Fargo Promoting a Sexual Performance by a Minor Defense
North Dakota makes it a Class B felony knowingly to produce, direct, or promote any performance that includes sexual conduct by a person who was a minor…
North Dakota Promoting a Sexual Performance by a Minor Defense Guide
Fargo Promoting a Sexual Performance by a Minor Defense
North Dakota makes it a Class B felony knowingly to produce, direct, or promote any performance that includes sexual conduct by a person who was a minor at the time of the performance. The offense does not require the State to prove the performance was obscene. It can reach the creation, procurement, transfer, transmission, exhibition, advertisement, or other promotion of a single photograph, video, or visual representation.
The breadth of N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-04 does not eliminate its elements. Prosecutors must prove who acted, what performance was involved, which form of statutory sexual conduct it contained, that the depicted person was a minor when the performance occurred, that the accused knew the performance’s character and content, and that the accused produced, directed, or committed one of the defined promotion acts. Device ownership, a username, a thumbnail, or a disturbing allegation is not a substitute for that proof.
This guide explains the current statute, definitions, digital forensics, account attribution, current computer-generated-image provisions, affirmative defenses, sex-offender registration, and North Dakota case law. It is general information, not legal advice for an individual case.
Elements and Class B Felony Penalty
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-04 applies when a person, knowing the character and content of a performance, produces, directs, or promotes a performance that includes sexual conduct by a person who was a minor when it occurred. Every phrase should appear in the State’s proof and the jury instructions.
Class B felony
Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-01, a Class B felony ordinarily carries up to ten years’ imprisonment, a $20,000 fine, or both. Registration, supervision, and collateral restrictions can be more enduring than the prison term.
No obscenity element
The neighboring § 12.1-27.2-03 offense is a Class A felony because it adds proof that the performance was obscene. Section 12.1-27.2-04 does not require prurient appeal, patent offensiveness, or lack of serious value. The absence of an obscenity element does not mean every image of a minor qualifies; the State must prove statutory sexual conduct and all remaining elements.
Different from use of a minor
Section 12.1-27.2-02 focuses on employing, authorizing, inducing, caregiver consent, or an adult portraying the adult as a minor for the specified purpose. Promotion can occur after the performance already exists and can be committed by a person who never communicated with the depicted minor.
Different from possession
Possession under § 12.1-27.2-04.1 requires knowing dominion or control over prohibited material and has its own grading enhancements. Promotion requires a production, direction, procurement, transfer, exhibition, or another defined act. A person may possess without promoting, promote without retaining, or face both counts if the State proves legally distinct conduct.
Offense-date law
The chapter has changed over time. Definitions and penalties in effect on the alleged date govern. A file may be created under one version, transmitted under another, and possessed later. Each charged act needs a date and applicable statute.
Producing and Directing a Sexual Performance
Producing
Production commonly means creating, making, or assembling the performance. It can involve taking a photograph, recording a video, operating a camera, rendering an image, editing source material, combining visual elements, or causing a file to be generated. The evidence must connect the accused to the production rather than merely to later possession.
Original metadata, camera serial information, source files, project history, application databases, render logs, cloud versioning, account records, device artifacts, and witness testimony can identify who created or altered a work. Social-media compression and screenshots can strip metadata, so the absence of camera data does not alone prove or disprove production.
Directing
Direction may consist of instructions about pose, conduct, clothing, camera angle, lighting, framing, duration, retakes, or transmission. The State should show the direction concerned the qualifying sexual conduct during the performance. A message sent after an unsolicited image arrived may be evidence of knowledge or possession without proving prior direction.
Remote production
An accused need not hold the camera. Messages directing another person to create and send a depiction can support production or direction. Full conversation history matters: cropped screenshots can omit who initiated the exchange, whether a request referred to a lawful image, or whether the account was controlled by the accused.
Payment, gifts, and benefits
Cash, digital payments, gift cards, vape products, games, transportation, food, or other benefits may support an inference that the accused caused production. The State should tie the transfer to the specific performance and user. A payment with an unrelated purpose should not be transformed by timing alone.
Coercion is not required
Section 12.1-27.2-04 does not require force, threat, or coercion. It also does not require the minor to understand that the conduct is being depicted sexually. The absence of coercion may affect sentencing or related charges but is not a defense to every form of promotion.
The Statutory Definition of “Promote”
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-01(5) defines promotion through a long list of acts. The word includes procure, manufacture, issue, sell, give, provide, lend, mail, deliver, transfer, transmit, ship, transport, publish, distribute, circulate, disseminate, present, exhibit, and advertise.
