Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Fargo Arming Rioters Defense

Arming rioters is a Class B felony, but the title hides three sharply different accusations. N.D.C.C. § 12.1-25-02 covers knowingly supplying a firearm…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota felony defense guide

Fargo Arming Rioters Defense

Arming rioters is a Class B felony, but the title hides three sharply different accusations. N.D.C.C. § 12.1-25-02 covers knowingly supplying a firearm, dangerous weapon, or destructive device for use in a riot; teaching another to prepare or use one with intent that it be used in a riot; or knowingly being armed while engaging in a riot. The State must prove the selected theory, the required mental state, a qualifying object, and a statutory riot. Lawful ownership, ordinary instruction, presence near a protest, or a weapon in someone else’s vehicle does not by itself establish this felony.

The prosecution must commit to a statutory theory

Section 12.1-25-02(1) makes a person guilty if the person: “a. Knowingly supplies a firearm, dangerous weapon, or destructive device for use in a riot; b. Teaches another to prepare or use a firearm, dangerous weapon, or destructive device with intent that any such thing be used in a riot; or c. While engaging in a riot, is knowingly armed with a firearm, dangerous weapon, or destructive device.” The alternatives should not be blended into a general claim that the defendant “helped arm a crowd.”

The supply theory

The State must prove a knowing supply and the weapon’s intended riot use. “Supply” ordinarily means furnishing, providing, or making available. Ownership is not essential, and a permanent transfer is unnecessary, but mere proximity is not a supply. A seller, lender, driver, organizer, or person who opens a storage area may face this theory only if the evidence establishes knowing provision for riot use.

The phrase “for use in a riot” is indispensable. A lawful sale completed before any event, return of another person’s property, transport to a range, or provision for personal defense does not become this offense simply because the recipient later attends a disturbance. The prosecution may use messages, timing, packaging, statements, event plans, quantity, or concealment to prove purpose, while the defense should preserve lawful explanations and the complete exchange.

The teaching theory

This alternative requires teaching another person to prepare or use a covered object and specific intent that it be used in a riot. Ordinary firearms training, safety instruction, repair, hunting education, historical demonstration, online commentary, or abstract advocacy lacks the statutory intent unless other evidence establishes the prohibited purpose. The exact lesson, audience, date, anticipated event, and instructor’s words matter.

Because teaching usually involves expression, the intent element supplies an important First Amendment boundary. Government may punish instruction deliberately integrated into imminent unlawful conduct, but it cannot presume criminal intent from controversial subject matter alone. Edited video, jokes, rhetoric, and reposted material should be evaluated in full context.

The armed-participant theory

This alternative requires two things at the same time: the accused must be engaging in a statutory riot and must knowingly be armed. Presence at a riot is expressly insufficient under § 12.1-25-03. Likewise, lawful possession near a demonstration does not establish riot engagement. The State must prove the underlying public disturbance, five-person assemblage, tumultuous and violent conduct, grave danger or substantial governmental obstruction, the defendant’s participation, and knowing armament.

What counts as a firearm, dangerous weapon, or destructive device?

The definitions in N.D.C.C. § 12.1-01-04 govern Title 12.1. They should not be replaced casually with the similar but not identical definitions in Title 62.1.

Firearm

A firearm is a weapon that will expel or is readily capable of expelling a projectile by explosive action. The definition expressly includes a loaded or unloaded pistol, revolver, rifle, gun, machine gun, shotgun, bazooka, or cannon. An unloaded gun can therefore qualify. A permanently inoperable replica, toy, component, or object incapable of explosive projectile discharge presents a factual and expert question rather than an assumption based on appearance.

Dangerous weapon

The Title 12.1 list includes switchblade or gravity knives, machetes, scimitars, stilettos, swords, daggers, billies, blackjacks, saps, bludgeons, cudgels, metal knuckles, sand clubs, slingshots, bows and arrows, crossbows, spears, certain spring- or gas-powered projectile weapons, and projectors or objects capable of emitting a noxious liquid, gas, or substance. An ordinary pocketknife is not automatically within this particular list merely because it could cause harm.

Destructive device

A destructive device means an explosive, incendiary, or poison-gas bomb, grenade, mine, rocket, missile, or similar device. Fireworks, smoke products, flares, bottles, fuel containers, and homemade objects require careful analysis of design, components, capability, and intended function. Photographs and an officer’s label should not replace laboratory examination or competent expert proof when identity is disputed.

