Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Fargo Disarming or Attempting to Disarm a Law Enforcement Officer Defense Lawyer

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-23-02.1 creates a Class C felony when a person, without an officer’s consent, willfully takes, removes, or attempts to take or remove a…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota Officer-Disarming Felony Defense Guide

Fargo Disarming or Attempting to Disarm a Law Enforcement Officer Defense Lawyer

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-23-02.1 creates a Class C felony when a person, without an officer’s consent, willfully takes, removes, or attempts to take or remove a firearm from a law-enforcement officer who is performing official duties. The State does not need to prove the gun left the holster. It does need to prove a willful act directed at taking or removing the firearm—not merely resistance, incidental contact with a duty belt, a chaotic struggle, or a hand that passed near the holster.

These cases can turn on seconds of body-camera video and competing descriptions of a fast physical encounter. Frame-by-frame movement, camera position, the officer’s commands, restraint techniques, holster design, witness vantage, injuries, fingerprints or DNA, and the accused’s physical and mental condition may all matter. “He went for my gun” is an important allegation, but it remains a conclusion that the evidence must support beyond a reasonable doubt.

What North Dakota must prove

The statute provides: “Notwithstanding subdivision d of subsection 3 of section 12.1-23-05, a person is guilty of a class C felony if, without the consent of the law enforcement officer, the person willfully takes or removes, or attempts to take or remove, a firearm from a law enforcement officer engaged in the performance of official duties.” Each phrase limits the charge.

A willful act

Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-02-02(1)(e), “willfully” means acting intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly. The term is broader than “intentionally,” but it still excludes pure accident. The prosecution should identify the conduct said to be willful: gripping the gun, pressing a holster release, pulling the weapon, deliberately reaching into the holster area, or another act directed at removal.

The mental-state analysis becomes more demanding when the State alleges an attempt. An attempt ordinarily requires conduct strongly corroborative of an intent to complete the offense. The jury should not convict merely because contact created a risk that the gun might be displaced. Reckless struggling near a duty belt and an intentional effort to take the gun are not interchangeable descriptions.

Taking, removing, or attempting to do so

A completed offense can occur when the accused obtains control of the firearm or separates it from the officer’s possession. “Removes” can include pulling it from a holster, hand, sling, carrier, or other location on the officer. The statutory text does not require that the accused fire, point, keep, or escape with the weapon.

An attempt can be charged before removal succeeds. Still, movement must be directed toward taking the firearm. Grabbing an officer’s forearm, vest, radio, belt, clothing, handcuffs, or ground for leverage does not necessarily show that objective. The precise hand placement, grip duration, direction of force, and response to commands matter.

A firearm

North Dakota defines “firearm” in N.D.C.C. § 62.1-01-01 as a device that expels or is readily capable of expelling a projectile by explosive action. The State should identify the weapon and establish functionality or ready capability through admissible evidence. A duty weapon will often be functional, but labels and appearance alone are not the statutory proof.

If the object was a conducted-energy weapon, baton, chemical spray, magazine, radio, or another tool, § 12.1-23-02.1 may not apply because the statute specifies a firearm. Other assault, theft, interference, or weapon statutes may be considered, but they have different elements.

From a law-enforcement officer

Title 12.1 defines a law-enforcement or peace officer as a public servant authorized by law or a governmental agency or branch to enforce law and conduct or engage in investigations or prosecutions for violations. The State should establish status and authority, particularly with out-of-jurisdiction officers, tribal officers, federal agents, corrections personnel, private security, reserve officers, or off-duty employment.

Without the officer’s consent

In an ordinary street encounter, lack of consent may be obvious from commands and resistance. It remains an element. Training demonstrations, evidence handling, range activity, emergency assistance, or an officer’s direction can involve consent. Scope and withdrawal matter: permission to secure a dropped weapon is not permission to retain it.

While the officer performed official duties

The State must prove the officer was engaged in official duties at the time. Arrest, detention, investigation, transport, warrant service, traffic enforcement, community caretaking, and responding to calls commonly qualify when within lawful governmental functions. Personal activity, private employment, or a purely private dispute may require closer analysis.

