Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Right to Counsel Before DUI Chemical Testing in North Dakota

A person arrested for DUI in North Dakota who expresses a present need to consult an attorney before deciding whether to take a chemical test has a…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota DUI right to counsel, lawyer before chemical test, Fargo DUI attorney call, breath test decision, blood test request, test refusal, implied consent, N.D.C.C. § 29-05-20, reasonable opportunity, cure refusal, NDDOT hearing, and suppression

Right to Counsel Before DUI Chemical Testing in North Dakota

A person arrested for DUI in North Dakota who expresses a present need to consult an attorney before deciding whether to take a chemical test has a limited statutory right to a reasonable opportunity to do so—so long as consultation will not materially interfere with timely testing. It is not an unlimited right to wait, locate a preferred lawyer, or postpone the decision indefinitely.

The issue is intensely factual. The exact words, when they were spoken, whether they expressed a need for advice, the officer’s response, access to a phone and numbers, privacy, call attempts, elapsed time, travel, detention location, test type, and any earlier refusal can decide both the criminal case and the NDDOT revocation.

Make the request direct and immediate. Say: “I need to speak privately with an attorney now before I decide whether to take the chemical test.” Ask for a phone and a reasonable opportunity. Call promptly, try another lawyer if the first does not answer, and tell the officer when consultation is complete. Do not assume a remark about hiring counsel later will be treated as a testing-related request.

North Dakota recognizes a limited statutory consultation right

The right comes from state law, not a general constitutional rule

N.D. Cent. Code § 29-05-20 provides that, after arrest, an attorney licensed in North Dakota may visit an accused at the request of the attorney or accused. North Dakota Supreme Court decisions apply that statute to a DUI arrestee’s testing decision.

The Court describes the right as statutory rather than constitutional. That classification matters for the triggering request, scope, remedy, and administrative proceeding. Miranda rights and the Sixth Amendment right to appointed counsel are related subjects but do not define this limited pretest consultation rule.

The person must be arrested

The recognized right concerns an arrested person deciding whether to submit to the post-arrest chemical test. Roadside questioning, field sobriety exercises, and preliminary breath screening ordinarily occur before arrest and involve different law.

Establish the arrest time. Reports may use “detained,” “taken into custody,” and “arrested” loosely. Handcuffs, formal words, transportation, and objective restraint can help identify the stage, but the statutory chemical test under § 39-20-01 itself ordinarily follows arrest.

The right is tied to the chemical-test decision

A request for a lawyer to fight the eventual charge, arrange bail, retrieve a vehicle, or address unrelated questioning is not automatically a request to consult before testing. The words and context must express a present need for legal advice relevant to the decision.

The simplest request leaves no doubt: “Before I answer the chemical-test request, I need to consult an attorney.” A lawyer called earlier for another reason should also be told that an immediate breath, blood, urine, or oral-fluid decision is pending.

The right is qualified by the need for timely evidence

Alcohol and drug evidence changes over time. The law balances consultation against obtaining an accurate, timely sample. If a lawyer cannot be reached within a reasonable period, the officer may require the person to choose without counsel.

The person cannot use phone calls to run out the clock. Officers cannot invoke evidence dissipation abstractly while creating avoidable delay or denying a short, practical call that would not interfere materially.

Police do not have to give legal advice

An officer must provide an opportunity when the right is triggered, but ordinarily need not explain whether taking the test is strategically wise, recommend a lawyer, predict the result, or interpret constitutional law for the arrestee. The officer should accurately provide the required implied-consent advisory.

If the person asks, “Should I call a lawyer?” the officer should clarify whether the person wants to consult one. The safest practice is direct clarification rather than treating uncertainty as a refusal.

A lawyer cannot guarantee confidentiality if police remain within hearing range

Meaningful consultation ordinarily requires practical privacy when it can be provided consistently with custody and safety. A phone held on speaker with several officers listening may inhibit candid advice and may undermine the opportunity.

