seized clothing, device location, arrest logs, and uninterrupted camera sequences can confirm or undermine identification. An officer’s good-faith impression is still subject to testing.
Individual acts versus the acts of strangers
The prosecution may introduce fires, property damage, injured officers, thrown objects, or barricades. Each event should be assigned a time, place, actor if known, and connection to the accused. Evidence from a different location can prove that some riot occurred while saying little about whether this defendant engaged in it. Unfairly graphic or cumulative footage may also raise relevance and prejudice objections under the Rules of Evidence.
Group communications and digital evidence
Messages, group chats, posts, maps, livestream commentary, and location records may bear on intent, awareness, or coordination. They can also show peaceful purpose, late arrival, efforts to de-escalate, or lack of knowledge about violence. Digital evidence requires lawful acquisition, authentication, attribution, completeness, and accurate timestamps. Membership in a channel is not proof that a person read, endorsed, or acted on every message.
Police plans and after-action materials
Operational plans, threat assessments, command logs, aerial observations, use-of-force reports, and after-action reviews may describe which group engaged in which conduct. Those records can expose overly broad labels or show that officers distinguished peaceful areas from destructive activity. They can also reveal that a declaration of “riot” preceded the alleged violence. Relevant records may be held by several agencies and require prompt preservation requests.
Defense themes grounded in the statutory text
No violent group conduct
After Bearrunner, passive resistance and police use of force do not by themselves prove the assemblage acted violently. If the evidence shows chanting, sitting, locked arms, slow movement, or refusal to stand, the State still needs violent conduct. The defense should insist that the jury identify the group’s violence rather than reason backward from the scale of the police response.
No grave danger and no substantial governmental obstruction
Even violence is not enough unless it creates grave danger or substantially obstructs a government function. A scuffle, isolated shove, damaged sign, or temporary inconvenience may be criminal under another provision without reaching this threshold. Measurements, traffic records, work logs, emergency-response records, and full video can test the alleged consequence.
Mere presence, observation, journalism, or assistance
The defense should affirmatively use the sentence the Legislature enacted. A person may be present to observe, report, provide medical aid, accompany another, practice religion, monitor legal rights, or peacefully advocate. Those purposes do not create immunity for later unlawful conduct, but they help explain location and undermine an inference of participation. The State must prove an act of engagement.
No knowing participation in the relevant conduct
A person may be separated from violence by distance, buildings, noise, smoke, darkness, or a police line. Someone leaving after realizing the character of the event is different from someone joining it. Native phone media, location history, witness testimony, and sightline evidence can show what the defendant knew and when.
Protected expression and association
The First Amendment protects peaceful advocacy, assembly, association, press activity, and criticism of officials. It does not protect assault or property destruction. The defense should separate protected evidence offered merely to show disfavored beliefs from conduct probative of actual participation. The State cannot convert shared slogans, clothing, symbols, or political views into a substitute for the statutory act.
Misidentification or loss of continuous observation
Helmets, masks, scarves, winter clothing, darkness, distance, and crowd movement complicate identification. A witness may accurately describe an event but misidentify the participant. Defense counsel should compare every image, officer location, handoff, and report rather than assume the booking name belongs to the person in a distant clip.
Justification, excuse, and withdrawal from danger
North Dakota’s justification and excuse rules in N.D.C.C. ch. 12.1-05 may apply in unusual circumstances, including immediate efforts to protect another from harm. The elements are specific; a sincere moral reason alone is not automatically a legal defense. Evidence of rescue, de-escalation, physical inability, coercion, or emergency should be preserved so counsel can evaluate the correct doctrine.
Attempt, solicitation, and conspiracy require imminence
For inchoate versions of this offense, § 12.1-25-03(2) incorporates § 12.1-25-01(3). A conviction for attempt, solicitation, or conspiracy requires prohibited conduct under circumstances presenting a substantial likelihood that it will imminently produce the offense. Abstract advocacy, remote planning, fantasy, or discussion detached from an imminent riot cannot be treated as equivalent to the statute’s heightened requirement.
Constitutional limits in a riot prosecution
Riot statutes regulate conduct, but they operate where speech and assembly are often present. A properly limited law may punish knowing participation in violent collective activity without violating the First Amendment. The constitutional danger arises when police or prosecutors use expressive content, association, or proximity as a proxy for the missing conduct. Courts must examine the whole record closely enough to ensure that protected advocacy is not the real basis for conviction.
Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444, 447–49 (1969), protects abstract advocacy and permits punishment of advocacy directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action only when it is likely to produce that action. North Dakota’s separate riot provisions reflect similar attention to imminence for attempt, solicitation, conspiracy, and incitement. A completed engaging-in-a-riot charge focuses on participation, not a person’s unpopular message.
Cox v. Louisiana, 379 U.S. 536, 551–58 (1965), recognizes government’s authority to regulate use of streets while rejecting uncontrolled discretion that punishes a demonstration based on official tolerance or disapproval. Content-neutral safety rules can be enforced. Selective treatment based on viewpoint, race, tribal identity, press role, or criticism raises a different issue. Comparative arrest evidence and command communications may be crucial.
