Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Fargo Promoting or Directing an Obscene Sexual Performance by a Minor Defense

North Dakota makes it a Class A felony knowingly to produce, direct, or promote an obscene performance that includes sexual conduct by a person who was a…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota Obscene Sexual Performance by a Minor Defense Guide

Fargo Promoting or Directing an Obscene Sexual Performance by a Minor Defense

North Dakota makes it a Class A felony knowingly to produce, direct, or promote an obscene performance that includes sexual conduct by a person who was a minor when the performance occurred. This charge under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-03 contains an additional element that the neighboring Class B felony for promoting a sexual performance does not: the State must prove obscenity under North Dakota’s three-part statutory test.

That difference matters. A visual depiction may be offensive, illegal under another section, or a sexual performance without being obscene as the law defines the term. The prosecution must prove that the work taken as a whole predominantly appeals to prurient interest under contemporary North Dakota standards, depicts sexual conduct in a patently offensive manner, and lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value when taken as a whole. The State must also prove the accused knew the performance’s character and content and actually produced, directed, or promoted it.

This guide explains every element, the obscenity test, the unusually broad definition of “promote,” current computer-generated-image provisions, digital evidence, affirmative defenses, registration, and case strategy. It is general information, not legal advice about a particular matter.

Elements of N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-03

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-03 provides that a person commits a Class A felony if, knowing the character and content of a performance, the person produces, directs, or promotes an obscene performance that includes sexual conduct by someone who was a minor at the time of the performance.

The State’s required proof

The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt: identity; knowing character and content; production, direction, or promotion; an obscene performance under the incorporated obscenity definition; sexual conduct as chapter 12.1-27.2 defines it; and minor status at the time of the performance. If the State charges several counts, it must connect each count to an identifiable act or legally permitted unit.

Class A felony

Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-01, a Class A felony ordinarily carries up to twenty years’ imprisonment, a $20,000 fine, or both. The chapter also carries registration and potentially special commercial fines.

Comparison with § 12.1-27.2-04

Section 12.1-27.2-04 makes knowing production, direction, or promotion of any performance including sexual conduct by a person who was then a minor a Class B felony. Section 12.1-27.2-03 raises the offense to Class A by requiring the performance to be obscene. The two statutes should not be blended: the jury must decide the added obscenity element for the greater charge.

Comparison with use and possession

Use of a minor under § 12.1-27.2-02 focuses on employing, authorizing, inducing, certain caregiver consent, or an adult’s deceptive portrayal. Possession under § 12.1-27.2-04.1 focuses on knowing control of specified material. Promotion can include a single transfer or exhibition even if the accused did not create or retain the performance.

Offense-date law

The chapter has changed significantly, including offense classification, definitions, affirmative defenses, possession enhancements, and computer-generated imagery. Apply the statute effective when the alleged production, direction, or promotion occurred. The date a file was created may differ from the date it was sent, posted, or displayed.

What It Means to Produce, Direct, or Promote

Produces

Production can include creating or manufacturing the performance. Evidence may involve operating a camera, arranging a scene, recording, photographing, editing, rendering, generating, or assembling a visual representation. Ownership of the final file is evidence but does not necessarily identify who created it.

Metadata, application databases, project files, camera identifiers, source media, editing history, cloud logs, account records, and witness testimony can establish or contradict production. Re-encoding, screenshots, platform compression, and reposting can remove or alter metadata, so an absence of creation data is not automatically conclusive.

Directs

Direction can include controlling or instructing the performance. Messages about pose, clothing, camera angle, conduct, lighting, duration, retakes, or audience may be relevant. The State should prove that the directions concerned the qualifying sexual conduct and performance, not merely that the accused discussed an existing image.

Promotes

Chapter 12.1-27.2 defines “promote” broadly to include procuring, manufacturing, issuing, selling, giving, providing, lending, mailing, delivering, transferring, transmitting, shipping, transporting, publishing, distributing, circulating, disseminating, presenting, exhibiting, or advertising. One deliberate digital transmission can fall within the text.