Procure
Procurement can include obtaining or causing acquisition of a performance. A request, negotiation, payment, instruction, download, or account exchange may be evidence. The State must prove that the accused procured the qualifying performance with knowledge of character and content.
Transfer or transmit
Sending one file through a messaging service, text, email, nearby-device transfer, shared folder, or another channel can fall within the statute. The defense should distinguish an intentional send from automatic backup, platform sync, malicious software, accidental attachment, or an act by another user.
Give or provide
A no-cost transfer can qualify. Commercial gain is not an element of § 12.1-27.2-04. How the recipient obtained access—direct file, link, credentials, physical media, or screen display—may determine the promotion act and evidence needed.
Publish, distribute, or circulate
Posting to a public or restricted account, group, channel, forum, website, or file-sharing network may support promotion. Privacy settings affect audience and proof but do not necessarily defeat the act. Server logs, post identifiers, moderation records, access lists, and account data matter.
Present or exhibit
Showing an image or video on a device can constitute promotion even without transferring a copy. The State should prove a deliberate display, what was visible, who controlled the screen, and knowledge. An unexpected autoplay, notification preview, or accidental screen share can raise reasonable doubt.
Advertise
An offer or announcement can be promotion even before a completed sale. The advertisement must concern a qualifying performance. Coded language, sample images, price lists, channel descriptions, or direct messages may be used, but interpretation should be grounded in complete context and reliable attribution.
Automated service-provider conduct
The promotion definition is broad, but criminal liability generally requires the accused’s conduct and the express knowledge element. An internet provider, platform, or cloud system may route or replicate content without a subscriber’s decision. Current possession law expressly protects certain service providers for third-party content; individual liability still requires proof under the charged statute.
Performance and Statutory Sexual Conduct
Visual performance
A “performance” includes a play, motion picture, photograph, dance, other visual representation, or any part of one. A single still photograph can qualify. Audio or text may be evidence of direction or knowledge but is not itself necessarily a visual representation.
Sexual performance
A sexual performance is a performance that includes sexual conduct by a minor. The State should identify the specific conduct rather than rely on a generic “explicit” label.
Enumerated sexual conduct
Current law covers actual or simulated sexual intercourse, sodomy, sexual bestiality, masturbation, sadomasochistic abuse, lewd exhibition of buttocks, breasts, or genitals, certain nude or partially denuded figures depicted for sexual stimulation or gratification, and physical contact with clothed or unclothed genitals, pubic area, buttocks, or breasts.
Actual and simulated conduct
Simulated conduct requires an explicit depiction creating the appearance of actual listed conduct and exhibiting a nude or partially denuded figure under the cross-reference. An ambiguous gesture, joke, dance, or ordinary physical activity should not be classified as simulation without examining what the depiction actually shows.
Lewd exhibition
Lewdness is context-dependent. Camera focus, pose, framing, clothing, direction, setting, conduct, expression, intended audience, and accompanying messages can matter. Anatomical visibility alone does not answer whether the exhibition was lewd.
Sexualized nude or partially denuded figure
The nude-figure alternative includes a purpose requirement: depiction for sexual stimulation or gratification of a viewer. Ordinary family, medical, news, artistic, athletic, or educational images are not automatically sexual conduct. Purpose can be inferred from instructions, composition, storage, captions, requests, and intended use.
Clothed contact
The current definition includes physical contact with specified body areas whether clothed or unclothed. The conduct must still appear in a visual performance and involve a minor under the chapter definition. Context can distinguish sexualized contact from ordinary care, sport, medical treatment, or family interaction.
Minor’s lack of awareness
The statute says the minor need not know that the minor is participating in the described conduct or any aspect of it. Covert recording or a manipulated depiction can therefore qualify. The accused’s knowledge remains a separate requirement.
Knowledge, Identity, and Account Attribution
Knowing character and content
The prosecution must prove the accused knew what the performance was. Requests, captions, replies, viewing, editing, organization, repeated transfers, payment, concealment, deletion, or admissions may support knowledge. A file’s presence alone may not.
Unsolicited content
A person can receive an unwanted image in a group chat, spam message, or direct message. Prompt deletion, blocking, reporting, nonresponse, and absence of viewing may support lack of knowledge or promotion. Forwarding, saving, requesting more, or paying can support the opposite inference.
Subscriber is not necessarily user
Account registration, phone billing, or internet service identifies a subscriber. Proving who typed, clicked, or transmitted at a specific time may require device tokens, login IPs, location, recovery data, multifactor records, photographs, contacts, payment, writing style, and physical access.