Armed and possession

Title 12.1 defines possession as direct physical control or the power and intention to control an accessible thing. A weapon on the person is straightforward evidence. A weapon in a shared car, backpack, tent, or room raises constructive-possession questions involving access, keys, ownership, location, statements, fingerprints, DNA, and other occupants. Knowledge and control cannot be presumed solely from presence in a common space.

A statutory riot must still be proved

Chapter 12.1-25 defines riot as a public disturbance involving at least five people whose tumultuous and violent conduct creates grave danger of damage or injury to people or property or substantially obstructs law enforcement or another government function. Noise, civil disobedience, trespass, a heated march, or police use of force does not automatically satisfy that definition.

In State v. Bearrunner, 2019 ND 29, ¶ 13, the North Dakota Supreme Court reversed an engaging-in-a-riot conviction. Protesters locked arms and resisted removal, but no evidence showed violent conduct by the group; the force came from officers overcoming noncompliance. For an armed-participant charge, Bearrunner prevents a weapon from supplying the missing riot element.

The supply and teaching theories also require a riot-related purpose. The State should identify the contemplated or actual riot, its timing, and the evidence connecting the accused’s provision or instruction to it. A general fear of unrest, defensive preparation, or political hostility is not the same as intent that a weapon be used in a statutorily defined riot.

Evidence that matters in an arming-rioters investigation

Weapon identity and operability

Original photographs, body-camera video, seizure records, chain of custody, serial numbers, laboratory testing, function tests, component analysis, and expert reports establish what the object was. The defense should inspect the item when permitted and document missing parts, permanent alterations, contamination, packaging, and who handled it. An inflammatory description in a report is not scientific proof.

Knowledge and control

Fingerprints, DNA, purchase records, registration information, receipts, messages, location, admissions, keys, passwords, and access can connect an object to a person. Each also has limits. DNA may reflect earlier lawful handling; ownership may not show present possession; access may be shared; and a statement may be ambiguous or obtained unlawfully. The complete circumstances must show knowing control.

Purpose of a supply

The State may examine chats, calls, payment records, event maps, transportation, delivery timing, packaging, and recipient conduct. Counsel should preserve the entire thread and ordinary business or personal context. A phrase that sounds sinister in a warrant affidavit may be sarcasm, safety planning, a lawful sale, or a reference to an unrelated event when read with surrounding messages.

Instruction and intent

For teaching, investigators may rely on videos, manuals, demonstrations, class rosters, encrypted messages, searches, or witness testimony. The defense should distinguish creation from forwarding, general information from individualized training, and safety content from preparation for unlawful use. Intent that the object be used in a riot must be proved, not inferred from technical knowledge alone.

Event and participation evidence

Body cameras, aerial recordings, livestreams, dispatch traffic, command logs, news footage, and phone location can show whether a riot existed and whether the accused engaged in it. Media should be synchronized by time and mapped by location. Dramatic footage from another area or hour may prove that something happened without connecting this defendant to it.

Defense issues under each charging theory

No knowing supply: The object belonged to another person, was inaccessible, was never transferred, or was supplied without awareness of its nature.

No riot-use purpose: The transfer was for sport, work, repair, sale, safekeeping, return, lawful defense, or another documented reason, and later misuse was not intended.

No criminal teaching intent: The instruction concerned safety, lawful use, history, journalism, academic study, or abstract advocacy and was not intended to facilitate weapon use in a riot.

No qualifying object: The item was a replica, ordinary tool, noncovered knife, inert component, or material that did not meet the Title 12.1 definition. Expert analysis may be necessary.

No possession or knowledge: A weapon was hidden in shared property, belonged to another occupant, was not accessible, or was present without the accused’s awareness.

No statutory riot: The gathering lacked violent group conduct, grave danger, or substantial obstruction. Under Bearrunner, passive resistance does not become violence because officers use force.

No engagement: The accused observed, reported, gave aid, peacefully protested, or was leaving rather than participating in tumultuous and violent group conduct.

Suppression or exclusion: A warrant may lack probable cause or particularity; questioning may violate Miranda; identification may be unreliable; digital evidence may be unauthenticated or incomplete; and unrelated crowd violence may be unfairly prejudicial.