The breadth of the definition makes attribution and knowledge especially important. An automatic cloud backup, unsolicited group-message download, platform preview, malware transmission, shared-folder synchronization, or service-provider routing is not necessarily a knowing act by the accused. The State should identify the specific promotion verb and user action.

Procurement and receipt

Because “promote” includes procure, the State may argue that requesting or obtaining a performance is promotion even without a later forward. The evidence should show what was requested, whether the material was obtained, who controlled the account, and whether the accused knew its character and content.

Presentation and exhibition

Showing a performance to another person can constitute promotion. The State should prove the display was deliberate, the material was visible as claimed, and the accused knew what it contained. A pop-up, accidental screen share, mistaken thumbnail, or unanticipated autoplay may present a different mental-state question.

Each count needs an act

A folder may hold many files and a conversation may contain several transfers. The prosecution should explain whether counts correspond to performances, transmissions, dates, recipients, or another statutory unit. Multiplicity can expose a defendant to unauthorized cumulative punishment and should be raised before trial.

The Three-Part North Dakota Obscenity Test

An “obscene sexual performance” under § 12.1-27.2-01 incorporates the definition of obscene material or performance in N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.1-01(5). All three requirements must be satisfied. The work is considered as a whole for the first and third.

Predominant appeal to prurient interest

Taken as a whole, the average person applying contemporary North Dakota standards must find the performance predominantly appeals to a prurient interest. The statute defines prurient interest as a voyeuristic, lascivious, degrading, shameful, or morbid interest in nudity, sex, or excretion that goes substantially beyond customary limits of candor.

“Predominantly” and “taken as a whole” prevent the State from isolating one frame or moment while ignoring the complete work. The full video, image set, conversation, sequence, caption, and intended presentation may matter. A cropped exhibit can distort context.

Patently offensive depiction or description

The performance must depict or describe sexual conduct in a patently offensive manner. Section 12.1-27.1-01 defines “patently offensive” as so offensive on its face as to affront contemporary North Dakota standards of decency. The jury must apply the statutory standard, not merely personal shock or dislike.

Lack of serious value

Taken as a whole, a reasonable person must find the performance lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value. A performance with genuine serious value is not obscene under this definition even if it contains nudity or sexual subject matter and offends many viewers.

Serious value is not decided solely by local popularity. Context, purpose, provenance, professional use, artistic structure, educational setting, scientific content, and qualified testimony can matter. A claimed value should be genuine and applied to the full work rather than invented after seizure.

Audience reference

The statute says obscenity is ordinarily judged with reference to adults. If the character of the material or circumstances of dissemination show it was designed for minors or another specially susceptible audience, it is judged with reference to that audience. The State should identify why the special-audience rule applies.

Not every prohibited sexual performance is obscene

Chapter 12.1-27.2 protects minors without requiring obscenity for its use, promotion, and possession offenses. That structure confirms that obscenity is meaningful additional proof under § 12.1-27.2-03. A court should not instruct that any sexual performance involving a minor is automatically obscene.

Expert testimony and the jury

Obscenity is ultimately determined under the legal test, but experts may address serious value, artistic or scientific context, technology, intended audience, provenance, or full-work meaning. Expert testimony should be disclosed properly and should not tell jurors merely how to vote.

Performance, Sexual Conduct, and the Complete Work

Performance under chapter 12.1-27.2

A performance includes a play, motion picture, photograph, dance, other visual representation, or any part of one. A still image can qualify. The offense still requires an obscene performance, sexual conduct, and minor status.

Actual or simulated sexual conduct

Sexual conduct includes actual or simulated intercourse, sodomy, sexual bestiality, masturbation, sadomasochistic abuse, lewd exhibition of buttocks, breasts, or genitals, certain sexualized nude or partially denuded figures, and physical contact with clothed or unclothed genitals, pubic area, buttocks, or breasts.

Purpose-based nudity provision

A nude or partially denuded figure falls within one alternative when depicted for sexual stimulation or gratification of any viewer. Ordinary family photographs, medical documentation, legitimate art, news, or educational material cannot be classified solely by the amount of visible skin. Purpose, composition, instructions, focal point, intended audience, captions, and surrounding communications matter.

