Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Fargo Facilitation of Sexual Acts in Public Defense

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-20-24 regulates the physical layout of a narrowly defined adult entertainment center. It is an infraction to willfully own, rent, lease…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota business and criminal defense guide

Fargo Facilitation of Sexual Acts in Public Defense

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-20-24 regulates the physical layout of a narrowly defined adult entertainment center. It is an infraction to willfully own, rent, lease, manage, or control a covered portion of the business when it contains either an opening in a partition that facilitates a sexual act or a fee-based viewing booth that is not sufficiently open, visible, and lighted. The statute is about the operator’s relationship to the premises and the design of the viewing area—not simply about whether an adult business exists.

The title can make the accusation sound far broader than the text. Section 12.1-20-24 does not criminalize every adult-oriented store, every video service, or every private room. It defines the facility, identifies two prohibited configurations, creates a specific private-office exception, and separately authorizes an injunction for a pattern of violations. A defense should measure the actual room, business model, control arrangements, lighting, sight lines, fees, and alleged notice against those words.

Fargo and Cass County focus: Before repairing or remodeling the area, preserve dated photographs, video, measurements, floor plans, lease documents, inspection correspondence, lighting conditions, signage, access rules, and point-of-sale records. A prompt safety correction may be sensible, but the original condition must be documented accurately.

What does North Dakota’s public-sexual-acts facilitation law prohibit?

The first statutory configuration is a partition between subdivisions of a room or area containing an opening that facilitates a sexual act between people on opposite sides. The second is a room, booth, stall, or partitioned area offered for a fee as an incident to viewing a video, motion picture, or similar entertainment unless at least one side is open to adjacent public space and the viewing area is lighted so people inside are visible from that space.

The State should not be permitted to prove the charge with the business’s reputation or adult inventory alone. It must prove the statutory kind of commercial facility, the defendant’s specified connection to the relevant portion, the prohibited physical condition, and willful conduct. No located reported North Dakota Supreme Court opinion has construed every phrase in § 12.1-20-24, so counsel should preserve text-based objections and avoid importing an unrelated local licensing rule into the criminal elements.

The elements must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt

An infraction is still an offense. N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-03.1 generally applies criminal procedure, the presumption of innocence, and the State’s burden of proof. A citation or complaint should identify the relevant premises, the defendant’s role, which statutory configuration is alleged, and the date. A vague allegation that an operator “allowed private booths” may not disclose whether the prosecution relies on a partition opening, an enclosed viewing space, or both.

1. A qualifying adult entertainment center

The facility must be commercial and must offer, for viewing at the facility, motion pictures or videos that include explicit representations of sexual conduct. The definition does not turn on the name over the door. A store calling itself an arcade may qualify if its actual operation fits; a business described colloquially as “adult entertainment” may fall outside the section if it does not offer the specified visual material for on-site viewing.

The Code expressly excludes hotel and motel guest rooms. That exclusion does not necessarily remove a separate commercial video-viewing area merely because it is inside a hotel building, and it does not immunize conduct prohibited by another statute. The location, function, access, and payment structure require evidence.

2. The accused’s relationship to the portion at issue

The person must willfully own, rent, lease, manage, or exercise control of the relevant portion. Ownership of the building and operation of the business are not always the same. A landlord may lease space without controlling its interior configuration; a corporate investor may lack operational authority; a manager may control daily access without owning the property; and a maintenance contractor may perform work without managing the area. Contracts, keys, authority to remodel, staffing responsibility, and actual decision-making matter.

3. A prohibited physical configuration

The State must prove either subsection 2(a) or 2(b). Those alternatives should not be blurred. A partition-opening theory requires an opening that facilitates a statutorily defined sexual act between people on the two sides. A booth theory requires a fee-based viewing area and the absence of the required openness and lighting. The second alternative does not say that an actual sexual act must have occurred.

4. Willful conduct

North Dakota defines “willfully” to include intentional, knowing, or reckless conduct. The State must connect that culpability to the accused and the relevant circumstances. Mere title, constructive ownership, or a condition created moments earlier by a customer may not establish willfulness.

Definitions narrow the charge

Adult entertainment center

The statutory definition requires a commercial facility and explicit motion pictures or videos offered for viewing there. Content sold for off-premises use is not identical to content offered for on-site viewing. A prosecutor should identify the media, the method of access, where it was viewed, and the commercial arrangement. Free promotional displays, employee training, live performance, ordinary cable television, and internet access raise text-specific questions that cannot be answered by a label alone.

