Fargo Fraudulent Practice in Urine Testing Defense
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-11-07 creates two Class A misdemeanor theories. The first prohibits willfully defrauding a urine test designed to detect a chemical or…
North Dakota criminal defense guide
Fargo Fraudulent Practice in Urine Testing Defense
N.D.C.C. § 12.1-11-07 creates two Class A misdemeanor theories. The first prohibits willfully defrauding a urine test designed to detect a chemical or controlled substance. The second prohibits knowingly possessing, distributing, or assisting in the use of a device, chemical, or real or artificial urine that is advertised or intended to alter a urine-test outcome. The State must prove the selected theory and its mental state; an unusual specimen or possession of an ordinary product is not automatically a crime.
These cases commonly overlap with probation, treatment court, pretrial release, employment, child-welfare, athletic, licensing, or treatment testing. The criminal charge remains separate from the consequence of a positive, invalid, dilute, substituted, or refused specimen. A laboratory flag may justify follow-up, but it does not by itself identify who changed the sample, establish criminal intent, or prove that a device or chemical was possessed for a prohibited purpose.
What is fraudulent practice in urine testing?
Offense level
Class A misdemeanor under either statutory theory.
Maximum penalty
Up to 360 days in jail, a fine of up to $3,000, or both.
First theory
Willfully defrauding a urine test designed to detect a chemical or controlled substance.
Second theory
Knowingly possessing, distributing, or assisting in the use of specified material advertised or intended to alter the result.
The statute is not limited to tests ordered in a criminal case. Its words can encompass a qualifying urine test in another setting, although the State still must establish jurisdiction, the test’s design, the charged conduct, and the required mental state. Whether an employer, court, treatment program, or agency could lawfully require the test may present a separate issue; it should not be silently substituted for the criminal elements.
No located reported North Dakota Supreme Court opinion directly construes every phrase of § 12.1-11-07. A careful defense should therefore start with the current statute and preserve disputes over “defrauds,” “assists,” “advertised,” “intended,” and what it means to “alter the outcome.” General North Dakota decisions still govern culpability, searches, authentication, expert testimony, records, pleas, and related counts.
The two statutory theories are different
Theory one: willfully defrauding a qualifying urine test
This theory focuses on conduct directed at a particular test. The State must prove a urine test existed, the test was designed to detect the presence of a chemical substance or controlled substance, the accused defrauded it, and the accused acted willfully. Common allegations include substitution, adulteration, adding water or another substance, using another person’s urine, concealing a delivery device, defeating observation, switching containers, or misrepresenting the specimen.
The statute does not say that every invalid sample is fraudulent. A specimen may be dilute because of fluid intake, medication, health, timing, or collection instructions. Temperature may be affected by delay, room conditions, device calibration, or documentation error. An insufficient quantity, inability to produce promptly, a broken seal, or collector deviation may render the test unusable without proving the donor willfully caused the problem.
Theory two: possession, distribution, or assistance
The second sentence reaches conduct before a test is actually defeated. It covers knowing possession or distribution of a device, chemical, real urine, or artificial urine when the item is advertised or intended to alter the outcome of a urine test. It also covers knowingly assisting in the use of such an item.
The item’s prohibited character cannot be assumed from its general category. Water, chemicals, medical tubing, containers, heating elements, and real urine can have lawful uses. Artificial urine may be sold for equipment calibration, education, research, or product demonstration. The State should identify the object, the advertising or intended use that allegedly brings it within the statute, the accused’s knowledge, and the evidence connecting the accused to possession, distribution, or assistance.
The charging document should identify the theory
A complaint that merely repeats the statute without stating whether the accused altered a test, possessed a product, distributed it, or helped another person may make preparation difficult. Discovery should identify the test date, collector, program, sample, item, alleged user, words or acts constituting assistance, and mental-state evidence. If the State charges alternatives, the verdict and instructions must preserve the required factual agreement.
State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8, ¶¶ 10–18, illustrates why statutory alternatives and culpability terms must receive independent effect. A jury should not be invited to combine weak proof of several uncharged acts into a generalized finding of “cheating.”