Lewd exhibition

Lewdness requires more than anatomical visibility. Pose, camera angle, focal emphasis, setting, conduct, expression, direction, clothing, and sexual context can be relevant. The State should identify the exhibition and the basis for calling it lewd.

Physical contact through clothing

The current definition can include physical contact with specified body areas through clothing. The prosecution must still show that the contact was included in a performance, involved a minor under the chapter definition, and was part of an obscene work for § 12.1-27.2-03.

The minor need not understand

The chapter says it is unnecessary that the minor know the minor is participating in the described sexual conduct or any aspect of it. The State therefore may prosecute covert or manipulated depictions. The accused’s required knowledge remains an independent element.

Complete versus edited exhibits

Because two obscenity prongs require assessment “taken as a whole,” the defense should obtain the complete performance. Cropping, excerpting, frame selection, missing audio, compression, or omitted sequence can materially affect prurience, offensiveness, and serious value.

Knowing the Character and Content

The State must prove the accused knew the performance’s character and content. It is not enough to establish ownership of a phone, subscription to an account, or presence in a chat. Knowledge may be inferred, but the inference must be reasonable and tied to the accused.

Evidence supporting knowledge

Requests, instructions, replies, captions, payment, repeated transfers, file names, previews, viewing history, organization, editing, concealment, deletion, and admissions may support knowledge. The strength depends on reliable attribution and technical explanation.

Unsolicited and automated data

Group chats, platform suggestions, cached previews, automatic downloads, cloud synchronization, shared albums, spam, and malware can place files on a device without deliberate selection. A forensic report should distinguish active user files from caches, thumbnails, deleted fragments, and remote placeholders.

Knowledge of obscenity

The statute requires knowing character and content, not necessarily legal expertise or use of the word “obscene.” A person can know what a work depicts while disputing whether it satisfies the legal obscenity test. The jury should not treat a legal conclusion as an admission simply because the accused recognized sexual content.

Account attribution

Subscriber data identifies an account holder, not necessarily the user at a particular minute. Login IPs, device tokens, location, multifactor records, recovery information, payments, linked accounts, photographs, contacts, writing style, and admissions can strengthen or weaken attribution.

Corporate and employee roles

A business owner, platform worker, studio employee, or manager should not be held individually responsible solely because an organization possessed or transmitted content. North Dakota’s corporate and accomplice statutes, actual knowledge, authority, conduct, and the charged promotion verb require individualized proof.

Minor Status, Proof of Age, and Computer-Generated Images

Minor at the time of performance

The offense expressly requires that the depicted or participating person was a minor when the performance occurred. Age at later transmission is not the test. Creation date, birth date, identity, and whether a depiction was altered must be established.

Current chapter definition

Current § 12.1-27.2-01 defines “minor” as an individual under eighteen or a computer-generated image used, created, adapted, altered, or modified to appear to depict an individual under eighteen through face, likeness, or another distinguishing characteristic. This recent language makes source and offense date central.

Proof methods

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-06 permits proof through inspection of the minor, the photograph or motion picture, witness opinion based on appearance, expert opinion based on appearance, and other lawful methods. Birth, school, platform, and identity records may also be relevant when admissible.

Age estimation limitations

Appearance can be affected by development, makeup, filters, camera angle, image quality, editing, and individual variation. An expert should disclose methodology, source material, limitations, and degree of certainty. The affirmative defense based on reasonable age belief is separate from whether the State proves actual minor status.

AI, face swaps, and altered material

A file may depict a real minor, an adult altered to look younger, a composite, a face swap, or a wholly synthetic figure. Source files, metadata, generation logs, editing history, model artifacts, cloud records, and expert analysis may be needed. A reposted screenshot can strip critical provenance.