Absolute privacy is not always feasible. Document room layout, distance, restraints, monitoring, background noise, call method, and whether the officer refused a reasonable request to step away.

The arrestee must communicate a present need for counsel

An affirmative request is the strongest invocation

“I want to talk to a lawyer before deciding” directly links the need for counsel to testing. It is stronger than mentioning that the person has a lawyer, plans to hire one, or will challenge the case later.

Say it after the officer asks for the chemical test, and repeat it after a change in requested sample or custody location. Ask the officer to record the request and note the time.

Hernandez distinguishes request from conversation

In Hernandez, the Court held that passive future-tense comments—having a paid lawyer and planning to call the lawyer after leaving—did not affirmatively express a present need to consult counsel about the chemical test. The custodial officer therefore had no duty to create a consultation opportunity.

The decision does not require ritual words. It requires communication of an actual need. Context, grammar, timing, tone, and what the officer asked all help show whether a statement invoked the right or merely mentioned counsel.

A passing reference may be insufficient

Statements such as “I will lawyer up,” “my lawyer will handle this,” or naming a lawyer during a discussion of court may concern future defense rather than the immediate sample. North Dakota opinions have treated some passing remarks as insufficient.

Officers can avoid litigation by asking, “Are you requesting to speak with an attorney now before you decide about the chemical test?” The defense should identify whether that clarification occurred and whether the answer was captured.

An ambiguous testing-related statement should be clarified

Skobodzinski explains that a request must be unambiguous, but police must seek clarification before denying the right when the statement is ambiguous. The duty to clarify prevents an officer from exploiting uncertain phrasing while the person plainly raises counsel in the testing context.

The critical distinction is between ambiguity about a present need and a mere conversational reference unrelated to consultation. A full recording is usually better evidence than a report saying only “did not request attorney.”

The request can follow an initial refusal

A driver does not necessarily lose the consultation right merely because the request comes after an officer has treated an earlier answer as refusal. If testing remains feasible and the person may cure the refusal, a timely request for counsel can be meaningful.

Skobodzinski rejected the Department’s effort to require special words connecting counsel to an expressed intent to cure. The officer had told the driver he could change his mind, and the delayed consultation deprived him of a meaningful opportunity.

The request should be made to someone who controls access

State the request to the arresting officer, testing operator, transporting officer, supervisor, or correctional officer. If one says another person controls the phone, repeat the request to that person and ask that it be relayed.

A lawyer who learns of the arrest can also request to communicate with the client under § 29-05-20. Record the call, time, recipient, and response through office notes and telephone records.

Language and disability can affect invocation

A non-English speaker may use literal or unfamiliar phrases. Hearing loss, head injury, cognitive disability, medication, or severe distress may also affect expression. Officers who recognize the issue should use an interpreter or other reasonable communication aid rather than infer refusal from misunderstanding.

Obtain interpreter logs, medical records, audio quality, education and language history, and video. The claim should identify what the person communicated and what police reasonably understood.

A reasonable opportunity is measured objectively from all circumstances

There is no fixed number of minutes

North Dakota uses an objective totality test rather than a universal time limit. A short period may be unreasonable if police do nothing and a phone is available; a longer period may be reasonable if the person makes calls, waits for a return call, and testing remains timely.

Build a precise clock: arrest, advisory, request, first phone access, each call and duration, consultation, decision, test sequence, and any transport or equipment delay. Avoid estimates such as “a while.”

Prompt access is usually the starting point

Once the request is made, police should provide practical access without avoidable delay. Transport to a law-enforcement center may be necessary when no safe phone access exists, but an officer should not postpone a readily available call merely for convenience.

In Skobodzinski, the driver asked for counsel while officers were already delayed and discussing testing; he did not receive access until more than an hour later at the law-enforcement center. The Supreme Court found the opportunity was not meaningful.