“Willfully” and “knowingly” are legal requirements
North Dakota’s criminal code defines “willfully” to include conduct undertaken intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly. Recklessness requires conscious and clearly unjustifiable disregard of a substantial likelihood of the relevant facts or risks, amounting to a gross deviation from acceptable standards. It is more demanding than an innocent mistake or ordinary carelessness.
State v. Roller, 2024 ND 180, ¶¶ 13–15, applies that definition and explains that intentional conduct is included within willful conduct. In the first theory, the prosecution must connect willfulness to defrauding the test. Suspicion that a person wanted a negative result does not by itself prove the person willfully manipulated the specimen.
“Knowingly” means the person knows or has a firm belief, without substantial doubt, that the person is engaging in the conduct. The second theory therefore requires more than accidental custody. A passenger may be near a product without possessing it; an employee may handle a package without knowing its contents; a retailer may stock a multipurpose item without knowing prohibited advertising; and a friend may provide transportation without assisting use.
Intent and knowledge may be proved circumstantially through packaging, product descriptions, search history, purchase records, concealment, temperature-control materials, instructions, messages, statements, timing, and conduct during collection. Each piece must be authenticated and placed in context. A website description written by a seller is not automatically a statement by the buyer.
Understanding specimen-validity evidence
Drug testing often uses an initial screen followed by confirmatory or validity testing. A screening result and a laboratory conclusion serve different purposes. The defense should obtain the complete analytical file, not only a probation officer’s summary or a portal label.
Temperature
Collectors commonly record a specimen’s temperature soon after collection because an out-of-range reading may suggest substitution. The defense should examine the collection time, reading time, device range, calibration or lot information, room conditions, cup storage, quantity, and whether the collector followed the written procedure. A handwritten number without timing and method may support suspicion but not necessarily the charged conduct.
Creatinine and specific gravity
These measurements can contribute to classifications such as dilute or substituted. Hydration, kidney function, body size, illness, medication, collection timing, and analytical uncertainty may matter. A dilute specimen is not synonymous with artificial urine or intentional water loading. The expert should explain the applicable threshold, method, quality controls, and whether the finding identifies a mechanism.
pH, oxidants, nitrites, and adulterants
Validity panels may look for abnormal acidity or alkalinity and substances associated with chemical adulteration. The defense should identify the exact analyte, concentration, cutoff, possible endogenous or environmental explanation, collection container, storage conditions, preservatives, and confirmation. A commercial point-of-care strip may not provide the same specificity as a validated laboratory method.
Drug analytes and medications
A positive drug result does not itself prove fraud. A negative result after an alleged adulteration also does not establish what the unaltered result would have been. Prescription medications, over-the-counter products, metabolism, detection windows, cross-reactivity, and confirmatory testing can affect interpretation. The criminal question is the conduct and mental state, not merely whether the donor used a substance.
Collection procedure and chain of custody
A reliable chronology begins with the test order and continues through identification, collection, sealing, labeling, storage, transport, accession, screening, confirmation, review, and reporting. Relevant documents can include the signed collection form, collector notes, incident report, restroom inspection, observed-collection record, seal numbers, courier log, laboratory accession record, instrument batch, control results, chromatograms or mass spectra, review notes, and final report.
Breaks or mistakes do not automatically exclude every result, but they can change the weight and the inference of intentional manipulation. A mislabeled cup, unsealed refrigerator, undocumented transfer, delayed temperature reading, or copied result can create an alternative explanation. The defense should ask which errors the method can detect and which it cannot.
State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 9–24, requires proper authentication and a sufficient foundation for records of regularly conducted activity. A laboratory report, collection spreadsheet, or probation printout does not become self-proving merely because an officer received it.
State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 20–26, explains the Rule 901 threshold. Authentication permits an exhibit to be considered; it does not conclusively establish that every entry is accurate, that the sample came from the accused, or that a validity finding proves deliberate fraud.
Laboratory and collector testimony
A collector can describe observation, identification, timing, temperature, behavior, seals, and the procedure followed. A toxicologist or laboratory scientist may explain chemical testing, specimen validity, controls, uncertainty, and interpretation. A probation officer may relay what was reported but may not possess the specialized foundation to convert a laboratory flag into an opinion about a particular adulterant or intentional method.