Statutory-construction issues remain

Including computer-generated images in the minor definition does not eliminate other elements. The State still must prove a performance, sexual conduct, obscenity, knowledge, and production, direction, or promotion. The application of a human-oriented phrase such as “person who was a minor at the time of the performance” to synthetic imagery may require careful legal briefing.

Digital and Forensic Evidence

Warrants and scope

Device and account warrants should establish probable cause, nexus, particularity, relevant data categories, and a defensible time period. The defense should compare the affidavit, warrant, extraction, search terms, and evidence actually used. Seizure authority is not unlimited authority to search every item forever.

Provider records

Messaging, social-media, cloud, telecom, and payment providers may supply account identifiers, messages, attachments, login history, IPs, device data, and preservation records. The meaning of fields, time zones, deletion, encryption, retention, and synchronization requires a knowledgeable foundation.

Forensic categories

Active files, deleted files, thumbnails, caches, unallocated fragments, cloud links, temporary files, and application databases are not equivalent. A report should show the source, location, hash, timestamps, access evidence, extraction method, and limitations. A hash match establishes data identity, not who knew of it.

Original performance and the whole-work requirement

Obscenity analysis demands the complete performance when available. The defense should seek original resolution, full duration, audio, related images, captions, project files, and surrounding context. Prosecutorial excerpts may be demonstrative but should not replace the work the jury must evaluate.

Authentication and hearsay

Messages and account records require authentication; repeated statements require hearsay analysis. State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 14–24, provides current authentication guidance. State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 8–26, explains why an investigator who merely received business records may not establish how their content was created and kept.

Expert evidence

Experts may address digital extraction, image authenticity, generation, editing, age estimation, artistic or scientific value, and platform behavior. State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108, ¶¶ 5–11, confirms that specialized opinions are expert testimony subject to disclosure.

Count chart

A defense chart should identify each alleged performance, file hash, source, date, promotion act, recipient, account, sexual-conduct category, obscenity basis, age proof, and applicable statute. This exposes duplicates, reposts, uncertain dates, and counts without a distinct act.

Defenses to Promoting or Directing an Obscene Sexual Performance

The performance is not obscene

The State may prove a sexual performance involving a minor without proving all three obscenity prongs. The full work may not predominantly appeal to prurient interest, may not be patently offensive under the statutory standard, or may have serious value. That can defeat § 12.1-27.2-03 even if a lesser or different charge remains disputed.

No production, direction, or promotion

Passive receipt, unsolicited content, or mere presence in a group may not prove the charged verb. The State should identify the user act that created, controlled, procured, transferred, presented, exhibited, or otherwise promoted the performance.

No knowledge of character and content

An unopened attachment, hidden file, automatic sync, cached thumbnail, shared device, or mislabeled content can create reasonable doubt about knowledge. Forensic location and access evidence matter.

Wrong user

Shared devices, compromised accounts, remote access, household cloud systems, recycled numbers, and multiple employees can undermine attribution. Subscriber status alone is not conclusive.

No qualifying sexual conduct

The depiction may be nonsexual nudity, lawful art, medical material, or ordinary conduct that does not fit the enumerated definition. The prosecution should identify the statutory alternative and supporting facts.

Actual-age and reasonable-belief defense

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-05(1) provides an affirmative defense when the accused reasonably and in good faith believed the person appearing was at least eighteen, if the person was actually at least fifteen. Profiles, identification, direct statements, contrary warnings, appearance, and context matter.

Bona fide purpose

Section 12.1-27.2-05(2) protects certain bona fide medical, scientific, educational, religious, governmental, judicial, or other appropriate dissemination or presentation by or to professionals or similarly interested persons. Legitimate law-enforcement, legal, medical, research, and educational handling should be documented carefully.

Offense-date and AI defense

The current synthetic-image definition may not apply to conduct predating its effective date. The State must prove when the charged promotion occurred and that the file fits the then-effective law. Uncertainty about provenance can also defeat proof under current law.

Unlawful search, statement, or evidence handling

A deficient warrant, search beyond scope, involuntary consent, unwarned custodial interrogation, broken chain, altered exhibit, undisclosed expert, hearsay, or missing original can support suppression, exclusion, or reasonable doubt.