The person must use the opportunity diligently

Call promptly. If the preferred lawyer does not answer, leave a concise message and try another lawyer, public defense contact if available, or a responsible resource. Do not spend the period on unrelated calls.

Tell the officer when attempts fail and request a reasonable additional attempt. A person who refuses offered means, repeatedly dials unavailable contacts, or stalls may be required to decide without counsel.

Police may set a reasonable limit

An officer may explain that testing is time-sensitive and set a practical deadline based on the elapsed time and circumstances. The limit should allow meaningful effort, not a nominal call designed to fail.

Record what limit was given, why, when it began, whether a call was connected, and whether the attorney requested a few additional minutes. A limit announced only after it expires is difficult to evaluate fairly.

Access to numbers and a working phone matters

A phone is not useful if the person cannot identify any attorney, cannot dial outside, lacks glasses needed to read numbers, or is told the wrong dialing procedure. Reasonable assistance may include a directory, internet lookup by staff, dialing instructions, or access to the person’s phone contacts when safe.

The right does not require police to select counsel. It does require an opportunity capable of producing communication, not merely placing an unusable handset in the room.

Privacy is part of meaningful consultation

Ask whether the officer stepped out, remained in sight but out of hearing, required speakerphone, recorded the call, or interrupted. Counsel should ask the client immediately whether anyone can hear and document the answer.

Safety, restraints, and facility design may justify visual monitoring. The defense should propose what modest privacy was feasible and how its denial affected the advice.

Testing delays created by police weaken a claim of urgency

Equipment malfunction, unavailable certification, transport, paperwork, staffing, and repeated officer discussion can consume time. If police tolerate those delays but deny a short lawyer call as materially interfering, the inconsistency matters.

The court examines objective facts. Compare the consultation time requested with the total investigation and with later waiting unrelated to evidence collection.

Consultation must occur before the decision it is meant to inform

A phone call after the chemical test or after testing has become impractical may not remedy denial at the decision point. Likewise, an offer to call a lawyer about court after a refusal does not necessarily provide a chance to reconsider testing.

The sequence should show whether counsel could still affect consent, refusal, sample choice issues, a warrant response, an independent test request, and preservation.

The counsel issue can determine whether an answer is a valid refusal

Waiting for counsel is not automatically refusal

When a driver properly invokes the right and a reasonable consultation will not materially interfere, failure to answer immediately is not the affirmative refusal needed for administrative revocation. Police must first afford the opportunity or establish why it could not reasonably be provided.

The driver should make clear that the pause is for consultation, not a final “no.” Say: “I am not refusing; I am asking to consult counsel before deciding.”

The right does not permit indefinite conditional refusal

If reasonable efforts fail to reach counsel, the officer may require a decision. Saying “I will not test until my personal lawyer arrives” can become refusal when physical arrival would materially delay testing.

A lawyer reached by phone should advise efficiently. The consultation is about an urgent evidence decision, not a full intake or trial strategy session.

A prior refusal may be cured in some circumstances

North Dakota recognizes that a person may reconsider. Whether a later agreement cures refusal can depend on promptness, continuous custody, testing feasibility, police position, and evidentiary delay. An officer’s statement that the person may change their mind is powerful context.

Skobodzinski treated consultation as meaningful partly because it could have led the driver to cure. Police had not irrevocably ended testing and acknowledged the possibility of reconsideration.

A second consultation is not always required

In City of Jamestown v. Schultz, 2020 ND 154, ¶¶ 7–13, the Court held that a driver who had received a reasonable consultation before agreeing to test was not automatically entitled to a second lawyer call when operator-credential problems changed who would administer the same breath test.

The holding is fact-specific. A materially different sample request, new legal authority, new threat, warrant development, or earlier inadequate consultation may present a different question. Identify what changed and why renewed advice was necessary.

Agreeing to test does not waive unrelated legal challenges

After advice, a driver may submit while later challenging the stop, arrest, advisory, consent, warrant, method, operator, device, sample, chain, laboratory, interpretation, or independent-test access. Consultation does not validate everything police did.

