Fargo Soliciting Obstruction of Proceedings Defense
North Dakota’s soliciting-obstruction statute is one sentence long, but a proper defense analysis is not. N.D.C.C. § 12.1-10-06 makes it a Class A…
North Dakota Soliciting Obstruction of Proceedings Defense Guide
Fargo Soliciting Obstruction of Proceedings Defense
North Dakota’s soliciting-obstruction statute is one sentence long, but a proper defense analysis is not. N.D.C.C. § 12.1-10-06 makes it a Class A misdemeanor to solicit another person to commit any offense defined in §§ 12.1-10-02 through 12.1-10-05. Those incorporated statutes cover four different subjects: failing to appear or produce information, refusing to testify, hindering an official proceeding through disorderly conduct, and disobeying a judicial order.
A charge therefore cannot be evaluated from the word “soliciting” alone. The State should identify the particular underlying offense, the request or attempted persuasion, the accused’s culpability, the status of the proceeding or order, and the facts that would make the requested conduct criminal. Asking someone to reschedule with the court, assert a lawful privilege, seek to quash a subpoena, comply through counsel, or obey an order as reasonably understood is not the same as urging a crime.
This guide explains the current statute, North Dakota’s default willfulness rule, each incorporated offense, communications and digital evidence, defenses, search issues, sentencing, and relevant official decisions. It is general information, not legal advice about a particular case.
The Statutory Framework
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-10-06 provides: “A person is guilty of a class A misdemeanor if the person solicits another to commit an offense defined in sections 12.1-10-02 through 12.1-10-05.” The quoted text is short enough to read as a whole. It does not create a general crime of asking someone to behave badly around a case. It incorporates a closed list of offenses.
The State must identify an incorporated offense
The charging document should permit the accused to understand which of the four statutes supplies the criminal object. A defense to solicitation of failure to honor a subpoena differs from a defense to solicitation of courtroom disruption. Each underlying statute has its own status, conduct, culpability, privilege, order, and defense requirements. Combining them into a generic allegation can obscure what must be proved and impair preparation.
The solicited act must amount to the identified offense
A request does not become criminal merely because it concerns a witness, hearing, or court order. The requested conduct must fall within §§ 12.1-10-02, -03, -04, or -05. If the other person was never lawfully ordered to appear, had a lawful privilege, was asked to use an authorized procedure, did not face an official proceeding, or was not subject to the judicial order, the alleged object may not match the incorporated offense.
Section 12.1-10-06 is not the general felony-solicitation statute
North Dakota separately defines criminal solicitation in N.D.C.C. § 12.1-06-03. That provision addresses persuasion to commit a particular felony, requires intent to promote or facilitate it, circumstances strongly corroborative of that intent, and an overt act by the person solicited. The obstruction offenses incorporated by § 12.1-10-06 are misdemeanors. The specific obstruction provision exists in a different chapter and does not recite all of § 12.1-06-03’s conditions. A lawyer should not automatically import every general-solicitation element into § 12.1-10-06 or erase the default culpability rules that apply to the specific text.
Default culpability is willfully
Section 12.1-10-06 does not expressly state a mental state and does not declare strict liability. Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-02-02(2), a Title 12.1 offense that specifies no culpability ordinarily requires willfulness. “Willfully” includes intentional, knowing, or reckless conduct. In State v. Luetzen, 2026 ND 13, ¶ 6, the Court reiterated that Title 12.1 supplies this default when an offense in the criminal code states no culpability. Application to the charged facts and jury instructions deserves close attention.
Classification and maximum penalty
Soliciting obstruction of proceedings is a Class A misdemeanor. The current general ceiling is 360 days of imprisonment, a $3,000 fine, or both. If the alleged object is disobedience of a judicial order, § 12.1-10-05 separately permits a fine in any amount deemed just for the person who disobeys or resists the order. Whether that special fine provision applies to a § 12.1-10-06 solicitation conviction is a statutory question that should not be assumed from the allegation alone.
Soliciting Hindrance by Disorderly Conduct
Section 12.1-10-04 criminalizes hindering an official proceeding by noise or violent or tumultuous behavior or disturbance. Intentional hindrance is a Class A misdemeanor; reckless hindrance is a Class B misdemeanor. Section 12.1-10-06 nevertheless classifies soliciting an offense defined in § 12.1-10-04 as a Class A misdemeanor. The complaint should identify whether the alleged criminal object was intentional or reckless hindrance and what conduct was requested.