Multiplicity and overlapping offenses

Several promotion verbs applied to the same performance and transmission do not necessarily authorize several punishments. The defense should compare § 12.1-27.2-03 with use, nonobscene promotion, possession, luring, and other counts under the same-elements and legislative-intent rules.

Penalty, Registration, Federal Risk, and Collateral Consequences

Twenty-year maximum

The Class A felony maximum is twenty years, with a fine up to $20,000. Sentencing may consider the number and nature of performances, age, production role, distribution, commercial conduct, coercion, criminal history, treatment, risk, acceptance of responsibility where appropriate, and other lawful factors.

Commercial fines

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-04.2 adds special fine provisions for conduct in a commercial or for-profit activity when the offender had ownership, control, managerial responsibility, or a financial interest other than wages. Second or subsequent offenses carry higher fine provisions.

Sex-offender registration

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-15 includes chapter 12.1-27.2 offenses in the sexual-offender definition. Registration affects residence, employment, school, travel, verification, and reporting. A registration violation can become a separate felony.

Interest of K.I.B., 2025 ND 157, ¶¶ 8–12, holds that the statute did not permit a juvenile court to excuse registration for a juvenile adjudicated under chapter 12.1-27.2. Registration should be treated as a central consequence before any plea.

Federal prosecution

Production, receipt, distribution, possession, enticement, and internet transmission can implicate federal statutes, some with mandatory minimum sentences. State and federal prosecutions can coexist. Device consent, statements, and plea strategy should be evaluated with federal exposure in mind.

Other consequences

A conviction can restrict contact with minors, devices, internet, residence, employment, professional licensing, education, travel, immigration, firearms, custody, foster or adoptive status, and housing. Pretrial release conditions may impose substantial restrictions before guilt is decided.

Official North Dakota Decisions Relevant to the Defense

State v. Wiese

State v. Wiese, 2024 ND 39, ¶¶ 10–13, upheld promoting and possession convictions based on messages seeking sexual material, account evidence, payment discussions, receipt, and admissions. It also applied invited error to a proposed jury instruction, emphasizing the need for correct and timely objections.

Interest of K.I.B.

Interest of K.I.B., 2025 ND 157, ¶¶ 8–12, holds that registration was mandatory for a juvenile adjudicated under chapter 12.1-27.2 under the governing statute.

State v. Henderson

State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 8–26, rejected business-record foundation supplied by an officer who lacked knowledge of how content was created and maintained. Platform and payment records need a qualified foundation.

State v. Burton

State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 14–24, addresses authentication and hearsay for a recorded communication. Similar issues arise with calls, voice messages, screen recordings, and captured disclosures.

State v. Ziegler

State v. Ziegler, 2025 ND 78, ¶¶ 8–13, illustrates the need for documentary foundation and personal knowledge. Investigator summaries cannot automatically replace admissible source data.

State v. Doyle

State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108, ¶¶ 5–11, requires disclosure of specialized opinion testimony. Image provenance, forensic extraction, age estimation, and serious-value testimony can be expert evidence.

State v. Smith

State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127, ¶ 8, restates the same-elements test relevant to overlapping obscene-promotion, nonobscene-promotion, possession, use, and solicitation counts.

State v. Olson

State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8, ¶ 27, discusses North Dakota’s culpability framework. Section 12.1-27.2-03 expressly requires knowledge of character and content, which should be applied to the identified performance and accused.

Fargo Investigation and Court Procedure

Preserve; do not browse or forward

Do not delete, reset, edit, forward, or display suspected material. Preserve devices and credentials and obtain legal advice. Unnecessary handling can alter metadata, create new promotion evidence, violate law, or compromise an independent examination.

Search and seizure

Obtain the affidavit, warrant, return, inventory, extraction reports, provider records, and chain documentation. Review probable cause, nexus, particularity, time limits, execution, and whether the examination exceeded authorization. Protective procedures can permit lawful defense review without uncontrolled reproduction.