Counsel should preserve the immediate testing decision while avoiding promises about admissibility or outcome without records.

A refusal can create criminal and administrative consequences

Current § 39-08-01 can criminalize refusal of a qualifying officer-directed chemical test after constitutionally adequate advice. Chapter 39-20 separately provides administrative revocation. The sample type matters because breath, blood, and urine are not constitutionally identical.

A denial of counsel may defeat the affirmative refusal necessary for revocation and may support suppression or other relief in criminal court. The correct remedy depends on forum, charge, sample, and prejudice.

Recent North Dakota decisions define the practical boundaries

Skobodzinski: delay can make access meaningless

The driver initially refused testing. The trooper told him to say if he changed his mind. During ensuing delay, the driver requested a supervisor and attorney. Officers allowed the supervisor conversation but did not provide attorney access until arrival at the law-enforcement center more than an hour later.

The Supreme Court concluded the delayed access did not provide a reasonable, meaningful opportunity to consult and potentially cure the refusal. The objective timeline, acknowledged ability to reconsider, and availability of an earlier opportunity controlled.

Hernandez: future representation is not a present request

The 2026 decision clarifies that saying one has a paid lawyer or will call the lawyer after release does not necessarily express a need to consult now. The Court required an affirmative request or expression of present need in the testing setting.

The holding protects ordinary conversation from becoming an automatic consultation request. It also gives defense counsel a clear drafting lesson: quote the words and show that they sought immediate advice before the decision.

Schultz: one reasonable consultation may be enough

The driver consulted an attorney and agreed to take an Intoxilyzer test. The first operator then discovered invalid credentials, and another operator administered the test. The Court held the driver was not entitled to a second opportunity merely because he asked whether he should call again.

Analyze the first consultation’s adequacy and whether the later development materially changed the legal decision. A request for officer advice is not necessarily a new affirmative counsel request.

Older cases remain useful, but current law controls

North Dakota’s foundational decisions describe the right as qualified, adopt a bright-line response to an expressed need for counsel, distinguish passing references, and balance testing urgency. Later cases refine how ambiguity, timing, reconsideration, and meaningful access work.

Always use the offense-date statutes and newest controlling opinion. The Supreme Court’s 2025 and 2026 decisions provide the most current direction for requests and delay.

The standard is objective

The officer’s subjective belief that the driver was stalling does not decide the issue, and the driver’s private belief that consultation was denied is not enough. Courts assess observable facts: words, time, resources, conduct, and testing needs.

That standard makes contemporaneous recordings and logs unusually important. A one-page report written later cannot fully capture pauses, unanswered calls, officer discussions, or privacy conditions.

Mixed questions receive layered review

Courts defer to supported factual findings and credibility determinations but review the legal significance of established facts under the governing standard. Preserve objections to both the facts and the application of law.

At an NDDOT hearing, make a complete record. District-court review is generally confined to that agency record, and the appeal deadline is extremely short.

The remedy depends on the forum and the evidence affected

Administrative revocation may be reversed

If consultation was unreasonably denied, the person’s failure to take the test may not qualify as the affirmative refusal necessary for revocation. Skobodzinski reversed the agency decision and reinstated driving privileges.

Request the NDDOT hearing within ten days after issuance of the temporary permit. Present the recording, phone logs, officer testimony, timestamps, and any lawyer or supervisor evidence.

Chemical-test evidence may be suppressed in a criminal case

North Dakota decisions recognize suppression of chemical-test results as a remedy when the limited statutory consultation right is infringed in the criminal setting. The motion should identify the request, denial, resulting sample, and why exclusion is legally appropriate.

Suppression is not automatic for every imperfect phone arrangement. The person must show invocation, an unreasonable opportunity, and the connection to the testing evidence.

Refusal evidence may be challenged

When police treat a counsel request as refusal without providing the required opportunity, the defense can challenge whether an affirmative refusal occurred and whether the State may use it. The argument can affect the refusal count, jury evidence, and license case.