Due process also requires fair notice and nonarbitrary enforcement. Bearrunner narrows uncertainty by giving “violent” its commonly understood meaning and refusing to count force used by officers as violence by passive protesters. A jury instruction or charging theory that equates noncompliance with violence would evade that holding and expose the conviction to statutory and constitutional challenge.
Official North Dakota decisions relevant to the charge
State v. Bearrunner, 2019 ND 29
This is the leading decision under §§ 12.1-25-01 and -03. The Court reversed the riot conviction because the State offered no evidence the group engaged in violence. Locking arms and resisting removal did not become violent because officers used force to overcome the protesters’ noncompliance.
State v. Vetter, 2025 ND 197
In a disorderly-conduct case, the Court applied ordinary meaning to “tumultuous” and treated the factual setting as important. Riot still requires the conjunctive phrase “tumultuous and violent”; proof that conduct was noisy or disorderly does not remove the violence element.
State v. Lonechild, 2023 ND 112
The Court gives statutory words their plain meaning and interprets a law so every word and phrase has effect. That method supports independent force for “public,” “five or more,” “tumultuous,” “violent,” “grave,” “substantially,” “engages,” and the express mere-presence exclusion.
In re A.R., 2010 ND 84
The decision distinguishes protected speech from accompanying conduct and makes context central. In a riot case, expressive words may supply background, but the conviction must rest on conduct satisfying the statute rather than offense at the viewpoint or language used.
City of Fargo v. Roehrich, 2021 ND 145
The Court explains that people may criticize police, use profanity, and make obscene gestures without arrest solely for that speech, while conduct may remain regulable. It also states North Dakota’s fair-warning and arbitrary-enforcement principles for vagueness review.
State v. Krall, 2026 ND 7
Circumstantial proof can sustain a conviction if its probative force permits guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The defense should confront the State’s proposed inferences from association, dress, movement, or messages while emphasizing the statutory rule that presence alone is innocent.
State v. Landsberger, 2025 ND 108
Jury instructions must correctly describe the applicable law as a whole. An engaging-in-a-riot instruction should define riot, require both tumultuous and violent conduct, state the consequence alternatives accurately, require willfulness, and tell jurors that mere presence is not enough.
State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127
A specific Rule 29 motion preserves the stated sufficiency issues. Counsel should name the exact deficiency—violence, group size, grave danger, substantial obstruction, the defendant’s engagement, identity, or culpability—at the close of the State’s evidence and renew the motion when appropriate.
From first appearance through trial in Fargo
A Cass County state charge ordinarily begins in the East Central Judicial District with an initial appearance addressing the accusation, counsel, release, and future dates. A defendant should not use that hearing to give an unscripted factual explanation. The complaint and probable-cause materials should identify the charged event and conduct well enough to permit preparation and protect against later prosecution for the same offense.
Discovery can involve several agencies and enormous media collections. Defense counsel should identify custodians for body cameras, aerial video, command-post recordings, radio channels, photographs, arrest logs, property records, forensic downloads, social-media returns, and use-of-force reports. Native files and metadata are preferable to compilations. A prosecutor’s highlight reel cannot show whether omitted minutes establish separation, peaceful behavior, or withdrawal.
Pretrial litigation may address the sufficiency and specificity of the charge, preservation failures, search warrants, statements, device searches, identification procedures, First Amendment evidence, authentication, completeness, hearsay, unfair prejudice, other-acts evidence, and instructions. If the State introduces misconduct by unidentified people, counsel should request a clear showing of relevance to the defendant and consider a limiting instruction.
Possible resolutions include dismissal, acquittal, a negotiated disposition, or conviction after plea or trial. The decision must account for the Class A misdemeanor exposure, additional counts, probation conditions, geographic restrictions, restitution claims, immigration consequences, professional licenses, employment, education, firearms questions, and any related civil case. A plea to a different offense can change both formal and practical consequences.
Immediate preservation steps
- Save every original file. Preserve phones, memory cards, livestream archives, cloud copies, photographs, and metadata without editing them.
- Record a private chronology for counsel. Include arrival, purpose, companions, precise locations, observed violence, movement, police instructions, arrest, and release.
- Create a scene map. Mark the accused, alleged violent acts, police lines, cameras, exits, streets, property boundaries, and sight obstructions.
- Keep clothing and equipment. Items visible on video may prove or disprove identification; do not alter or discard them.
- Preserve witness information. Save contacts and what each person observed, but do not coordinate accounts or pressure anyone.
- Do not delete posts or messages. Deletion removes context and can generate a separate allegation of concealment.
- Follow every release condition. Seek a court modification instead of informally testing a location, contact, or event restriction.
Frequently asked questions about engaging in a riot
What is engaging in a riot under North Dakota law?
It is willful participation in a public disturbance involving an assemblage of at least five people whose tumultuous and violent conduct creates grave danger of damage or injury to people or property or substantially obstructs law enforcement or another government function. The State must prove both the qualifying riot and the defendant’s engagement. The statute expressly excludes mere presence.
Is engaging in a riot a felony?
