Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Right to an Independent Chemical Test After a North Dakota DUI Arrest

A person who completes the chemical test directed by North Dakota law enforcement may obtain an additional chemical test, at the person's expense, from a…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota independent chemical test lawyer, independent blood test after DUI, Fargo DUI blood draw, second BAC test, N.D.C.C. § 39-20-02, police interference, hospital blood alcohol test, additional chemical test, test preservation, rising alcohol defense, and DUI evidence

Right to an Independent Chemical Test After a North Dakota DUI Arrest

A person who completes the chemical test directed by North Dakota law enforcement may obtain an additional chemical test, at the person’s expense, from a qualified person of the person’s choosing. The additional test can verify, contradict, or help interpret the government’s result—but the right is easy to lose through delay, an unclear request, refusal of the officer’s test, or failure to make practical arrangements.

The statute does not turn police into the driver’s testing service. It does require freedom from unreasonable police interference once the right exists and is clearly asserted. Whether officers afforded a reasonable opportunity is decided from the total circumstances: the request, timing, detention, telephone access, transportation, provider availability, release plan, medical facility, cost, and everything the person and officers did next.

Ask clearly, promptly, and on the recording. Say: “I completed your chemical test. I want an additional independent blood alcohol and drug test under N.D.C.C. § 39-20-02. I need a phone and a reasonable opportunity to arrange it now.” Identify a qualified provider, ask what release or transportation arrangements are permitted, and repeat the request if another officer or jailer takes custody.

The request must communicate an independent test clearly

Use the words “additional independent chemical test”

Do not rely on hints such as “I do not trust that machine,” “Can I go to the hospital?” or “I want another opinion.” A clear statement identifies that the officer’s test was completed and that the person now wants a separate chemical test by a qualified provider of the person’s choosing.

Bowen reaffirmed that the person bears responsibility for asserting the right and that the request must be clear and unambiguous. A later declaration repeating the legal standard without factual detail may lose to credible testimony that no request was heard.

Make the request where audio and video capture it

State the request to the arresting officer, the chemical-test operator, and any correctional officer who assumes custody. Ask the officer to note it in the report. If a telephone call is allowed, tell a family member or lawyer what was requested and when.

Recordings can prevent a credibility contest. If no recording exists, identify every witness, exact words, location, and approximate time while memory is fresh.

Name the test and provider when possible

“I want an independent blood draw at Sanford Medical Center” is more actionable than “I want a test.” Ask to contact the facility and confirm that it will collect a legal blood-alcohol specimen, preserve it, arrange analysis, and document the chain of custody.

A person need not know every laboratory detail at the jail counter, but a concrete proposal shows diligence and helps distinguish a real evidence request from delay or general dissatisfaction.

Ask for the practical means to arrange the test

Request a telephone, directory or internet contact information if available, access to a lawyer or family member who can help, information about release, and permission for a qualified provider to collect at the detention facility if feasible. If transportation is needed, ask whether police will permit a sober adult, ambulance, taxi, or other lawful means.

The person should not passively wait after making one statement. Follow up, make calls, accept reasonable offered assistance, and explain obstacles. Courts examine the person’s effort as well as police conduct.

Repeat the request after transfer of custody

An arresting officer may leave after booking while jail staff controls phones and release. Repeat the request and ask staff to contact the officer or supervisor. The clock on useful alcohol testing continues to run.

Write down names, badge numbers, call times, numbers dialed, messages, facility responses, and any refusal. A lawyer should obtain jail logs and video before routine retention periods expire.

Do not make the request conditional on undoing the government test

The statutory right supplements the officer’s test. A statement that the person will take a blood test only instead of the officer’s breath test is not a request for an additional test and can result in refusal consequences.

Complete the lawful officer-directed chemical test first, then state the independent request. If constitutional objections exist to the selected government sample, legal advice is necessary because blood and urine requests can raise issues not present with breath.

Act immediately

Alcohol concentration changes with time, and some drugs redistribute or decline. A test collected several hours later may require modeling and may lose much of its ability to check the earlier result. Delay also makes providers, collectors, transportation, and payment harder to arrange.

The request should follow the officer’s completed test without unnecessary interruption. Counsel contacted during the testing process should treat the evidence problem as urgent.