State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108, ¶¶ 5–11, distinguishes observations based on personal knowledge from opinions rooted in specialized knowledge. A witness cannot evade expert disclosure and foundation requirements by being labeled an “investigator” or “collector.”
The defense should review qualifications, test validation, standard operating procedure, proficiency testing, quality-control failures, maintenance, lot recalls, uncertainty, cutoff selection, corrective actions, and communications with the referring agency. If the State claims a specific commercial product caused the result, the expert should identify a reliable analytical basis rather than infer the product from packaging found elsewhere.
Possession and distribution cases require a real connection
Actual possession may be shown through custody on the person. Constructive possession usually depends on authority, location, access, and circumstances supporting dominion or control. Mere proximity is not automatically possession. A product found in a shared bathroom, vehicle, workplace, residence, or retail stockroom requires person-specific proof.
Digital evidence may include online orders, payment records, shipping notices, product searches, instructions, texts, and resale advertisements. The defense should determine who controlled the account, device, payment method, delivery location, and package. Shared family accounts, saved cards, marketplace records, and forwarded messages can create misleading attribution.
“Distribution” should be tied to an actual transfer or conduct fitting the legal meaning, not mere conversation. “Assists in the use” requires proof of knowing help. Providing an ordinary container, ride, money, or information may be innocent unless the surrounding evidence shows the accused knew the prohibited use.
The item must also be advertised or intended to alter a urine-test outcome. Preserve the original packaging and complete advertisement as it appeared on the relevant date. A prosecutor should not rely on a later website revision, a reseller’s description, or a law-enforcement characterization when the actual marketing and use were different.
Probation and treatment-court consequences
North Dakota’s probation statute and current court form expressly address willfully defrauding a urine test administered as a probation condition. A single incident can therefore produce two different proceedings: a new Class A misdemeanor charge under § 12.1-11-07 and an allegation that the person violated an existing judgment.
The proceedings are not interchangeable. The new criminal case requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt and carries its own plea and trial rights. A revocation hearing uses different procedures and can expose the person to a sentence that could have been imposed in the original case. The court should identify the alleged condition, conduct, evidence, and available sanction.
A program may administratively treat a refusal, dilute sample, missed test, or tampering indicator as positive. That rule can matter to supervision but does not automatically establish every element of § 12.1-11-07. Counsel should obtain the signed judgment, program manual, testing directive, notices, sanction history, and any agreement concerning intermediate conditions.
Do not admit the criminal elements simply to explain the supervision problem without understanding the consequences. Conversely, contesting the new charge does not excuse ignoring a valid order. Continue reporting and testing as directed unless the court or supervising authority changes the requirement in writing.
Searches of property, phones, and accounts
Investigators may search a person before collection, inspect the restroom, seize a container, search a vehicle or residence, or obtain digital purchase records. Probationers may have reduced privacy under a signed search condition, but the actual judgment, officer authority, purpose, and scope still matter. People not subject to that condition retain their own rights.
A warrant should connect the suspected offense to the place and material sought. State v. Quam, 2026 ND 145, ¶¶ 9–18, discusses digital-search nexus. A suspicion about one test should not automatically authorize years of unrelated health information, photographs, and communications.
Third-party consent is limited by authority and scope. State v. Gietzen, 2024 ND 5, ¶¶ 7–15, affirmed suppression where consent did not extend to a locked container associated with another person. A roommate, driver, employer, or collector may control some spaces without authority over a private bag, device, or account.
When probable cause depends on an informant, employee, former partner, or confidential source, basis of knowledge and corroboration matter. State v. Ochoa, 2004 ND 43, ¶¶ 10–19, evaluates informant information within the totality.
Defense issues that can change the case
- No fraud: the specimen issue resulted from physiology, hydration, medication, delay, equipment, collector error, or another nonfraudulent cause.
- No required mental state: the accused did not intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly defraud the test and did not knowingly possess or assist with a prohibited item.
- Item not covered: the device, chemical, or urine was not advertised or intended to alter a urine-test outcome.
- No possession or assistance: proximity, shared space, or ordinary help does not establish control or knowing participation.