Under the current version of N.D.C.C. § 12.1-25-03, engaging in a riot is a Class A misdemeanor. The authorized maximum is 360 days’ imprisonment, a $3,000 fine, or both. Other conduct during the same event may support felony charges, including serious assault, arson, large-loss criminal mischief, or particular weapons offenses.
How many people are required for a riot?
The statutory assemblage must include five or more people. A five-person gathering alone is not a riot. The State also needs a public disturbance, tumultuous and violent conduct, and the specified grave danger or substantial obstruction. A large crowd does not satisfy those qualitative requirements automatically.
Can I be guilty just because I was in the crowd?
No. Section 12.1-25-03(2) states that mere presence at a riot is not an offense under that section. The prosecution must identify conduct showing that the accused participated. Presence can be part of the evidence, but it cannot carry the State’s burden without an act and the required culpability.
Is locking arms with other protesters violent conduct?
Not on the facts decided in State v. Bearrunner. The North Dakota Supreme Court held that locking arms and resisting arrest did not rise to the ordinary meaning of violence, even though officers used force to separate and remove protesters. Different conduct or additional facts could change the analysis, but police force does not automatically become violence by the accused.
Can passive resistance support a different charge?
Potentially. Bearrunner affirmed a trespass conviction while reversing the riot conviction. Refusing directions or resisting official action may implicate trespass, public-safety-order, obstruction, or preventing-arrest provisions depending on the facts. Each offense has its own elements, defenses, and classification; none should be treated as an automatic substitute for another.
Must I personally injure someone or damage property?
Section 12.1-25-03 uses “engages in a riot,” so the precise participation theory matters. Direct violence is powerful evidence, but prosecutors may rely on coordinated acts or accomplice principles when legally supported. They still must prove the defendant’s willful participation and cannot erase the statutory mere-presence protection through guilt by association.
What does “substantially obstructs law enforcement” mean?
The statute does not define “substantially,” so its ordinary meaning suggests a real and important obstruction rather than minor delay or inconvenience. The obstruction must result from the assemblage’s tumultuous and violent conduct. Police deployment itself does not necessarily prove that violent group conduct substantially obstructed an official function.
What if violence happened on another block?
The State may prove that a riot occurred somewhere within a broader event, but it must still connect the defendant’s conduct to that riot. Time, distance, barriers, sightlines, movement, and knowledge matter. Footage of dramatic conduct elsewhere should not be allowed to create guilt merely by association with the same event name.
Does the First Amendment protect protest activity?
Yes. Peaceful speech, assembly, association, journalism, criticism of police, and much recording activity receive constitutional protection. The First Amendment does not protect assault, arson, vandalism, or knowing participation in properly defined violent conduct. The defense should separate protected message and association from the physical acts the statute requires.
Can social-media posts prove participation?
Posts may be relevant to identity, location, knowledge, intent, or coordination if lawfully obtained, authenticated, attributable, complete, and accurately timed. Political rhetoric, event promotion, group membership, or reposting is not necessarily proof of participation in violence. The full thread, audience, platform context, and native data should be examined.
What if I left when violence started?
Leaving can be powerful evidence that the person did not willfully engage in the riot or withdrew before relevant conduct. Preserve video, phone location, messages, transportation records, and witnesses that establish timing. Leaving does not automatically erase an offense already completed, so the conduct before departure must still be analyzed.
Can I be charged for helping an injured person?
Providing aid is not itself engaging in a riot. Circumstances may show humanitarian presence, lack of willfulness, or a justification or excuse. However, the State may dispute the person’s conduct or purpose. Medical evidence, video, witness accounts, and the duration and location of assistance should be preserved.
Can prosecutors use another person’s property damage against me?
They may offer it to prove that a riot existed, subject to relevance and evidentiary limits. To prove the defendant engaged in that riot, the State needs an individualized connection. Counsel can challenge distant, unidentified, cumulative, or inflammatory footage and ask the court to prevent jurors from treating one stranger’s act as everyone’s act.
What is the special rule for attempt, solicitation, or conspiracy?
The statute incorporates a heightened requirement: prohibited conduct must occur under circumstances in which there is a substantial likelihood it will imminently produce the engaging-in-a-riot offense. Remote planning, abstract advocacy, or mere discussion is not equivalent to an imminent likelihood of a statutory riot. The separate elements of attempt, solicitation, or conspiracy also apply.
What should I bring to a Fargo riot-defense lawyer?
Bring the complaint, citation, court notices, release terms, complete original videos and photographs, the phone used during the event, relevant clothing, a detailed private timeline, a scene map, medical records, transportation information, witness contacts, and full message threads. Do not edit files, delete posts, coordinate accounts, or violate release restrictions.
Require proof of participation, not a verdict against the crowd
The statutory sentence excluding mere presence is not a footnote. It is the rule that prevents a mass event from becoming mass criminal guilt. The defense should reconstruct the accused person’s exact location, knowledge, conduct, and movement; test whether any group violence met the definition; and keep protected expression separate from physical participation. A Fargo criminal-defense lawyer can preserve the full media record and force the case back to what North Dakota law actually requires.