Police must not unreasonably interfere, but they need not do everything

The core right is freedom from police interference

North Dakota decisions describe the independent-test right as the opportunity to obtain a test through the person’s own efforts and expense without unreasonable police obstruction. Officers cannot make the statutory right meaningless by preventing calls, misleading the person, delaying until evidence disappears, or blocking an available qualified collector without justification.

Whether interference occurred depends on the whole encounter, not one rigid checklist. Detention needs, safety, staffing, distance, facility rules, release timing, and the driver’s diligence all matter.

Totality of circumstances controls

In Koenig v. North Dakota Department of Transportation, 2012 ND 18, ¶¶ 6–10, officers told the driver he would be released when a sober adult arrived, looked up and called a hospital number for him, and offered another call when his ride did not appear. The Court held the total circumstances afforded a reasonable opportunity.

The result turned on those facts. Koenig does not authorize officers to ignore every transportation request or withhold all communication. It shows that reasonable assistance and release can satisfy the statute even when officers do not drive the person to a hospital.

Police do not have a universal transportation duty

The person ordinarily must arrange transportation. If release is prompt and a sober adult, taxi, or other means is realistically available, officers may not be required to transport. Koenig specifically found no transportation duty on its record.

Different facts can support a different conclusion: continued detention, no lawful outside transportation, a nearby willing provider, a time-sensitive request, and police control over the only means to reach the collector. Ask explicitly and document the answer.

Telephone access can be decisive

A reasonable telephone opportunity may allow the person to locate a hospital, lawyer, family member, laboratory, collector, funds, and transportation. Police interference can include withholding a phone after a clear request or arbitrarily limiting calls so arrangements cannot be made.

Telephone access is not self-executing. The person should use the offered phone, make focused calls, and accept reasonable help with numbers. In Koenig, declining an offered follow-up call weighed against the claim.

Police may impose reasonable safety and custody conditions

An intoxication arrest does not require release to an unsafe driver. Officers may require a sober responsible adult, follow jail-security rules, prevent evidence tampering, and limit access that would endanger staff or others. Those interests should be implemented without defeating timely testing unnecessarily.

Consider alternatives: a mobile qualified collector, collection at the jail, escorted testing, release to a sober adult, or a nearby medical facility. The question is whether the response was reasonable, not whether the person’s preferred logistics were granted exactly.

Police should not provide materially false information

An officer should not tell a tested person that independent testing is legally forbidden, that no hospital can test without checking, that the government test cannot be challenged, or that requesting a second test is itself refusal. False information can deter the effort as effectively as denying a phone.

Compare the officer’s statement with facility policies and recorded calls. Prove what was available at the time rather than relying on later speculation.

Ordinary facility refusal is not automatically police denial

A hospital may decline forensic collection, require registration, demand advance payment, lack a qualified collector, or send specimens only to its contracted laboratory. A private provider’s unavailability can be an independent obstacle rather than state interference.

The person should try another qualified option if time permits and ask police for reasonable access to do so. Preserve who refused, why, and whether an alternative existed.

The independent test should be designed to answer a useful forensic question

Independent blood testing is often the most informative option

A properly collected whole-blood specimen can be analyzed for ethanol and, if requested and preserved appropriately, drugs. It creates a specimen that an independent laboratory can retest and that a toxicologist can compare with the officer’s breath, blood, or urine result.

Specify whole blood for forensic alcohol analysis when appropriate. Hospital clinical serum or plasma testing can produce a value that is not directly interchangeable with whole-blood alcohol concentration. Obtain the matrix, method, units, and conversion evidence before comparing numbers.

A medical blood draw needs documented collection and custody

Record collector identity and qualification, date and exact time, specimen tubes and additives, lot information, seal numbers, labeling, patient identifiers, storage temperature, every transfer, laboratory receipt, analytical method, controls, uncertainty, and report certification.

A result without reliable identity and custody may be attacked. Independent does not mean informal. The defense should aim for documentation at least as careful as the State demands of its own evidence.

Clinical testing and forensic testing serve different purposes

Hospitals may run an alcohol result for treatment using serum or plasma, while forensic laboratories commonly use preserved whole blood and a validated evidentiary method. A clinical panel can still be relevant, but differences in specimen and purpose must be explained.

Ask the facility whether it will collect a separate legal specimen without necessarily running an emergency-department panel. Avoid unnecessary medical charges or treatment data when a direct forensic collection is available and safe.