- Test not within the statute: the State cannot prove the urine test was designed to detect a chemical or controlled substance.
- Specimen not reliably identified: labeling, sealing, custody, or accession problems prevent a reliable connection to the accused.
- Unreliable interpretation: a screening or validity flag does not support the claimed mechanism, product, or intentional act.
- Unlawful search or statement: evidence exceeded a warrant, probation condition, valid consent, or constitutional interrogation limits.
- Duplicative or unsupported counts: possession, completed fraud, tampering, and probation allegations require separate element analysis.
The best theory should fit the original records. It may challenge the chemistry, the collection, identity, possession, advertising, intent, search, or several connected inferences. A conclusory claim that “the test was wrong” is less useful than showing precisely where the State’s chain fails.
Collector questions, probation interviews, and alleged admissions
A person may be questioned while still in the collection room, immediately after an abnormal temperature reading, during a probation visit, or after officers find a product. The setting matters. A collector may ask routine administrative questions, while a probation officer or detective may be seeking evidence of a new crime. Counsel should identify when suspicion focused on the accused, whether the person was free to leave, who participated, whether the exchange was recorded, and what warnings or promises were given.
Words used in the moment can be ambiguous. Saying a sample was “bad,” “messed up,” or “not mine” may refer to labeling, collection, health, or a belief that the result is inaccurate rather than an admission of substitution. Agreeing that an item could defeat a test is not necessarily an admission that it was possessed or intended for that purpose. The complete recording and exact questions are more reliable than a later summary.
A truthful medical explanation should be supported rather than improvised. If hydration, kidney disease, medication, inability to void, recent hospitalization, or collection instructions may matter, preserve contemporaneous records and consult an appropriate professional. Creating a new medical story after the result, altering a prescription list, or asking a provider to backdate a note can cause much greater harm.
Refusal and fraud are not identical
A program may treat leaving, failing to provide within a set time, declining observation, or producing insufficient volume as refusal. That characterization may carry a supervision or employment consequence. The criminal statute, however, requires willful fraud or the separate knowing-item theory. Counsel should distinguish inability, misunderstanding, anxiety, privacy objection, noncompliance, and an intentional effort to deceive.
Plea language must match the actual theory
A proposed factual basis should identify whether the defendant admits manipulating a particular qualifying test or knowingly possessing, distributing, or assisting with a covered item. State v. Haskins, 2026 ND 23, addresses the need for a sufficient plea basis. Vague language such as “there was a testing issue” may fail to establish the offense while still creating damaging collateral admissions.
Resolution discussions should address the original case, new charge, revocation allegation, remaining probation exposure, testing conditions, treatment placement, employment or license reporting, and whether seized property will be returned. A dismissal of the new charge may not automatically end a program sanction; a probation agreement may not dismiss the criminal case unless the written terms say so.
North Dakota decisions relevant to the defense
No located reported opinion directly decides all elements of § 12.1-11-07. These official decisions address principles likely to govern a prosecution.
State v. Roller, 2024 ND 180
“Willfully” includes intentional, knowing, or reckless conduct under North Dakota’s criminal code.
State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8
Statutory alternatives and culpability requirements must be given meaningful, separate effect.
State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83
Authentication may rest on circumstantial evidence; admission does not eliminate disputes over accuracy and weight.
State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42
Laboratory, business, and electronic records require authentication and a valid hearsay foundation.
State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108
Opinions based on specialized knowledge must be treated as expert testimony.
State v. Quam, 2026 ND 145
A digital warrant requires a factual nexus to the devices, accounts, information, and time searched.
State v. Gietzen, 2024 ND 5
Third-party consent depends on authority and scope, particularly for private containers and property.
State v. Ochoa, 2004 ND 43
Informant knowledge, reliability, corroboration, and the full affidavit matter to probable cause.
State v. Haskins, 2026 ND 23
A plea needs an adequate factual basis identifying the statutory theory, item or test, conduct, and mental state.
State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127
Same-elements analysis applies when one testing incident produces several criminal convictions.
A practical defense plan
- Identify the exact theory. Separate completed fraud, possession, distribution, and assistance.