Shared devices and cloud accounts
Family tablets, business computers, gaming devices, shared photo libraries, and cloud accounts can contain data created by several users. Per-user profiles, application databases, authentication artifacts, schedules, and testimony can identify or undermine individual control.
Deletion and disappearing messages
Deletion can be evidence of concealment, but platforms also expire messages automatically or remove content remotely. A forensic examiner should distinguish user deletion, platform moderation, cache cleanup, remote unsend, storage optimization, and factory reset.
Knowledge of age and affirmative defense
The State must prove actual minor status. Chapter 12.1-27.2-05 separately creates a narrow affirmative defense based on a reasonable good-faith belief that the person was at least eighteen when the person was actually at least fifteen. Profiles, statements, identification, appearance, contradictory information, and the full conversation matter.
Minor Status, Proof of Age, and Synthetic Depictions
Age when the performance occurred
The person must have been a minor when the performance occurred. A file sent years later retains the depicted person’s age at creation. The prosecution should establish identity, creation date, and birth date rather than infer age solely from the date of transmission.
Statutory proof methods
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-06 allows the factfinder to rely on inspection of the minor or performance, witness opinion from appearance, expert appearance testimony, and other lawful methods. Records and authenticated statements may also be relevant.
Limits of appearance
Filters, makeup, camera angle, body development, image quality, editing, and individual variation can make age estimation unreliable. An expert should explain methodology, training, source material, error limits, and certainty rather than offer an unsupported number.
Current computer-generated-image definition
Current law defines “minor” to include certain computer-generated images used, created, adapted, altered, or modified to appear to depict someone under eighteen through face, likeness, or distinguishing characteristics. The chapter also defines a computer-generated image as one created with artificial intelligence or another computer program.
Provenance analysis
An image may be a real photograph, altered adult, face swap, composite, or wholly synthetic rendering. Source files, metadata, generation history, editing layers, model artifacts, platform records, and expert analysis may distinguish them. Reposts and screenshots can remove provenance.
Effective date and exact wording
The synthetic-image amendment cannot automatically govern earlier conduct. Each alleged production or promotion needs a date. Even under current law, the State must prove the defined minor, qualifying performance, sexual conduct, knowledge, and promotion act.
Digital Forensics and Evidentiary Foundation
Search warrants
Device and account warrants require probable cause, nexus, and particularity. Examine the alleged facts connecting each device or account to the offense, the time period, categories authorized, extraction method, later searches, and whether investigators exceeded scope.
Provider returns
Social-media, messaging, cloud, telecom, email, and payment records can show identifiers, logins, IPs, devices, messages, attachments, and transactions. Time zones, retention, encryption, edits, disappearing settings, and synchronization must be understood.
Forensic file location
An active gallery file differs from a thumbnail, cache, unallocated fragment, remote placeholder, or application blob. File location can support an inference about access and control, but each artifact needs explanation. A hash identifies matching data, not a user’s knowledge.
Messages in full context
Obtain the complete conversation from all available devices and providers. One side’s screenshot may omit preceding requests, replies, unsent messages, edits, timestamps, or account identifiers. Compare provider time with local-device time and daylight-saving settings.
Authentication
Under State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 14–24, recorded evidence may be authenticated through testimony and circumstantial indicators, but hearsay remains separate. The same distinction applies to messages, videos, screen captures, and voice notes.
Business records
State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 8–26, held that an officer who merely received records could not supply missing knowledge about how their contents were created and kept. Platform and payment evidence needs a custodian, certification, or other lawful foundation.
Experts
Digital extraction, image authenticity, age estimation, synthetic-image detection, and platform behavior may require expert testimony. State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108, ¶¶ 5–11, requires proper disclosure of specialized opinion testimony.
Independent review without illegal copying
Defense counsel and experts need lawful access to the evidence, often under a protective order or controlled examination. Do not forward or recreate suspected material. A forensic image and validated reports can permit analysis while protecting the minor and preserving chain of custody.
Defenses to Promoting a Sexual Performance
No production, direction, or promotion
Mere receipt, passive device presence, or account ownership may not prove a listed act. The State should identify what the accused created, instructed, procured, sent, displayed, advertised, or otherwise promoted.
No qualifying sexual conduct
The depiction may show nonsexual nudity, lawful medical or family activity, ordinary contact, sport, dance, or ambiguous conduct outside the enumerated definition. The exact statutory alternative should be identified.
No knowledge
An unopened attachment, automatic download, cached preview, hidden file, mislabeled content, or unsolicited message may create reasonable doubt about knowledge of character and content. Forensic access evidence is essential.
Wrong user
A shared device, compromised account, remote access, recycled phone number, shared cloud library, or another employee can defeat attribution. Subscriber information should be tested against actual-use evidence.