An independent breath test has practical limits

A second evidentiary breath test soon after the first can provide a trend and check gross inconsistency, but access to an approved instrument and certified operator may be limited. Consumer breath devices vary and may lack reliable calibration, logs, and admissible foundation.

If breath is used, identify the instrument, serial number, operator, approved method, diagnostics, gas standard, deprivation period, sample traces, times, and certified record. A number from an unknown handheld device may create more confusion than proof.

Urine often answers presence better than driving-time impairment

Urine accumulates substances over the bladder interval and may show prior use long after acute effects. An independent urine test can check identity or laboratory findings, but it usually cannot establish a precise drug concentration or impairment at driving time without substantial limitations.

Document prior voiding, collection time, observed or unobserved procedure, preservatives, storage, screening, confirmation, analytes, cutoffs, and whether the report identifies active compound or metabolite.

Drug testing must be requested deliberately

An alcohol-only order will not automatically produce a comprehensive toxicology analysis. If prescription, cannabis, stimulant, sedative, or other drug issues matter, the collector and laboratory need proper tubes, sufficient volume, a defined panel, confirmatory methods, and storage instructions.

Broad drug testing can reveal unfavorable information. Counsel should weigh the purpose, likely substances, prescription history, detection windows, and disclosure consequences while acting quickly enough to preserve evidence.

The defense should preserve part of the specimen

Ask the laboratory not to consume the entire sample, to maintain the seal and storage, and to release an aliquot under documented custody for later defense testing. Obtain the written retention period and send a preservation notice.

A sample discarded under ordinary policy before counsel acts may be lost permanently. Prompt written instructions turn a momentary opportunity into reviewable evidence.

A second result can verify, contradict, or contextualize the State’s evidence

Two results create a time series, not a simple winner

If the officer’s test and independent test occur at different times, the numbers should not be compared as if simultaneous. Alcohol may still be absorbing, may be near a plateau, or may be eliminating. The specimen types and analytical uncertainty also matter.

A toxicologist should work from verified times, matrices, methods, units, food, drinking history, and uncertainty. The later number does not mechanically “cancel” the earlier one.

A lower later result can be expected elimination

Alcohol concentration often falls after absorption. A later independent value below 0.08 may be consistent with an earlier over-limit result, inconsistent with it, or inconclusive depending on the interval and assumptions.

Calculate a range rather than selecting an elimination rate that produces the desired answer. If the government’s test was within North Dakota’s two-hour per-se period, the test-time value has direct statutory significance.

A higher later result may support continuing absorption

When the later properly comparable result is higher, it may support a rising-alcohol analysis. But differences in blood versus breath, whole blood versus serum, device bias, timing, food, recent drinking, and uncertainty must be addressed first.

The defense should not promise a rising-alcohol conclusion merely because the second digit is larger. Use a qualified expert and the complete drinking timeline.

Agreement can strengthen or narrow the dispute

Closely agreeing independent and government results may confirm the central concentration while leaving other issues—driving, actual physical control, timing, stop, arrest, advisory, or impairment—open. It can also help resolve a case efficiently.

Lawyers should obtain and understand the result before disclosing or using it. Discovery duties, expert rules, subpoena risk, and ethical obligations must be evaluated under the facts and applicable procedure.

Disagreement requires a source-by-source audit

Large disagreement can arise from misidentification, collection time, specimen matrix, mouth alcohol, contamination, calibration, analytical error, storage, unit conversion, or a real biological change. Audit both tests symmetrically rather than assuming the independent result is correct because the defense obtained it.

Give the expert raw data and quality-control material, not just final reports. A defensible opinion explains why one result is more reliable or why the conflict prevents a confident conclusion.

Independent drug results rarely prove impairment by themselves

Detection of a drug or metabolite does not automatically establish unsafe-driving incapacity at a particular time. The independent result must be integrated with dose timing, prescription directions, pharmacology, active compounds, metabolites, driving, video, examination, and medical alternatives.

Its value may be to show the State identified the wrong substance, overstated a screen, missed a medication, failed to confirm, or relied on a concentration without an accepted impairment threshold.

Police denial can support suppression or dismissal, but ordinary failure may not

The statute distinguishes inability from police interference

Section 39-20-02 says the person’s failure or inability to obtain an additional test does not preclude admission of the officer-directed test. That language prevents automatic exclusion when no provider is available, transportation fails, the person lacks funds, or the person does not follow through.