- Preserve the full test file. Obtain the order, collection form, incident notes, cup information, readings, seals, custody, raw data, controls, and report.
- Document health and intake. Preserve prescriptions, supplements, medical conditions, fluid instructions, food, timing, and other legitimate explanations.
- Secure the physical item. Photograph and preserve packaging, instructions, lot numbers, residue, receipts, and the item without handling it unnecessarily.
- Build the possession timeline. Identify who owned, purchased, transported, stored, accessed, or knew about the item.
- Audit digital attribution. Review account ownership, device access, orders, payments, messages, and complete advertisements.
- Examine searches and statements. Compare collection, probation, consent, warrants, and interviews with the actual legal authority.
- Coordinate parallel cases. Protect deadlines and consistency across probation, employment, licensing, treatment, and criminal proceedings.
Frequently asked questions about fraudulent urine testing
Is fraudulent practice in urine testing a felony?
No. Both theories in N.D.C.C. § 12.1-11-07 are Class A misdemeanors, punishable by up to 360 days in jail and a fine of up to $3,000.
Does the law apply only to probation tests?
No. The criminal statute is not limited to probation. Probation law separately makes willfully defrauding a test a common supervision violation, so one event may create both proceedings.
Is a dilute sample automatically fraud?
No. Dilution can have innocent physiological or collection explanations. The State must prove willful fraud, not merely a laboratory or program classification.
Can possession of artificial urine be charged before a test occurs?
Potentially. The second theory covers knowing possession when the artificial urine is advertised or intended to alter a urine-test outcome. Possession, knowledge, and prohibited character must all be proved.
Are ordinary chemicals or containers illegal?
Not by category alone. The statute requires a covered item advertised or intended to alter the outcome and knowing possession, distribution, or assistance.
What does “willfully” mean?
Under North Dakota law, willful conduct includes intentional, knowing, or reckless conduct. Recklessness requires conscious and clearly unjustifiable disregard, not ordinary negligence.
Can helping another person be charged?
Yes, if the State proves the accused knowingly assisted in the use of a covered device, chemical, real urine, or artificial urine. Ordinary help without knowledge of the prohibited use is not enough.
What if the urine belonged to someone else?
Substitution can support a completed-fraud allegation, while possession or assistance may support the second theory. The State still must authenticate the sample, identify the actor, and prove the required mental state.
Can a positive drug test prove the fraud charge?
A positive result may show substance exposure but does not itself prove manipulation. The prosecution must establish conduct directed at defrauding the test or a separate possession or assistance theory.
Can an invalid test revoke probation even without a conviction?
A revocation proceeding uses different standards and can proceed separately. Program rules may treat tampering, refusal, or an invalid sample as a violation even while the new criminal charge is contested.
Should I admit tampering to avoid a program sanction?
Not before understanding how the statement can affect the criminal charge and original sentence. Counsel can address immediate compliance and any hearing without an uninformed admission.
Can police search my phone for purchase records?
They may seek a warrant or rely on another recognized authority, but the search needs a lawful basis and appropriate scope. Probation conditions and third-party consent require fact-specific review.
Can laboratory records be challenged?
Yes. Sample identity, custody, method, controls, thresholds, expert foundation, completeness, hearsay, and the inference of intentional fraud may all be examined.
What should be preserved immediately?
Preserve collection documents, program rules, laboratory reports, medications, medical information, the physical item and packaging, receipts, messages, account data, video, and all court orders.
Can related evidence-tampering charges be filed?
Potentially, especially if evidence is destroyed, altered, concealed, or fabricated after an investigation begins. Do not delete records or discard the product.
How does a lawyer evaluate the defense?
A lawyer separates the statutory theories, reconstructs collection and custody, tests the chemistry and expert foundation, evaluates possession and mental state, reviews searches and statements, and coordinates all parallel proceedings.
Talk with a Fargo defense lawyer before making an admission
A questionable specimen can jeopardize liberty in both a new prosecution and an existing case. A prompt defense preserves the physical and laboratory evidence, protects retest and hearing deadlines, separates an invalid result from intentional fraud, and coordinates the criminal response with probation, employment, licensing, or treatment consequences.