No actual minor or no proof of age
The State may be unable to identify a depicted person, date the performance, or establish age reliably. Synthetic-image provisions must be applied under the correct offense-date law and still require proof of all elements.
Reasonable good-faith age belief
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-05(1) supplies an affirmative defense when the defendant reasonably and in good faith believed the person was at least eighteen, if the person was actually at least fifteen. The defense does not apply when the person was under fifteen.
Bona fide professional or institutional purpose
Section 12.1-27.2-05(2) provides an affirmative defense for certain bona fide medical, scientific, educational, religious, governmental, judicial, or other appropriate dissemination or presentation. The purpose, audience, professional role, security, and scope should be documented.
Unlawful search or interrogation
Suppression may address deficient warrants, overbroad execution, involuntary consent, custodial interrogation without valid warnings, or questioning after invocation. Evidence can also be challenged for chain, alteration, hearsay, authentication, and disclosure failures.
Offense-date law
A newer definition or greater penalty cannot automatically be applied to earlier completed conduct. Creation, receipt, access, transmission, and continuing possession are different events. The State should date each count rather than rely on the device-seizure date.
Multiple Files, Multiple Messages, and Overlapping Counts
Unit of prosecution
Investigators may count files, messages, dates, recipients, or promotion acts. The legislature’s intended unit of prosecution controls, not the forensic software’s file total. Duplicate hashes, thumbnails, copies, previews, archives, and the same file on synchronized devices can inflate a raw count.
Promotion and possession
A sent file may support both promotion and possession allegations, but cumulative punishment depends on elements and legislative intent. A file retained automatically after sending may not represent a separate conscious act. Count-specific motions and instructions matter.
Use, promotion, and luring
A conversation requesting an image can generate use, promotion, luring, solicitation, patronizing, or attempt charges. Counsel should identify the conduct supporting each, compare elements, and prevent the same generalized evidence from substituting for a missing element.
Same-elements analysis
State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127, ¶ 8, restates the same-elements test. The test is an important beginning, though statutory intent and the allowable unit can also affect multiplicity and merger.
Image count and sentencing
Even when not an element of § 12.1-27.2-04, file count can influence sentencing. The defense should distinguish original performances from duplicates, thumbnails, cache entries, and files never accessed by the accused. The presentence report should not adopt an unvalidated number.
Registration and Other Consequences
Sex-offender registration
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-15 includes chapter 12.1-27.2 in its sexual-offender definition. Registration requires reporting residence and other information and can impose verification, travel, work, and school duties. Failure to register can become a new offense.
Interest of K.I.B., 2025 ND 157, ¶¶ 8–12, holds that a juvenile court could not exercise discretion to excuse registration for a chapter 12.1-27.2 adjudication under the statute. Registration must be understood before a plea.
Commercial enhanced fines
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.2-04.2 contains special fines for a person acting in a commercial or for-profit activity with ownership, control, managerial responsibility, or financial interest other than wages. Repeat offenses have higher provisions.
Federal exposure
Internet production, receipt, distribution, and possession can implicate federal statutes, including offenses with mandatory minimums. State and federal authorities may share forensic evidence. A state plea does not necessarily end federal risk.
Release and supervision restrictions
Courts may restrict devices, internet, encrypted applications, contact with minors, residence, employment, travel, and firearms. Monitoring software can generate alerts requiring prompt explanation. Conditions should be clear, feasible, and obeyed until modified.
Life consequences
A conviction can affect employment, professional licensing, education, housing, immigration, parenting, foster or adoptive status, guardianship, reputation, and family relationships. Sentencing exposure is only one part of informed decision-making.
Official North Dakota Decisions Relevant to the Defense
State v. Wiese: promotion and online evidence
State v. Wiese, 2024 ND 39, ¶¶ 10–13, directly addresses § 12.1-27.2-04. The Court found sufficient evidence from messages, account data, discussions of price and payment, receipt, and admissions. It also held that a proposed jury instruction produced invited error, underscoring preservation.
Interest of K.I.B.: registration
Interest of K.I.B., 2025 ND 157, ¶¶ 8–12, concerns a juvenile adjudicated for promotion and possession. The Court held registration could not be excused under the statute.
State v. Henderson: provider records
State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 8–26, explains that an officer who received business records could not supply missing knowledge of their creation and maintenance. Platform and payment records need proper foundation.
State v. Burton: authentication
State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 14–24, addresses authentication and hearsay for recorded evidence. Messages, screen recordings, calls, and captured disclosures require the same disciplined analysis.