Whether an officer made a mistake or later loses a suppression issue does not automatically mean the officer was outside official duties. Conversely, the statutory phrase should not be deleted from the instructions. Reports, dispatch, assignments, body camera, jurisdiction, and the officer’s reason for acting supply the evidence.

What counts as attempting to disarm an officer?

North Dakota’s general attempt statute defines a substantial step as conduct “strongly corroborative of the firmness of the actor’s intent” to complete the crime. Section 12.1-23-02.1 independently includes attempts, but the same distinction between purposeful movement and ambiguous preparation is important.

Conduct that may support an attempt allegation

  • gripping the firearm’s handle and pulling;
  • defeating or manipulating a retention device while reaching for the weapon;
  • repeatedly reaching for the same holster after warnings;
  • announcing an intention to take the gun while moving to do so;
  • pinning the officer’s gun hand and trying to pry the weapon away; or
  • coordinating with another person to obtain the firearm during the struggle.

Conduct that may remain ambiguous

  • brief contact with the belt during a takedown;
  • grabbing clothing to avoid falling;
  • protecting the face or neck from pressure;
  • reaching for handcuffs, a seat belt, door frame, or the ground;
  • contact caused by an officer pulling the person across the holster; or
  • uncoordinated movement during a medical, psychiatric, or intoxication crisis.

No list decides a case. The factfinder must determine what the accused actually did and the culpability accompanying that act. Slow-motion video can clarify hand placement, but it can also create a misleading sense of deliberation that did not exist in a one-second event.

Reading body-camera footage like evidence, not a highlight clip

Body cameras have a wide-angle lens, move with the officer’s torso, and may not show the officer’s own belt. An arm can block the critical moment. Audio may begin before video, synchronization among cameras may drift, and automatic buffering may omit sound. A single officer’s camera rarely captures the complete geometry.

The defense should obtain every body and dash camera, original files, audit logs, metadata, dispatch audio, jail video, civilian recordings, and still photographs of equipment placement. The videos should be synchronized using identifiable events rather than assuming displayed timestamps match perfectly.

Real-time playback matters. Jurors should see what occurred at natural speed before studying enlarged frames. A hand appearing near a holster for two frames may be described as a “grab” after repeated slow motion even though the motion was part of rolling, bracing, or pulling away. Conversely, multiple angles may clearly show deliberate manipulation hidden from one camera.

Officer narration on video is not automatically personal observation. Statements such as “stop grabbing my gun” may be admissible and probative, but they can also reflect perception formed under stress. The factfinder should compare the statement with the visible motion, tactile account, holster condition, witness observations, and later report.

Holster design and physical mechanics

Modern duty holsters may use passive friction and one or more active retention devices requiring a specific sequence. The model, draw direction, release location, belt position, weapon fit, and officer’s setup can help distinguish a purposeful draw attempt from incidental contact.

A qualified instructor or holster expert may explain operation, but should not tell the jury what the accused intended. The defense should inspect the actual holster and firearm, document post-incident condition, determine whether a retention hood moved, and identify scratches, broken parts, or displacement. Training records may show how the officer recognizes and responds to a weapon-retention threat.

DNA or fingerprints on a firearm or holster can support contact, but transfer and limitations matter. Officers and evidence handlers routinely touch the equipment. A mixed or partial profile may not establish a grip, time, or direction. Absence of recoverable DNA does not prove no contact; presence does not establish attempted removal.

Evidence that should be collected and tested

All recordings

Body camera, dash camera, business video, residential cameras, phones, dispatch, radio traffic, interview recordings, jail booking, and medical-facility video may capture different portions. Preservation must begin quickly because private systems overwrite.

Equipment and photographs

The firearm, holster, belt, retention devices, uniform, body armor, radio, handcuffs, and damaged clothing can show positioning and force. Scene and injury photographs help reconstruct whether the accused was standing, prone, pinned, rolling, seated, or moving through a confined space.

Medical evidence

Injuries, breathing complaints, head trauma, seizure, diabetic emergency, medication, intoxication, and psychiatric symptoms may affect movement, perception, memory, and culpability. Medical evidence is not an automatic defense, but it can explain movements inaccurately characterized as deliberate.

Officer reports and prior statements

Compare the initial radio call, immediate remarks, use-of-force report, probable-cause statement, supplemental narrative, deposition, and testimony. Details may legitimately become clearer, but changes in which hand touched what, how long the grip lasted, or whether the holster moved deserve examination.