How the three theories change the factual investigation

When the allegation is a hand-to-hand transfer

A video of one person handing an object to another may look conclusive while leaving every disputed element unanswered. The image may not establish what the object was, whether it functioned, who owned it, what the giver knew, or why it was transferred. The exchange could be a return, temporary safekeeping, removal from danger, or a lawful transaction. Counsel should obtain the footage before and after the clip, identify every witness, compare the object with the item later seized, and examine statements made at the time.

Timing is especially important. A transfer made before any public disturbance may still be charged if the State proves riot-use purpose, but it cannot rely on hindsight alone. Later criminal conduct by the recipient does not automatically establish the supplier’s earlier knowledge. Conversely, a message explicitly arranging delivery for destructive conduct can be powerful even if the supplier never attends the event. The legal question remains the supplier’s mental state and purpose when furnishing the covered object.

When the allegation involves a vehicle, room, or cache

Constructive possession disputes often arise when police find several weapons in a vehicle, hotel room, residence, campsite, or storage space used by multiple people. The investigation should identify who rented or owned the space, who had keys or passwords, where each object was located, whose property surrounded it, whether containers were locked, and what forensic testing shows. General access does not necessarily establish the power and intention to control each item.

A group quantity can support an inference of supply, but it is not conclusive. A collector, vendor, instructor, security worker, sporting group, or household may have several lawful items. Receipts, inventory records, photographs taken before the event, work documents, range reservations, and witness testimony can supply ordinary context. The defense should also determine whether officers combined property seized from different locations into one display that visually implies a single coordinated cache.

When the allegation is online or classroom instruction

The prosecution should identify what the accused personally taught, to whom, and with what criminal intent. Publicly available material on operation, maintenance, safety, or history is different from individualized instruction intended for use in a riot. A person who merely receives, stores, links, or forwards material is not necessarily its teacher. Platform records, authorship data, editing history, audience settings, payments, direct questions, and follow-up communications can clarify the role.

Words such as “defense,” “training,” “action,” or “prepare” can have lawful and unlawful meanings. The fact-finder is entitled to consider surrounding circumstances, but inflammatory interpretation should not replace proof. The defense should preserve the original file, full recording, syllabus, disclaimers, examples, and adjacent messages. Selectively quoted language may omit repeated instructions to avoid violence or comply with law.

When the accused carried a weapon at an event

For subsection (c), evidence of knowing armament is only half the case. Prosecutors must also prove that the accused engaged in the statutory riot. A person may lawfully or unlawfully possess a firearm under another law yet remain only a bystander to the group conduct. The weapon cannot bootstrap peaceful presence into violent participation. The defense should document what the accused did, whether the object was displayed or used, proximity to violence, opportunities to observe it, and efforts to leave or de-escalate.

North Dakota weapon laws outside chapter 12.1-25 may impose restrictions based on the person, location, concealment, public gathering, or type of item. Those provisions should be analyzed separately. Acquittal on arming rioters does not decide a distinct possession count, and proof of a technical weapon violation does not establish engagement in a riot. Charging precision prevents jurors from treating any firearm violation as the Class B felony at issue here.

Search warrants, digital extraction, and expert proof

Arming-rioters investigations can expand rapidly from one seized device to cloud accounts, location history, payment services, social networks, and additional residences. The Fourth Amendment and North Dakota law require a warrant supported by probable cause and sufficiently particular in the places and things described, unless a recognized exception applies. Counsel should compare the affidavit, warrant, return, extraction report, and actual review. A warrant tied to one event does not necessarily authorize an unlimited search of every file and year.

Consent presents separate questions. Who gave it, what did officers request, what did the person understand, was consent voluntary, and did the search remain within its scope? A co-occupant’s authority over common premises may not extend to another person’s locked container or account. Emergency circumstances may justify immediate action without creating permanent authority for a complete forensic examination after the emergency ends.

Experts may be needed to identify a destructive device, determine firearm operability, reconstruct deleted or incomplete messages, compare video objects, analyze acoustics, or explain explosives. The defense should receive the underlying data, methods, photographs, notes, calibration or validation information, and chain of custody—not merely the conclusion. The legal definition controls; an expert’s technical or military label may be broader than the object category the Legislature enacted.