There must be an official proceeding
The State should establish the proceeding, its location, its status at the relevant time, and how the requested behavior would affect it. Noise outside a courthouse after business hours is not automatically hindrance of an official proceeding. A hearing conducted remotely can be hindered, but the State must connect the requested conduct to the proceeding rather than to generalized annoyance.
Hindrance is more than disapproval
Peaceful observation, criticism, protest, or use of an authorized objection does not necessarily hinder a proceeding. The incorporated statute identifies noise, violent or tumultuous behavior, or disturbance and requires actual hindrance. Soliciting lawful protest is different from soliciting a disruption intended to stop witnesses from being heard.
Intentional and reckless alternatives
If the object is intentional hindrance, the requested actor’s purpose to hinder matters. If the object is reckless hindrance, the alleged conduct must involve conscious and clearly unjustifiable disregard of a substantial likelihood, with a gross deviation from acceptable standards. A vague suggestion to “make your voice heard” does not automatically establish either alternative.
Protected speech and unprotected disruption
Courts may regulate conduct to preserve order, but the First Amendment protects speech and assembly. The analysis should distinguish message content from noise, violence, or disruption. In another disorderly-conduct setting, State v. Vetter, 2025 ND 197, ¶¶ 7–14, discussed protected activity, contextual conduct, and proof of culpability. That decision does not define § 12.1-10-04, but it demonstrates why the conduct and mental state should be separated.
Soliciting Disobedience of a Judicial Order
Section 12.1-10-05 applies when a person disobeys or resists a lawful temporary restraining order, preliminary or final injunction, or another final order—other than an order for payment of money—issued by a North Dakota court. A solicitation charge premised on this statute demands careful review of the written order and the person allegedly asked to violate it.
The order must be one the statute covers
Not every judicial instruction is a temporary restraining order, injunction, or final order. The State should identify the document, issuing court, date, scope, finality where relevant, and nonmonetary obligation. A request to delay payment under a money judgment falls outside the express text of § 12.1-10-05, although other remedies may exist.
The order must be lawful
Lawfulness is part of the incorporated offense. That does not generally authorize private defiance whenever a person believes a judge was wrong. Proper remedies may include clarification, reconsideration, appeal, or a stay. But the State should not ask a jury to assume lawfulness without producing the order and legal setting.
Notice and scope are central factual issues
The accused’s request must be evaluated against what the bound person knew and what the order actually prohibited. A no-contact order may define direct and indirect contact; an injunction may name particular property or conduct; a final order may contain exceptions. Paraphrasing it from memory can expand the order beyond its terms. The defense should obtain the signed order, service record, hearing transcript, later modifications, and any written clarification.
Advice to challenge an order is not advice to violate it
Encouraging someone to consult counsel, seek a stay, appeal, move to modify, or request permission is not the same as soliciting disobedience. Messages such as “you do not have to accept this without a challenge” must be read with the next instruction. The complete exchange may show lawful procedural advice rather than a request for defiance.
Evidence in a Soliciting-Obstruction Case
Complete messages and recordings
Text messages, email, social-media exchanges, jail calls, recorded meetings, voicemails, and witness testimony can supply the alleged solicitation. Complete conversations matter because qualifications, objections, and lawful alternatives may appear before or after the sentence the State selected. Native files and provider returns can also establish timestamps, participants, delivery, edits, and attachments.
Identity and attribution
A display name or phone number does not invariably identify the speaker. Devices and accounts may be shared, compromised, spoofed, or used by another person. The State may rely on admissions, subscriber records, distinctive facts, device extractions, login information, voice identification, or witnesses. The defense should test the link rather than concede authorship from appearance alone.
The underlying subpoena, question, proceeding, or order
The source documents are indispensable. Counsel should obtain the subpoena and return, transcript, exhibit request, privilege ruling, hearing notice, injunction, restraining order, final order, and modifications. Without them, neither side can reliably decide whether the solicited conduct would violate one of the four incorporated statutes.
Chronology and response
A timeline should show when the accused learned of the proceeding or order, when the alleged request occurred, how the recipient responded, whether counsel was involved, and what happened next. A later lawful filing may corroborate an innocent interpretation. A secret payment followed by nonappearance may support the State. Neither should be evaluated without the full record.
Authentication and evidentiary foundation
State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 12–18, addresses authentication of digital evidence. Authentication is a threshold question and does not settle authorship, meaning, or weight. The defense should identify who captured an exhibit, whether the original remains available, and whether the proposed evidence accurately presents the entire exchange.
Defense Analysis
No solicitation occurred
The accused may have described legal options, repeated another person’s idea, asked a neutral question, vented, or advised compliance. The State must prove more than a conversation about the case. Exact language, tone, relationship, and surrounding acts can create reasonable doubt about whether there was any request or attempted persuasion.