Civilian witnesses

Bystanders may have a better view of hand position than a body camera. Their distance, lighting, obstructions, attention, stress, relationship, and prior discussions affect reliability. Interviews should be recorded when possible, and investigators’ questions should not supply the conclusion.

Use-of-force and training material

Policies and training can explain officer actions, commands, weapon-retention responses, and report terminology. A policy violation does not automatically prove a criminal defense, and compliance does not establish the defendant’s intent. The material is most useful when tied to disputed events.

Statements, searches, and constitutional issues

After a force incident, officers may question the accused at the scene, in an ambulance, hospital, patrol car, or jail. Custody, Miranda warnings, invocation, pain, medication, intoxication, exhaustion, and comprehension should be reviewed. A statement such as “I was just trying to get away” may help one issue while being used against another; the complete recording matters.

Searches may include clothing, phones, vehicles, homes, social accounts, and medical records. The State must establish lawful authority and remain within scope. A serious charge does not create a general license to search years of messages or every digital account for hostility toward police.

If officers used force or entered a home unlawfully, suppression and justification are distinct questions. North Dakota generally does not authorize force merely to resist an arrest or official act under color of law, though excessive force can raise separate justification issues. Counsel should analyze the precise force, timing, perceived danger, proportionality, and whether contact with the firearm was actually defensive movement.

Defenses to disarming or attempting to disarm an officer

No act directed at the firearm

The hand may have contacted clothing, belt equipment, or the holster incidentally while the accused tried to maintain balance, breathe, protect an injury, or comply with conflicting commands. Multiple angles and mechanics can rebut a conclusion based on touch alone.

Accident rather than willfulness

Willfulness excludes accident. A fall, takedown, vehicle extraction, pileup, or sudden officer movement can place a hand on the weapon area without intentional, knowing, or reckless conduct directed at removal.

No attempt

Ambiguous proximity or preparation is insufficient. The evidence must corroborate an effort to take or remove the gun. Failure to manipulate the retention system, momentary contact, and movement away from the firearm may support reasonable doubt.

The object was not a firearm

Contact with a taser, magazine pouch, radio, baton, spray, flashlight, or empty holster does not satisfy a statute limited to a firearm. If functionality is disputed, the State must prove the device expelled or was readily capable of expelling a projectile by explosive action.

The person was not a qualifying officer or was not on official duty

Private security and civilians do not become law-enforcement officers merely by wearing equipment. Off-duty private work or personal disputes may also raise an official-duty issue. Authority, assignment, jurisdiction, and purpose should be proved.

Consent or authorized handling

Rare cases may involve an officer directing another person to secure, transfer, or inspect a firearm. Training and range activity can also involve consent. The State must prove the act exceeded any authorization.

Identification and perception error

Several people may be involved in a struggle. Darkness, blocked views, gloves, similar clothing, stress, and rapid movement can lead witnesses to attribute another person’s hand to the accused. Synchronized recordings and physical positioning are essential.

Suppression, exclusion, and instructions

Unlawful statements or searches may be suppressed. Video, forensic evidence, medical material, and expert opinions require proper foundation. Jury instructions should distinguish willful contact from an actual effort to take the firearm and should not treat the officer’s conclusion as an element.

Trial questions that prevent a vague “gun grab” conviction

Which hand, which movement, and which moment?

The prosecution should identify the particular movement alleged to be the taking or attempt. If one witness describes the right hand on the grip and another describes the left hand on the outer holster, that is not a minor difference when intent and act are disputed. A synchronized exhibit can require the State to commit to the same moment across video, testimony, and closing argument.

What did the accused do after contact?

Continued pulling, manipulation of a retention device, or renewed reaching after a warning may support the State. Immediate withdrawal, opening the hand, reaching in another direction, or following a command may support accident or a different objective. The sequence should be evaluated without assuming that every later movement proves the meaning of an earlier one.

What did the officer actually perceive?

An officer may feel pressure without seeing the hand. That tactile perception can be genuine and still leave uncertainty about grip, location, and purpose. The report should distinguish what the officer saw, felt, inferred, and learned from other officers or later video. Cross-examination can respect the danger of the encounter while testing those categories precisely.