Ask for a pretrial ruling and tailored instruction. The jury should not hear a legal conclusion that the driver refused when the court has found the required consultation opportunity was denied.

A later call may not cure an earlier denial

If the opportunity arrives after testing can no longer be taken or after the driver’s decision is treated as final, the right may have lost its purpose. Police cannot necessarily cure denial by permitting a routine phone call at booking.

Prove what could still have happened at each moment. In a cure case, show the officer continued to hold testing open; in a test-result case, show whether consent and collection were already complete.

The administrative record must be developed fully

Subpoena or call the arresting and transporting officers, testing operator, correctional staff, supervisor, and attorney if needed. Offer video, call detail, facility logs, maps, and timelines. Make offers of proof when evidence is excluded.

Section 39-20-06 generally limits judicial review to the agency record and requires service and filing within seven days after the hearing as shown on the decision. A thin hearing record is difficult to repair later.

Criminal and NDDOT litigation should remain coordinated

The same testimony can affect both matters, but deadlines and burdens differ. Compare every officer statement across the report, agency hearing, deposition or motion hearing, and trial.

A successful license argument may reveal evidence useful in criminal court. A criminal ruling may aid persuasion but does not automatically set aside the agency action.

A serious counsel-denial claim starts with a forensic timeline

Preserve every recording immediately

Request squad, body, testing-room, transport, booking, jail, lobby, and telephone audio or video; dispatch; CAD; phone and kiosk logs; reports; notes; advisories; chemical-test records; warrants; and supervisor communications. Send written preservation demands before automatic deletion.

Obtain the lawyer’s call log, voicemail, notes, and recollection. Preserve the client’s phone records and family messages. Do not record privileged substance unnecessarily; focus on timing, access, and whether communication occurred.

Transcribe the exchange word for word

Include the chemical request, every attorney reference, clarification, refusal or agreement, offer to reconsider, time warning, phone instruction, call attempt, privacy request, and final decision. Identify speaker and timestamp.

Compare the transcript to the report. Common disputes include omitted attorney references, changed order, understated waiting, and a “refusal” label that preceded any reasonable call opportunity.

Separate the invocation question from the opportunity question

First ask whether the person affirmatively requested or expressed a need to consult. If yes—or if testing-related ambiguity required clarification—ask whether police provided a reasonable, meaningful opportunity. Do not collapse the two steps.

Hernandez is central to step one. Skobodzinski is central to step two and to post-refusal consultation where cure remained possible.

Measure police-caused and evidence-related delay

Chart driving, stop, arrest, advisory, request, calls, transport, equipment preparation, operator availability, diagnostic sequence, sample, and booking. Mark time spent on police paperwork or waiting unrelated to the client.

If a five-minute call was denied but officers waited thirty minutes for an operator, demand an explanation. If testing was near the two-hour period and the client had already used substantial time on unsuccessful calls, the State’s urgency argument is stronger.

Investigate phone functionality and privacy

Test the detention phone’s dialing rules, blocked numbers, collect-call restrictions, attorney directory, volume, and privacy. Obtain photographs or a diagram of the room. Identify whether the person had glasses, language assistance, or access to saved contacts.

A formal offer of a phone is not meaningful if no outside call could connect. Conversely, records of multiple completed calls can undermine a denial claim.

Prepare the attorney witness carefully

The lawyer may establish when the call came, how long it lasted, interruptions, audibility, officer proximity, and whether additional time was requested. Protect privileged legal advice unless waiver and strategy justify disclosure.

Use objective phone records where possible. A narrow stipulation may establish access without revealing confidential substance.

File separate, timely motions

Move to suppress chemical results, exclude refusal evidence, dismiss or limit a refusal count where supported, and litigate arrest or sample authority separately. Each motion should identify the legal right, facts, remedy, and preservation basis.