No willful culpability
Because the specific statute does not state a mental state, Title 12.1’s willfulness default is important. An accidental transmission, misunderstood remark, or good-faith belief that the requested act was authorized may negate the required culpability depending on the facts. In Luetzen, the Court emphasized that the statutory text and applicable culpability rules must be read together rather than replaced by labels.
The requested conduct was lawful
A person may ask a witness to consult counsel, invoke a valid privilege, seek accommodation, request a continuance, challenge a subpoena, appeal an order, or use another authorized process. If the request was for lawful conduct, the object was not an offense under §§ 12.1-10-02 through -05.
No lawful order or covered proceeding
The subpoena may be invalid, service may be disputed, the question may not be pertinent, the required warning may never have occurred, the event may not qualify as an official proceeding, or the order may fall outside § 12.1-10-05. The prosecution cannot prove solicitation of a listed offense by omitting the facts that make the object criminal.
Lawful privilege
Sections 12.1-10-02 and -03 expressly recognize lawful privilege. The privilege must actually apply and may require a ruling. A request to assert it is not automatically obstruction. Counsel should document the privilege basis, the tribunal’s ruling, any immunity order, and the witness’s later compliance.
Statutory defense based on timely compliance
The failure-to-appear and refusal-to-testify statutes contain defenses for compliance before the earlier failure or refusal substantially affected the proceeding. If the recipient appeared, produced the material, accepted the oath, or answered in time, the defense should trace the exact point at which the proceeding was allegedly affected.
Ambiguity and incomplete context
Ambiguous words cannot be converted into a criminal request simply by selecting the most incriminating interpretation. The defense can use prior conversations, ordinary practices, later lawful steps, and recipient testimony to establish another reasonable meaning. Translation issues, speech-to-text errors, and missing attachments also deserve attention.
Entrapment
Entrapment can arise when law enforcement or an agent induces an offense by methods creating a substantial risk that the offense would be committed by a person not otherwise ready to commit it. Merely providing an opportunity is not enough. Recorded exchanges, informant instructions, benefits, pressure, and the accused’s earlier conduct determine whether the defense has factual support.
Multiplicity, merger, and related charges
The State may charge solicitation alongside attempted obstruction, conspiracy, witness tampering, order violation, or a completed underlying offense. Counsel should compare statutory elements, the alleged acts, units of prosecution, and North Dakota merger rules. In State v. Cotton, 2025 ND 191, ¶¶ 6–8, the Court discussed misdemeanor sentencing merger and the relationship between preparatory and completed offenses. The exact counts and conduct control.
Suppression of digital evidence
A warrant for a phone or cloud account must establish probable cause and a nexus to the data sought. State v. Quam, 2026 ND 145, ¶¶ 9–18, examines nexus in a digital-search setting. Counsel should review the affidavit, warrant, date range, categories searched, return, extraction, and later use of unrelated information.
Investigation, Charging, and Sentencing
Charging precision
The complaint or information should provide fair notice of the essential facts. A useful charge identifies the person solicited, approximate communication, incorporated statute, proceeding or order, and criminal object. A generic allegation tracking only § 12.1-10-06 may leave uncertainty about which of several materially different offenses the defense must meet.
Interviews
An investigator may present one line from a message and invite the accused to explain. A spontaneous answer can establish authorship, knowledge, or meaning without access to the full conversation or source order. A person has the right to remain silent and ask for counsel. Preserving the device while declining an unprepared interview does not establish guilt.
Do not create a second allegation
After learning of an investigation, do not contact the recipient to coordinate accounts, ask for deletion, pressure a witness, or violate an order. Preserve everything. New contact can be misinterpreted or become separate evidence even if the original communication was innocent.
Sentencing factors
The Class A misdemeanor maximum is not the expected sentence. Courts may consider the seriousness and persistence of the request, harm or delay to the proceeding, whether money or threats were used, criminal history, acceptance of responsibility, treatment needs, and lawful mitigation. Probation conditions may restrict contact or require compliance with existing orders.
Collateral consequences
A conviction involving interference with courts can affect professional licenses, government employment, security-sensitive work, immigration analysis, reputation, and future credibility. Lawyers and regulated professionals may face separate disciplinary review. Those consequences should be considered before plea decisions, not after sentencing.
Using Official Decisions Accurately
Published North Dakota appellate decisions squarely construing § 12.1-10-06 appear limited. The statutory text and the elements of the incorporated offense are therefore the starting point. Decisions from other contexts can explain culpability, digital proof, warrants, charging, and merger, but they should not be presented as though they created elements for this offense.