Can the jury agree on the same act?

If the State presents several reaches during a long struggle, the instructions or verdict form may need to identify the charged act or require unanimity on one act. Otherwise some jurors may rely on incidental early contact while others rely on a later movement, leaving no unanimous finding on the same criminal conduct.

Class C felony consequences

A Class C felony carries up to five years’ imprisonment, a fine up to $10,000, or both. The maximum is not a prediction. Criminal history, injuries, actual weapon movement, related offenses, conduct after the incident, acceptance of responsibility, treatment needs, and mitigation can affect sentencing.

A felony conviction can impair firearm rights, employment, housing, licensing, education, military status, immigration, voting during incarceration, and travel. A conviction involving an officer and firearm can have reputational effects beyond the formal sentence. Plea language should not casually admit conduct broader than necessary.

Restitution may be sought for damaged equipment, medical expenses, or other loss legally caused by the offense. Workers’ compensation, insurance, repair records, causation, depreciation, and losses attributable to separate counts require careful review.

North Dakota appellate decisions that frame the defense

Reported decisions directly interpreting every phrase of § 12.1-23-02.1 are limited. These official opinions address firearm proof, willfulness, attempt, evidence, searches, instructions, and overlapping counts without claiming a direct holding where none exists.

State v. Luetzen, 2026 ND 13

Luetzen holds that the statutory firearm definition requires functionality—expelling or ready capability to expel a projectile by explosive action. Circumstantial and lay evidence may prove functionality, but the issue remains part of the State’s burden.

State v. Roller, 2024 ND 180

Roller quotes the definition that a person acts willfully when acting “intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly.” It also explains that intentional conduct is included within willful conduct.

State v. Hartson, 2024 ND 78

Hartson explains that a substantial step is conduct “strongly corroborative of the firmness of the actor’s intent” to complete the crime. That principle helps distinguish a true removal attempt from ambiguous contact.

State v. Kroeplin, 266 N.W.2d 537 (N.D. 1978)

Kroeplin addresses gun authentication, relevance, and chain of custody. The duty weapon and holster should be connected to the incident and preserved in substantially the same condition.

State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83

Burton applies authentication rules to a recording. Authentication permits consideration; it does not make an officer’s or prosecutor’s interpretation of the images conclusive.

State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108

Doyle explains when specialized opinion is expert testimony. Holster mechanics, use-of-force reconstruction, video analysis, toxicology, and DNA opinions require appropriate disclosure and reliable methods.

State v. Quam, 2026 ND 145

Quam addresses probable-cause nexus in a digital search. An officer-disarming accusation does not automatically justify a limitless search of every device, account, and date range.

State v. Gietzen, 2024 ND 5

Gietzen limits third-party consent where apparent authority did not reach a locked bag. Shared vehicles or premises do not erase separate privacy interests in closed containers and devices.

State v. Landsberger, 2025 ND 108

Landsberger illustrates the importance of accurate jury instructions and objections. The instruction should identify the act, firearm, officer status, official duty, lack of consent, and culpability required by the evidence.

State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127

Smith discusses specific Rule 29 grounds and same-elements review. Counsel should identify the missing proof and separately analyze disarming, resisting, assault, and interference counts.

Fargo felony procedure and early defense work

A Class C felony generally proceeds in Cass County District Court through initial appearance, preliminary hearing unless waived, arraignment, discovery, motions, negotiation, and trial. Release conditions can include no contact with officers or witnesses, sobriety testing, travel restrictions, and weapons prohibitions. Follow the written order exactly.

Defense preservation should begin at once. Agencies should retain every original recording, metadata and audit logs, dispatch, equipment, photographs, use-of-force files, medical records, and witness interviews. Civilian video may disappear within days. Clothing and holster condition may change if not secured.

Counsel can build a synchronized timeline, inspect the weapon and retention system, retain appropriate experts, compare every officer statement, identify unrecorded angles, litigate statements and searches, and prepare instructions that prevent incidental contact from being treated as an automatic attempt.