North Dakota decisions distinguish those events from a denial by law enforcement. When police unreasonably prevent a clearly requested test, suppression of government results or dismissal may be available depending on the case.

The remedy should address the lost evidence

Suppression of the officer-directed chemical result may be appropriate because the denied independent test would have permitted verification or impeachment. In some settings, dismissal may be argued when the interference destroyed irreplaceable evidence and no narrower remedy protects the right.

The court will examine what was requested, whether the right had arisen, what police did, whether testing was realistically obtainable, how quickly alcohol or drugs changed, and the resulting prejudice.

Williams limits claims after refusal

Williams reversed suppression because the driver refused the officer-directed chemical breath test. His earlier PBT did not activate the § 39-20-02 right. An officer’s discussion of later hospital testing did not transform refusal into a completed government chemical test.

A motion must therefore establish the threshold first. Prove that the qualifying officer-directed test was actually administered before litigating whether the additional test was denied.

Bowen makes credibility and detail central

In Bowen, the defendant’s declaration stated in conclusory terms that he clearly requested his own blood test. A correctional officer did not recall the request and described her regular practice of notifying the arresting officer when one was made. The district court credited that testimony, and the Supreme Court affirmed.

A successful claim should include the actual words, recipient, time, location, response, witnesses, recordings, and follow-up actions. Reciting “clear and unambiguous” is not a factual account.

Koenig shows why diligence matters

The officers in Koenig facilitated a hospital call and release plan; the driver’s ride did not arrive, and he declined another offered call. The Court held he received a reasonable opportunity and that officers were not required to transport him on those facts.

Accept reasonable assistance. If it fails, explain why and ask for the next feasible option. A person cannot manufacture denial by refusing the means officers provide.

Administrative and criminal remedies should both be preserved

An independent-test denial may affect a criminal prosecution and an NDDOT over-limit suspension. Raise it timely in each forum, obtain the agency record, and meet the ten-day hearing request and seven-day judicial-review deadlines.

Do not assume a criminal suppression order automatically changes an administrative decision. Make the evidence and legal argument in the forum that must decide it.

The defense should investigate the request as carefully as the test

Preserve all recordings and logs

Request squad, body, testing-room, booking, jail, lobby, hospital, and telephone recordings; dispatch and custody logs; call detail; visitor and release records; reports; notes; written advisories; chemical-test records; and facility communications. Send preservation notices before routine deletion.

Collect the client’s phone records, family messages, rideshare history, payment attempts, hospital calls, and witness accounts. Independent evidence can prove the effort even when police video ends at booking.

Interview every person who heard the request

Identify the arresting officer, testing operator, booking staff, correctional officers, dispatchers, lawyers, family, transport providers, hospital staff, and anyone else contacted. Ask for actual words and normal practices without feeding the legal conclusion.

Routine-practice testimony can matter, as Bowen illustrates. Test whether the claimed practice is documented, consistently trained, and actually followed that night.

Reconstruct what testing was realistically available

Contact the proposed facility about offense-date hours, forensic collection policy, required orders, qualified staff, payment, police custody, test kits, transport, laboratory routing, turnaround, and retention. Determine whether a mobile collector or alternative facility existed.

A current policy may differ from the policy on the arrest date. Seek records and a knowledgeable witness rather than relying on a receptionist’s present recollection.

Build a minute-by-minute chronology

Include driving, stop, arrest, officer test, independent request, every call, custody transfer, proposed transport, release authorization, actual release, facility arrival, collection, and analysis. Mark unexplained gaps and who controlled the person during each one.

Overlay the expected alcohol or drug evidence change. The same one-hour delay may matter differently for a near-threshold alcohol case and a long-window urine metabolite issue.

Retain the right expert for the actual dispute

A forensic toxicologist can compare specimens, timing, units, methods, and uncertainty. A breath-testing expert can analyze the Intoxilyzer record. A laboratory-quality expert can address validation or controls. A medical witness may explain collection feasibility or drug pharmacology.

Give the expert the full record, including unfavorable facts. Ask what a timely additional sample could have shown and whether delay destroyed the ability to answer the disputed question.