- State v. Luetzen, 2026 ND 13, ¶¶ 5–6 — statutory text and Title 12.1’s default culpability rule.
- State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8, ¶¶ 18–29 — charging amendments and the limited reach of § 12.1-02-02 outside Title 12.1.
- State v. Vetter, 2025 ND 197, ¶¶ 7–14 — protected activity and circumstantial proof of culpability in a different disorderly-conduct setting.
- State v. Cotton, 2025 ND 191, ¶¶ 6–8 — misdemeanor sentencing merger and preparatory offenses.
- State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 12–18 — authentication of digital evidence.
- State v. Quam, 2026 ND 145, ¶¶ 9–18 — probable cause and nexus for digital searches.
- State v. Rolland, 2024 ND 175, ¶¶ 15–25 — procedure and scope in reviewing a phone warrant.
- State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 12–21 — evidentiary foundation and review of digital communications.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is soliciting obstruction of proceedings in North Dakota?
It is willfully soliciting another person to commit an offense defined in N.D.C.C. §§ 12.1-10-02 through -05: specified failures involving witnesses or information, refusal to testify, hindering a proceeding by disorderly conduct, or disobedience of a covered judicial order.
Is it a felony?
No. Section 12.1-10-06 classifies the offense as a Class A misdemeanor. Related conduct may support separate charges with different classifications.
What is the maximum penalty?
The current Class A misdemeanor ceiling is 360 days in jail, a $3,000 fine, or both. The actual result depends on the evidence, resolution, history, and sentencing factors.
Must the other person actually obstruct the proceeding?
The specific statute focuses on solicitation and does not expressly require success. What the accused requested and whether it was a listed criminal offense remain essential.
Must the other person agree?
Section 12.1-10-06 does not expressly require agreement. A refusal or lack of response may still be important evidence about the meaning and context of the alleged request.
Is telling a witness to hire a lawyer obstruction?
No. Advising someone to obtain counsel is lawful. The issue is whether the accused solicited an actual offense, not whether legal advice complicated an investigation.
Can a witness assert the Fifth Amendment?
A valid privilege may be asserted through proper procedure. Sections 12.1-10-02 and -03 expressly refer to lawful privilege. A court may need to decide its scope and whether immunity changes the answer.
Can someone ask to quash or modify a subpoena?
Yes. Seeking lawful relief is different from ignoring a subpoena. The request, timing, court ruling, and later compliance matter.
What counts as an official proceeding?
The statute includes specified court, grand-jury, legislative, court-ordered, and authorized-agency proceedings, plus proceedings expressly made subject to the section.
Can peaceful protest be charged?
Peaceful protected activity is not automatically hindering. Section 12.1-10-04 requires actual hindrance by noise, violent or tumultuous behavior, or disturbance, with the specified culpability.
Can advice to appeal a court order be solicitation?
Advice to appeal, seek a stay, request clarification, or move to modify is not the same as advice to disobey. The complete communication should show which was proposed.
What if the order was unclear?
Ambiguity may affect whether the requested conduct amounted to disobedience and whether the accused acted willfully. Obtain the signed order, transcript, service record, and modifications.
Can text messages be used as evidence?
Yes, if properly obtained and authenticated. The State still must prove authorship, completeness, meaning, culpability, and the underlying criminal object.
Can police search a phone?
They may seek a warrant, but it must establish probable cause and a nexus to the device or account and describe the search with lawful particularity.
What evidence should be preserved?
Preserve complete messages, original devices, call records, subpoenas, orders, transcripts, hearing notices, privilege communications, calendars, and witness names. Do not delete or edit anything.
Should the accused contact the recipient to explain?
No. New contact can worsen the situation or violate an order. Preserve the record and consult counsel before communicating.
What It Means to Solicit Another Person
A request, command, inducement, or attempted persuasion
In ordinary legal usage, solicitation involves seeking to persuade, induce, command, request, or encourage another person to engage in prohibited conduct. The exact words are important. “Ignore the subpoena” differs from “call the clerk and ask whether the hearing can be moved.” “Do not answer even if the judge orders you” differs from “tell your lawyer you intend to invoke the Fifth Amendment.” The State should prove the communication actually conveyed the alleged request rather than rely on a witness’s conclusion that someone “wanted the case stopped.”
The request must be tied to a particular criminal object
The more ambiguous the message, the harder it may be to prove what was solicited. A statement such as “take care of this” can mean lawful preparation, scheduling, document collection, negotiation, or criminal interference. Context may clarify it, but context must come from reliable evidence. The identity of the recipient, the pending matter, follow-up acts, and the accused’s knowledge can support or undermine the State’s reading.