Statements also require careful review. Routine identification questions differ from custodial interrogation about ownership, purpose, recipients, or event plans. Miranda applies when custody and interrogation coincide; voluntariness remains necessary even when Miranda does not. Body-camera and interview-room recordings can resolve whether officers supplied facts, promised outcomes, minimized the charge, or obtained an ambiguous assent later summarized as a confession.

Speech, association, and lawful weapon activity

The First Amendment does not protect supplying weapons for violent collective conduct or instruction deliberately integrated into a crime. It does protect abstract advocacy, political association, journalism, teaching for lawful purposes, and unpopular ideas. Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444, 447–49 (1969), makes imminence and likelihood critical when advocacy is prosecuted as incitement. Section 12.1-25-02’s intent and riot-use requirements should prevent punishment based solely on subject matter.

Firearm ownership also cannot be used as character evidence that a person favors violence. The prosecution may prove a qualifying object and its criminal connection, but lawful possession at other times is not a substitute. Search, seizure, due process, and Second Amendment questions depend on the exact conduct and charge; no constitutional right immunizes knowing weapon provision for an actual riot.

North Dakota decisions that guide the defense

State v. Bearrunner, 2019 ND 29

The controlling riot decision requires actual violent group conduct. Locking arms and resisting removal did not qualify where officers supplied the force.

State v. Grensteiner, 2024 ND 218

Possession may be actual or constructive, exclusive or joint. Constructive possession requires realistic power and capability to exercise dominion and control; shared-location facts must be examined closely.

State v. Vetter, 2025 ND 197

Undefined terms receive their ordinary meaning, and intent may be proved circumstantially. The case also discusses “tumultuous” while preserving the distinct violence requirement for riot.

State v. Lonechild, 2023 ND 112

Courts give effect to every statutory word and phrase. Supply, for use, teaches, intent, engaging, knowingly armed, and the weapon categories each perform separate work.

In re A.R., 2010 ND 84

Protected speech must be distinguished from accompanying conduct. A teaching prosecution should focus on criminal intent and conduct rather than controversial language alone.

State v. Krall, 2026 ND 7

Circumstantial evidence may sustain guilt, but its combined probative force must permit proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

State v. Landsberger, 2025 ND 108

Instructions must correctly state the enacted elements. The jury should receive the particular § 12.1-25-02 alternative rather than a blended paraphrase.

State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127

Specific Rule 29 grounds preserve those sufficiency issues. Counsel should identify the missing weapon, mental-state, riot, participation, or purpose proof.

Case process and sentencing issues

A Class B felony in Fargo ordinarily proceeds in the East Central Judicial District. Early hearings address counsel, release, and probable cause; they are not opportunities for an unplanned factual narrative. Discovery may include warrants, device extractions, laboratory reports, recordings, event media, undercover communications, and evidence held by several agencies. Counsel should seek native files, metadata, chain-of-custody records, and the complete communications surrounding any alleged transfer or lesson.

Pretrial motions can address warrant sufficiency, digital-search scope, statements, confidential informants, expert reliability, object identification, First Amendment issues, other-acts evidence, severance, and jury instructions. If § 12.1-32-02.1 is alleged, the defense should demand clarity about the bodily-injury attempt, threat, or menace said to trigger a minimum sentence and whether that fact was charged for jury determination.

Resolution must account for prison exposure, probation, forfeiture, restitution, immigration, firearm disability, employment, professional licensing, and related state or federal charges. A plea label can have lasting consequences beyond the sentence. The comparison should be between provable elements and actual alternatives, not the emotional force of the accusation.

The difference between the maximum and a mandatory minimum

The ten-year figure is the outer Class B felony limit, not a required sentence. North Dakota courts consider the governing sentencing statutes, the offense, history, harm, mitigation, treatment needs, restitution, negotiated terms, and other relevant facts. Section 12.1-32-02.1 is different: when its additional conditions are charged and found, it can require a minimum term. The State should specify whether it alleges injury, attempted injury, or a threat or menace with the weapon rather than treating knowing armament alone as the trigger.

Forfeiture and return of property

Police custody of a firearm, device, phone, vehicle, or money during the case does not by itself decide permanent ownership. Different statutes and procedures govern evidence retention, contraband, forfeiture, and return. Third-party owners may have interests distinct from the defendant. Counsel should preserve purchase records and ownership documents, track every seized item on the inventory, and avoid informal transfers or disposal while litigation is pending. A negotiated disposition should state clearly what happens to property instead of leaving the issue to an uncertain later request.