Sexual conduct

Section 12.1-20-24 incorporates the meaning in N.D.C.C. § 12.1-27.1-01. That cross-reference defines the explicit content relevant to whether a facility qualifies. The evidence should show what was actually offered, not just that equipment could access material somewhere on the internet.

Sexual act

The partition-opening provision incorporates the meaning in § 12.1-20-02. Counsel should use the current definition applicable on the alleged date and insist that a claimed opening be capable of facilitating conduct within that definition. An ordinary service opening, ventilation gap, damaged panel, or sight hole does not become the statutory condition merely because it is located in an adult business.

Person

Title 12.1’s general definition may include an organization where relevant. Corporate responsibility and an individual agent’s responsibility are distinct questions under chapter 12.1-03. The prosecution should not treat the company, property owner, employee, and manager as interchangeable. The complaint and evidence should identify who allegedly acted willfully and how.

The two prohibited configurations

Partition openings that facilitate a sexual act

Subsection 2(a) covers an opening in a partition between subdivisions of a room or area when that opening facilitates a sexual act between individuals on opposite sides. The physical details matter: height, size, shape, placement, permanence, surrounding fixtures, access to each side, and whether the opening actually connects two subdivisions. Photographs taken straight on may misrepresent depth or accessibility, so measurements and multiple angles are important.

The statute does not require the prosecution to use slang, and a charge should not be decided through moral rhetoric. It requires proof that the opening facilitates the defined act. Evidence of design, repeated use, operator instructions, customer reports, surveillance, cleaning protocols, or prior notice may be relevant. So may innocent design purposes, immediate repairs, lack of access to one side, or an opening created without the operator’s knowledge.

Fee-based viewing rooms, booths, stalls, and partitions

Subsection 2(b) reaches a room, booth, stall, or partitioned part of a room offered to individuals for a fee as an incident to viewing covered entertainment. Payment can be direct or part of a broader transaction, but the State should prove the connection between the fee and the viewing space. A storage room, restroom, employee area, or ordinary retail fitting room is not transformed into the statutory viewing area because a customer played a video on a personal phone.

A covered viewing area avoids this branch when it satisfies both design conditions: at least one side is open to adjacent public space so the inside is visible to people there, and the viewing area is lighted so its occupants are visible from that public space. “Open,” “adjacent public space,” “visible,” and “lighted” are fact questions informed by the actual layout. A narrow doorway with a curtain, a dark hallway, an opaque half-door, glare, shelving, or a camera feed may not be equivalent to an open and visible side.

Temporary conditions

A customer may hang a coat, move a display, cover a light, damage a panel, or block a sight line. The State still must prove the defendant’s willful ownership, management, or control of the prohibited condition. Duration, notice, inspection practice, staff response, and authority to correct the condition help distinguish a momentary customer act from a managed configuration.

What “willfully” means in North Dakota

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-02-02(1)(e) provides that a person acts willfully when acting intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly. Recklessness is more than ordinary carelessness: it involves conscious and clearly unjustifiable disregard of a substantial likelihood of the relevant facts or risks, amounting to a gross deviation from acceptable standards.

State v. Roller, 2024 ND 180, ¶¶ 13–15, applies the Code definition and explains that intentional conduct is included within willful conduct. In a § 12.1-20-24 case, the instructions and arguments should identify the conduct and circumstances to which willfulness applies. The word should not become an empty presumption based on business ownership.

Evidence of written warnings, prior inspections, repeated customer complaints, instructions to employees, repair orders, photographs, or deliberate concealment may support the State. Evidence of a recent defect, prompt correction, no authority over the space, inaccurate notice, a reasonable inspection system, or an area outside the defendant’s responsibility may cut the other way. The question is the accused’s culpability at the charged time.

State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8, ¶¶ 10–18, reinforces that statutory culpability must be given real effect. A court should not rewrite a willful offense as strict premises liability merely because compliance can be evaluated through physical measurements.

The private-office exclusion

Subsection 3 states that the section does not apply to an enclosure that is private office space used by the owner, manager, or employees if the office is not held out or available to the public for fee-based viewing of a video, motion picture, or similar entertainment. Both use and availability matter. A room labeled “office” is not necessarily excluded if customers routinely rent it for viewing; an actual back office does not lose the exclusion merely because it contains a computer monitor.

Evidence can include door signage, locks, staff-only policies, employee schedules, inventory, office furniture, customer access records, payment menus, surveillance, and testimony about actual practice. The defense should preserve evidence of how the enclosure was used on ordinary days, not stage it after an inspection.