Agreement is not stated as an element
Section 12.1-10-06 punishes the solicitation. Its text does not say the other person must agree, commit the offense, or succeed. That distinguishes solicitation from conspiracy and from completed obstruction. An immediate refusal by the recipient may be powerful context but does not necessarily end the element analysis. At the same time, the absence of any response can make an ambiguous statement harder to interpret.
Lawful advice and advocacy
A lawyer, friend, advocate, or family member may lawfully advise a person to consult counsel, assert a valid privilege, request accommodation, challenge a subpoena, appeal an order, seek a stay, or comply through authorized means. The line is not whether advice makes the government’s work more difficult. It is whether the accused willfully solicited conduct that actually constitutes one of the listed crimes.
Words must be evaluated in context
Jokes, anger, exaggeration, quotation, hypotheticals, and conditional statements can be misunderstood in text. Conversely, coded language may communicate a clear request when read against a shared history. The defense should obtain the full thread, earlier messages, attachments, in-person context, and later conduct rather than litigating a single sentence selected by an investigator.
Soliciting Failure to Appear, Produce Information, or Be Sworn
Section 12.1-10-02 contains more than one form of conduct. It covers a person lawfully ordered to appear at a specified time and place to testify or produce information in an official proceeding who, without lawful privilege, fails to appear or produce it. It also covers a person attending an official proceeding who, without lawful privilege, fails to obey a lawful order to occupy or remain at the designated witness location, or to be sworn or make an equivalent affirmation.
A lawful order is foundational
The State should establish the order, its issuing authority, service or notice, specified time and place, and what testimony or information it required. A defective subpoena, informal request, ambiguous date, or order directed to someone else may not satisfy the incorporated offense. Solicitation evidence cannot cure a missing lawful-order element.
Official proceeding is defined
For §§ 12.1-10-02 and -03, an official proceeding includes proceedings before a North Dakota judge, court, magistrate, or grand jury; the Legislative Assembly or a session or interim committee; a proceeding in which a court lawfully orders attendance or production; a proceeding before an authorized agency; and another proceeding expressly made subject to the section. A private meeting or informal interview is not automatically an official proceeding.
Information means tangible objects
The statute defines information as a book, paper, document, record, or other tangible object. Modern disputes may involve electronically stored records, but the actual subpoena language, possession or control, production method, and governing rules matter. An inability to produce something that does not exist or is not controlled by the witness is different from willful nonproduction.
Lawful privilege matters
The underlying offense applies only when the person acts without lawful privilege. Attorney-client privilege, the privilege against self-incrimination, spousal privileges, statutory confidentiality, and other protections have specific limits and procedures. Asking a witness to assert a privilege that counsel reasonably believes applies is different from telling the witness to fabricate a privilege or disregard a final ruling.
Express statutory defenses
Section 12.1-10-02 provides defenses when the person was prevented from appearing or unable to produce information because of circumstances the person did not recklessly help create, and when the person complied before the failure substantially affected the proceeding. Those provisions are important to the solicitation charge because a request directed toward conduct covered by a defense may not have the criminal object the State alleges.
Soliciting Refusal to Testify
Section 12.1-10-03 applies when a person, without lawful privilege, refuses to answer a pertinent question in an official proceeding and continues after the specified authority directs the person to answer and warns that continued refusal may result in criminal prosecution. The identity of that authority differs by setting.
Legislative proceedings
Before the Legislative Assembly or one of its session or interim committees, the presiding officer must direct the witness to answer and advise that continued refusal may lead to criminal prosecution. A preliminary objection or request for clarification before that direction is not the same as the completed offense described by the statute.
Other official proceedings
In another official proceeding, a court or judge must direct or order the answer and provide the statutory warning. A lawyer’s demand, investigator’s question, or agency employee’s insistence may not satisfy that requirement unless the actual statutory conditions are met. The record should show the question, ruling, direction, warning, and continued refusal.
The question must be pertinent
Pertinence connects the question to the subject under inquiry. A witness may object that a question is irrelevant, overbroad, privileged, or beyond lawful authority. A judge or presiding officer may resolve the objection. The solicitation case should not treat a disputed question as automatically pertinent without examining the proceeding and ruling.
Compliance before substantial effect is a defense
It is a statutory defense that the witness complied before the refusal substantially affected the proceeding. If the accused allegedly encouraged an initial refusal but then urged compliance, the chronology can materially alter the case. Transcripts and recordings are often better evidence than summaries written after the hearing.