Frequently asked questions about arming rioters

Is arming rioters a felony?

Yes. It is a Class B felony, punishable by up to ten years’ imprisonment, a $20,000 fine, or both. The maximum is not a prediction.

Must a weapon actually be fired or used?

No. The supply and teaching alternatives focus on prohibited purpose, and the armed-participant alternative focuses on knowing armament while engaging in a riot. Actual use may support other charges or sentencing provisions.

Is there an automatic four-year minimum?

Not merely because § 12.1-25-02 includes a weapon. Section 12.1-32-02.1 requires additional charged and proven facts involving injury, attempted injury, or a threat or menace with a covered weapon. Counsel must examine the exact allegation.

Can an unloaded gun qualify?

Yes. Title 12.1’s firearm definition expressly includes covered weapons whether loaded or unloaded, provided they will or are readily capable of expelling a projectile by explosive action.

Does an ordinary pocketknife count?

Not automatically under the Title 12.1 list. Design and type matter. A prosecutor should not import a broader definition from another statute without legal support.

Can pepper spray be a dangerous weapon?

The Title 12.1 definition includes an object capable of producing and emitting a noxious liquid, gas, or substance. The exact product, capability, and governing definition must be examined.

What does “supplies” mean?

It generally means furnishes, provides, or makes available. The State must prove a knowing act of provision and the weapon’s intended use in a riot, not just ownership or proximity.

What if I sold the item lawfully before any protest?

A lawful sale without knowledge or purpose connected to riot use may defeat the required elements. Preserve receipts, advertisements, messages, payment records, and timing.

Can firearms training become criminal teaching?

Only if the State proves instruction to prepare or use a covered object with intent that it be used in a riot. Lawful safety, sport, hunting, repair, or academic instruction is not enough by itself.

Does the First Amendment protect online instruction?

It protects abstract advocacy and lawful information, not instruction intentionally integrated into criminal weapon use. Authorship, audience, context, intent, imminence, and the full communication matter.

Can I be charged because a gun was in a shared vehicle?

Shared location alone does not establish knowing possession. The State must prove actual or constructive control and knowledge through access, location, ownership, statements, forensic evidence, or other facts.

Must the gathering really meet the riot definition?

Yes. The State needs five or more people, a public disturbance, tumultuous and violent conduct, and grave danger or substantial governmental obstruction. A protest label is insufficient.

What if I was armed but only watching?

The third theory requires engagement in the riot, not mere presence. Other weapon laws may apply, but § 12.1-25-02(c) requires both knowing armament and actual riot participation.

Can police search my phone for messages?

They need lawful authority such as valid consent or a sufficiently particular warrant. Counsel should examine probable cause, scope, extraction methods, dates, accounts, authentication, and completeness.

Can lawful self-defense explain the weapon?

It may rebut riot-use purpose or participation, depending on the facts. It does not automatically immunize conduct during a riot. Preserve permits, training, communications, video, and the reason the item was present.

What should I bring to a Fargo defense lawyer?

Bring charging papers, warrants, inventories, laboratory reports, purchase or sale records, permits, complete messages, original media, device information, an event timeline, witness contacts, and documents showing lawful purpose. Do not delete data or contact witnesses to align accounts.

Primary authorities

This guide relies on N.D.C.C. ch. 12.1-25, § 12.1-01-04, ch. 12.1-02, and ch. 12.1-32. North Dakota cases link directly to official Court System opinions. Current-law review completed November 4, 2026.

Separate the weapon facts from the event’s label

A serious-sounding accusation is not a substitute for the selected statutory theory. The defense should identify the object, test possession and knowledge, reconstruct any transfer or instruction, determine whether a statutory riot existed, and connect—or disconnect—the accused from it. Early preservation gives a Fargo felony-defense lawyer the best chance to replace assumptions with admissible facts.

Bring the unedited evidence to that review. A few surrounding minutes, an original receipt, a complete conversation, or proof of shared access can change how an isolated photograph or message should be understood. Felony decisions should be made from the complete record and the current statute, not from the charge title alone.


Call nowChoose a time