What to do after the accusation

  1. Do not contact the officer or witnesses. Follow release orders and let counsel handle preservation and interviews.
  2. Preserve your clothing and injuries. Photograph injuries over time and keep unwashed clothing separately if relevant.
  3. Write a private chronology for counsel. Include commands, positions, hand placement, force, breathing, pain, medical symptoms, cameras, and witnesses.
  4. Identify every recording source. Note businesses, homes, vehicles, phones, doorbells, ambulances, and jail cameras without trespassing or contacting witnesses.
  5. Preserve medical and phone information. Keep discharge papers, medication, call logs, locations, and complete messages.
  6. Do not give a reconstruction interview without counsel. Memory after a violent, fast event can be incomplete, and guesses may be treated as lies.

Frequently asked questions about disarming an officer

Does the gun have to come out of the holster?

No. The statute also criminalizes an attempt to take or remove the firearm. The State must still prove conduct directed at removal with the required culpability.

Is touching an officer’s holster enough?

Not automatically. Touch may be circumstantial evidence, but accidental or defensive contact during a struggle does not by itself prove a willful taking or attempt.

What does “willfully” mean?

Under North Dakota law, willfully includes intentional, knowing, or reckless conduct. Pure accident is excluded, and an attempt theory still requires proof directed toward completing the taking.

What is the penalty?

The offense is a Class C felony carrying up to five years’ imprisonment, a $10,000 fine, or both.

Can grabbing a taser support this exact charge?

Section 12.1-23-02.1 specifies a firearm. A taser or other tool may support a different charge, but it is not automatically a firearm.

Must the State prove the gun worked?

North Dakota’s firearm definition requires a device that expels or is readily capable of expelling a projectile by explosive action. Functionality may be proved circumstantially but remains required.

Who qualifies as a law-enforcement officer?

A public servant authorized by law or a governmental entity to enforce law and conduct or engage in investigations or prosecutions. Private security does not qualify merely by appearance.

What does “official duties” mean?

It generally includes authorized governmental functions such as arrests, investigations, traffic enforcement, warrant service, transport, or responding to calls. The particular assignment and circumstances must be proved.

What if the arrest was unlawful?

An unlawful arrest does not automatically authorize taking an officer’s gun. Suppression, officer-duty status, and justification are distinct issues requiring fact-specific analysis.

What if the officer used excessive force?

Excessive force can raise justification and credibility issues, but force directed at a firearm is especially scrutinized. Timing, necessity, proportionality, and the person’s perceived danger matter.

Can body-camera video settle the case?

Sometimes, but one camera may miss the belt area or distort timing and distance. Every angle, original metadata, natural-speed playback, audio, and physical evidence should be reviewed.

Can DNA on the holster prove an attempt?

DNA may support contact but usually cannot establish when, why, or how contact occurred. Transfer, mixtures, handling, and other evidence must be considered.

Can resisting arrest be charged too?

Yes. Resisting, assault, interference, and other charges may accompany the allegation, but each has distinct elements and may require double-jeopardy analysis.

Can mental illness or intoxication be relevant?

Potentially. It may affect movement, perception, memory, voluntariness, or culpability, but voluntary intoxication is not a universal defense. Medical evidence and the precise mental state control.

Should I explain to investigators that I never wanted the gun?

Get legal advice first. A rushed reconstruction can contain guesses or unintended admissions, especially after injury, medication, or a stressful struggle.

What should I bring to a Fargo defense lawyer?

Bring charging papers, release orders, videos, photographs, medical records, clothing, complete messages, witness and camera locations, and a private detailed chronology.

Primary authorities

This guide relies on N.D.C.C. § 12.1-23-02.1, § 12.1-01-04, § 12.1-02-02, § 62.1-01-01, § 12.1-32-01, and the linked official opinions. Current-law review completed November 4, 2026.

A struggle is not self-explanatory

The legal question is not whether contact occurred near a duty weapon. It is whether the State can prove a willful taking, removal, or real attempt involving a functional firearm, a qualifying officer, lack of consent, and official duties. A few frames and a report conclusion cannot replace that analysis.

A Fargo criminal-defense lawyer can preserve all recordings, reconstruct positions in real time, inspect the holster and gun, obtain medical and dispatch evidence, challenge expert overstatement, litigate searches and statements, and keep related resistance or assault allegations from swallowing the distinct elements of this felony.


Call nowChoose a time