State v. Ziegler: documentary proof
State v. Ziegler, 2025 ND 78, ¶¶ 8–13, illustrates that documents and summaries need foundation and personal knowledge. A forensic chart does not authenticate its underlying sources automatically.
State v. Doyle: expert disclosure
State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108, ¶¶ 5–11, holds that specialized opinion testimony is subject to expert disclosure. Digital-forensic, age-estimation, and synthetic-image opinions should be disclosed with bases.
State v. Smith: overlapping counts
State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127, ¶ 8, states the same-elements test used in analyzing overlapping offenses arising from one course of conduct.
State v. Olson: knowledge and elements
State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8, ¶ 27, explains North Dakota’s culpability framework. Section 12.1-27.2-04 expressly requires knowledge of the performance’s character and content.
Fargo Investigation and Court Strategy
Preserve without redistributing
Do not delete, reset, forward, display, or independently copy suspected material. Preserve devices and account access and obtain counsel. Uncontrolled handling can change metadata, create new promotion evidence, or violate law.
First appearance
Release conditions may prohibit contact with minors, restrict devices and internet, require monitoring, limit residence or work, and prohibit travel or firearms. Read and obey the exact written terms.
Preliminary hearing
The hearing can identify the claimed performance, promotion verb, sexual-conduct category, age evidence, account attribution, knowledge, and count structure. Probable cause remains lower than trial proof.
Discovery
Obtain warrants, affidavits, full extractions, provider returns, original messages, files, metadata, hash lists, payment data, age proof, interviews, expert notices, and favorable material. Qualified independent review may require a controlled forensic copy.
Motions
Motions may address warrant nexus and scope, statements, authentication, business records, hearsay, expert disclosure, other acts, count multiplicity, joinder, offense-date law, synthetic imagery, affirmative defenses, and protective evidence handling.
Plea and trial
A plea evaluation must account for Class B exposure, registration, federal risk, supervision, internet and contact restrictions, treatment, restitution, immigration, licensing, employment, and parenting. At trial, the State must prove each element and each count beyond a reasonable doubt.
Sentencing
Preparation may address history, role, file count, treatment, risk, acceptance where appropriate, work, family, and lawful mitigation. The defense should correct duplicate file counts, unsupported commercial claims, and inaccurate descriptions before the court relies on them.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is promoting a sexual performance by a minor?
It is knowingly producing, directing, or promoting a performance that includes sexual conduct by someone who was a minor when the performance occurred.
What is the penalty?
It is a Class B felony, ordinarily carrying up to ten years’ imprisonment and a $20,000 fine.
Must the material be obscene?
No. Obscenity is an added element of the separate Class A offense under § 12.1-27.2-03.
Can one photograph be a performance?
Yes. The definition of performance includes a photograph and any part of a performance.
Can sending one file be promotion?
Potentially. Transfer and transmission are expressly included, but the State must prove knowing conduct, attribution, and every other element.
Does receiving a file count as promotion?
Receipt alone is not necessarily promotion, although procurement is included. The request, acquisition, control, and knowledge must be examined.
Does nudity automatically qualify?
No. The depiction must contain statutory sexual conduct. One nudity alternative also requires a purpose of sexual stimulation or gratification.
Must the minor know about the depiction?
No. The statute says the minor need not know the minor is participating in the described conduct or any aspect of it.
Does account ownership prove the user?
No. Subscriber status is evidence, but logins, devices, IPs, location, recovery data, messages, payment, and physical access may be needed for attribution.
Can automatic cloud sync create a defense?
It can affect knowledge and conduct. A forensic examiner should determine whether data were deliberately saved, viewed, sent, cached, or synchronized automatically.
How is age proved?
The statute permits inspection of the person or depiction, appearance testimony, expert opinion, and other lawful proof, including admissible identity records.
Does current law include AI-generated depictions?
Current definitions include certain computer-generated images made to appear to depict someone under eighteen. Effective date, provenance, and all remaining elements matter.
Is reasonable mistake about age a defense?
A narrow affirmative defense exists if the accused reasonably and in good faith believed the person was at least eighteen and the person was actually at least fifteen.
Are legitimate medical or legal uses protected?
The chapter provides an affirmative defense for specified bona fide professional, governmental, judicial, educational, scientific, religious, and similar appropriate purposes.
Does conviction require registration?
Chapter 12.1-27.2 offenses fall within North Dakota’s sexual-offender registration statute when its conditions are met.
What should a person charged in Fargo do first?
Do not delete or forward data, obey release conditions, preserve devices and credentials, obtain the warrants and count list, and begin qualified forensic and legal review promptly.