Do not wait for trial. Administrative deadlines may expire first, and Herrera separately requires probable-cause challenges to be raised pretrial.

Keep advice focused when counsel receives the live call

Confirm arrest, requested sample, advisory, prior tests or refusals, medical issues, medication, crash, warrants, CDL status, and whether the officer says time is limited. Explain immediate legal consequences accurately and efficiently.

Then document start and end times, privacy limitations, interruptions, and any request made to the officer. The consultation should not unnecessarily delay testing or drift into a complete case interview.

Frequently asked questions about counsel before North Dakota DUI testing

Do I have a right to call a lawyer before a North Dakota DUI breath test?

After arrest, if you affirmatively ask or express a present need to consult counsel before deciding, police must provide a reasonable opportunity unless it would materially interfere with timely testing.

Is this a constitutional right?

North Dakota describes the pretest consultation right as a limited statutory right derived from state law, including § 29-05-20, rather than a general constitutional right.

What words should I use?

Say: “I need to speak privately with an attorney now before I decide whether to take the chemical test.” This clearly expresses a present testing-related need.

Is saying “I have a lawyer” enough?

Not necessarily. Hernandez holds that conversational, future-tense references to having or later calling a lawyer do not automatically request immediate consultation.

What if my statement is ambiguous?

When an ambiguous statement concerns a present need for counsel in the testing setting, Skobodzinski says officers must seek clarification before denying the right.

How long may I wait for a lawyer?

There is no fixed statewide minute limit. Reasonableness depends on elapsed time, test urgency, call access, attempts, privacy, police delay, and other objective circumstances.

May I wait for my lawyer to come to the station?

Usually not if physical arrival would materially delay the chemical test. The right generally concerns a reasonable opportunity to consult, commonly by telephone.

What if no lawyer answers?

Try another reasonable number promptly. If counsel cannot be reached within a reasonable time, the officer may require you to decide without legal consultation.

Must police give me privacy?

The opportunity must be meaningful, and feasible privacy is relevant. Safety and facility limits may justify visual monitoring, but unnecessary listening can support a challenge.

Do police have to provide a lawyer or legal advice?

No. They generally need not select counsel, appoint one for the testing decision, or advise what choice to make. They must not unreasonably block a properly invoked consultation.

Can I ask for counsel after initially refusing?

Yes, the request may still matter if testing remains feasible and refusal can be cured. Skobodzinski rejected a rigid rule that an earlier refusal ends the consultation issue.

Can I change my mind and take the test?

Sometimes. Prompt reconsideration while testing remains practical may cure refusal. Timing, police conduct, delay, and whether the officer held the test open are important.

Do I get a second lawyer call if the breath-test operator changes?

Not automatically. City of Jamestown v. Schultz held that one reasonable consultation was enough on its facts when another operator administered the same test after a credential problem.

What if police wait until the jail to let me call?

That may be too late if an earlier practical opportunity existed or the delay destroyed a meaningful chance to decide or cure refusal. Skobodzinski reversed an agency revocation after a lengthy delay.

What is the remedy if police deny counsel?

Possible remedies include reversal of administrative revocation, suppression of chemical-test results, or exclusion and challenge of refusal evidence, depending on the forum and facts.

How quickly must I challenge the license revocation?

The NDDOT hearing request is generally due within ten days after issuance of the temporary operator’s permit. A later criminal court date does not extend that period.

What evidence proves denial?

Preserve all video and audio, exact words, timestamps, phone logs, dialing restrictions, privacy conditions, transport and equipment delays, reports, supervisor communications, and the contacted lawyer’s nonprivileged timing evidence.

What should a defense lawyer argue?

Separate whether the right was invoked from whether the opportunity was reasonable, then connect the denial to refusal, chemical evidence, administrative revocation, and the specific remedy requested.

Legal update note: This guide reflects North Dakota statutes and reported decisions reviewed through November 5, 2026, including State v. Hernandez. The offense-date law and recorded facts control.


Call nowChoose a time