First appearance and release

The court may restrict devices, internet, contact with minors, residence, employment, travel, firearms, and other activity. Follow the written order. A new contact or technical monitoring violation can lead to detention or additional charges.

Preliminary hearing

The hearing can identify the promotion verb, alleged performance, obscenity theory, sexual-conduct category, age evidence, account attribution, knowledge proof, and each count. Probable cause is lower than proof at trial, so investigation continues regardless of the result.

Discovery and experts

Discovery should include complete performances, original files, metadata, provider returns, messages, full extractions, hash lists, search history, project files, payment data, age proof, forensic methods, expert opinions, and all favorable evidence. Serious-value analysis may require a qualified subject-matter expert.

Motions

Pretrial motions may address warrant validity and scope, statements, authentication, business records, hearsay, experts, complete-work presentation, other acts, count multiplicity, joinder, statutory definitions, synthetic imagery, affirmative defenses, obscenity instructions, and protective handling.

Plea and trial

A plea must address the exact act, Class A range, registration, federal risk, supervision, internet and contact restrictions, treatment, immigration, licensing, and family consequences. At trial, the State must prove every element, including all three obscenity prongs; moral condemnation cannot replace legal proof.

Sentencing and restitution

Sentencing preparation may address history, role, number of acts, treatment, risk, acceptance where appropriate, family and employment, and lawful mitigation. Restitution must be documented and causally related. The defense should avoid conceding disputed file counts or commercial gain through an inaccurate presentence report.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is promoting or directing an obscene sexual performance by a minor?

It is knowingly producing, directing, or promoting an obscene performance that includes sexual conduct by a person who was a minor when the performance occurred.

What is the penalty?

It is a Class A felony, ordinarily carrying up to twenty years’ imprisonment and a $20,000 fine.

How is it different from ordinary promotion under § 12.1-27.2-04?

The Class A offense requires proof that the performance was obscene. The neighboring Class B offense does not require obscenity.

What does “promote” include?

It includes procuring, making, selling, giving, transferring, transmitting, publishing, distributing, presenting, exhibiting, advertising, and many related acts.

Can one digital transmission count?

Potentially. Transfer or transmission appears in the statutory promotion definition, but the State must prove knowing user action and every other element.

What makes a performance obscene?

All three statutory prongs must be proved: predominant prurient appeal, patently offensive sexual conduct, and lack of serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value, with the work considered as a whole where specified.

Is every sexual performance involving a minor obscene?

No. North Dakota separately criminalizes nonobscene promotion, confirming that obscenity is an additional element of this Class A offense.

Does one photograph qualify as a performance?

Yes, a photograph can meet the chapter’s performance definition, but the remaining elements still must be proved.

Is nudity alone enough?

Not always. The chapter requires statutory sexual conduct, and the nude-or-partially-denuded alternative includes a sexual-stimulation or gratification purpose.

Must the accused know the performance is legally obscene?

The statute requires knowledge of character and content. Whether that content meets the legal obscenity test remains a question under the statute; legal vocabulary is not itself an element.

Does the minor have to know about the performance?

No. The chapter states the minor need not know the minor is participating in the described sexual conduct or any aspect of it.

Does current law cover AI-generated images?

Current chapter definitions include certain computer-generated images made to appear to depict a person under eighteen. Offense date, provenance, and all other elements still matter.

Is mistaken age a defense?

A narrow affirmative defense applies when the accused reasonably and in good faith believed the person was at least eighteen and the person was actually at least fifteen.

Can legitimate medical or research handling be defended?

Yes. The chapter provides an affirmative defense for specified bona fide medical, scientific, educational, religious, governmental, judicial, and similarly appropriate handling.

Does conviction require registration?

Chapter 12.1-27.2 is included in North Dakota’s sexual-offender registration statute, which requires registration when its conditions are met.

What should a person charged in Fargo do first?

Do not delete, browse, forward, or discuss the material; obey release conditions; preserve devices and credentials; obtain the warrants and exact count list; and begin qualified forensic and legal review promptly.

Primary Authorities


Call nowChoose a time