File a fact-specific motion

Identify the completed officer-directed chemical test, quote the independent request, explain why it was clear, list the practical arrangements, prove police interference, show available testing, quantify the lost time, and connect the denial to the requested remedy.

Address Williams, Bowen, and Koenig directly. Distinguish ordinary failure or inability from state-caused denial. A motion built around the statute’s sequence and the exact recording is stronger than an abstract fairness argument.

Use the independent result carefully at negotiation and trial

Authenticate the collection and report, resolve matrix and unit differences, comply with expert-disclosure rules, and anticipate cross-examination about timing, payment, laboratory selection, and inconsistent results. Independence does not exempt evidence from foundation.

If the result helps, explain precisely what it proves. If it is mixed, use it to narrow the dispute without overstating it. If it is harmful, analyze discovery obligations and trial strategy ethically before deciding whether and how it affects resolution.

Frequently asked questions about independent DUI testing in North Dakota

Do I have a right to a second DUI test in North Dakota?

After you complete the chemical test directed by law enforcement, § 39-20-02 permits an additional test by a qualified person of your choosing at your expense. The right does not replace the officer’s selected test.

Does taking the roadside PBT give me the independent-test right?

No. City of West Fargo v. Williams holds that preliminary screening is not the chemical test that activates § 39-20-02.

Can I refuse the police breath test and demand my own blood test?

Not under § 39-20-02. The additional-test right arises after submission to the officer-directed chemical test. Refusal can create separate criminal and license consequences.

Must police tell me I can get an independent test?

North Dakota precedent does not impose a general duty to advise every tested driver of § 39-20-02. Once a clear request is made, police may not unreasonably interfere.

How clear does my request need to be?

State v. Bowen requires a clear and unambiguous request. State that you completed the officer’s chemical test and want an additional independent chemical test under § 39-20-02.

Should I ask for blood, breath, or urine?

The best choice depends on the government’s sample, suspected substance, time, provider availability, and forensic question. Whole blood is often useful for alcohol and drug confirmation, but professional advice is valuable.

Who pays for the independent test?

The charged person bears the cost under § 39-20-02, including collection, analysis, transportation, and related charges.

Must police drive me to the hospital?

Not always. Koenig found no transportation duty where officers facilitated a hospital call and release to a sober adult. Continued custody, available alternatives, and the total circumstances can change the analysis.

Must police give me a phone?

A reasonable opportunity to arrange testing often requires communication access. Whether denial of a phone violates the right depends on the clear request, custody, alternatives, timing, and total circumstances.

What if the hospital refuses to draw blood?

Ask why, document the refusal, and promptly seek another qualified option if possible. A private facility’s unavailability is not automatically police interference.

Can a later lower result prove the police test was wrong?

Not by itself. Alcohol may decline over time, and sample type, units, method, and uncertainty differ. A toxicologist should compare the results and timing.

What if the later result is higher?

It may support continuing absorption, but only after accounting for specimen differences, timing, food, drinking history, and measurement uncertainty. It is not automatic proof of a lower driving-time concentration.

Can I independently test for drugs?

Yes, but the order, tubes, volume, panel, confirmatory method, and retention must be planned. An alcohol-only collection or routine hospital screen may not answer the drug question.

Can my lawyer retest the State’s sample instead?

Retesting a preserved State specimen may be possible and useful, but it differs from collecting a second specimen soon after arrest. Ask for preservation and access immediately.

What happens if police block the test?

When police deny a clear and reasonable effort, the defense may seek suppression of the government result or dismissal, depending on the facts and prejudice. Ordinary failure or inability does not automatically exclude the State’s test.

Does a denial affect the NDDOT case?

It can. Preserve the issue in the administrative hearing as well as criminal court. The NDDOT hearing request is generally due within ten days after permit issuance.

What records should be preserved?

Preserve every video and audio recording, jail and phone logs, reports, testing records, release and transport material, hospital communications, payment attempts, collection and chain documents, raw laboratory data, and witness information.

What should the independent-test motion prove?

It should prove completion of the officer’s chemical test, a clear request, diligent arrangements, realistic test availability, police interference, time-sensitive evidence loss, and the legal basis for suppression or dismissal.

Legal update note: This guide reflects North Dakota statutes and reported decisions reviewed through November 5, 2026. Testing methods, facility policies, and case law can change. The offense-date law and recorded circumstances control.


Call nowChoose a time