The exclusion should be analyzed before broad constitutional arguments. If the area is a genuine private office not offered to the public for fee-based viewing, the statutory text may resolve the charge. If facts are disputed, the parties may need a site diagram and witness testimony rather than competing descriptions.

Inspections, photographs, surveillance, and search issues

Cases may begin with a health inspection, licensing visit, fire inspection, employee report, customer complaint, undercover visit, or law-enforcement search. The legal authority and scope differ. A business open to the public generally exposes public areas to observation, but that does not automatically authorize entry into locked offices, opening containers, accessing computers, or extending an administrative inspection into an unlimited criminal search.

State v. Quam, 2026 ND 145, ¶¶ 9–18, addresses the need for a probable-cause nexus in a digital search. If investigators seize point-of-sale data, internal messages, remote cameras, or phones, the warrant should connect those categories and date ranges to the suspected offense.

Third-party consent also requires care. A cashier may admit an inspector to the retail floor without having authority over a landlord’s locked mechanical room or an owner’s password-protected device. State v. Gietzen, 2024 ND 5, ¶¶ 7–15, explains that actual or apparent authority and the scope of consent depend on known facts.

Visual evidence needs context

A photograph freezes one angle and one lighting condition. The defense should obtain original files and metadata, identify whether flash or exposure correction was used, and compare the image with measurements and video from a person walking through the adjacent public space. State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 20–26, explains the authentication threshold; authenticity does not prevent cross-examination about angle, completeness, or what an image fairly depicts.

Business records need a foundation

Lease records, payment histories, inspection logs, and exported surveillance may be relevant to control and fee-based use. State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 9–24, requires proper authentication and a sufficient regularly-conducted-activity foundation. A police-created summary of transactions is not automatically the business record itself.

A pattern can support an injunction

Subsection 4 authorizes the North Dakota Department of Health and Human Services or the state’s attorney with jurisdiction to bring an action to enjoin a pattern of violations. This is distinct from prosecuting one infraction. “Pattern” ordinarily requires more than an isolated condition, and the government should identify the acts, dates, locations, notice, and persons it says establish repetition.

An injunction can have more serious business consequences than the fine. It may compel structural changes, restrict use of portions of the premises, impose compliance duties, or expose a person to contempt if a court order is later violated. The operator must understand the proposed wording, inspection provisions, duration, affected entities, and whether the order reaches conduct beyond the statute.

Due process still matters. State Board of Architecture v. Kirkham, Michael & Associates, Inc., 2003 ND 133, ¶¶ 6–9, begins statutory injunction analysis with the enacted language and ordinary meaning. Section 12.1-20-24 specifically identifies who may sue and what predicate—a pattern of violations—must exist.

Prompt voluntary compliance may affect practical negotiations, but it does not necessarily moot a filed case or admit the historical allegation. Corrective work should be documented and described carefully. A consent decree can carry reporting and enforcement consequences beyond a simple repair agreement.

Speech, vagueness, and local regulation

Adult expressive material can implicate the First Amendment, but § 12.1-20-24 regulates specified premises configurations rather than banning a viewpoint or all adult media. Constitutional analysis depends on the charge, application, evidence, available alternative channels, and any overlapping local ordinance. A business should not assume that mentioning adult videos ends the inquiry—or that every physical-layout rule is immune from challenge.

A vagueness challenge examines whether the statute gives adequate notice and supplies standards for enforcement. Terms such as “open,” “visible,” “adjacent public space,” “offered,” and “facilitates” should be applied to concrete facts, measurements, and ordinary meaning. Selective or inconsistent enforcement can matter, but disagreement with an inspector’s preference is not itself a constitutional violation.

State and local rules may coexist. Fargo zoning, licensing, building, fire, nuisance, and business regulations can impose requirements separate from § 12.1-20-24. Compliance with one does not necessarily establish compliance with all, and a local violation does not automatically prove the state infraction. The charging instrument should identify the legal authority actually alleged.

RMM Properties v. City of Minot, 2024 ND 213, describes the limited judicial review applicable to a local governing body’s land-use decision. Although it does not involve adult entertainment, it illustrates why a zoning appeal and a criminal defense must be handled through their own records and standards.

Penalty, procedure, and repeat infractions

The ordinary violation is an infraction with a maximum fine of $1,000. There is ordinarily no incarceration for an infraction. Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-01(7), however, a person who committed the charged infraction after at least two prior convictions for the same infraction within the preceding year may be sentenced as for a Class B misdemeanor. If the prosecution seeks misdemeanor treatment, the complaint must say so.

A person charged only with an ordinary non-jailable infraction generally is not entitled to appointed counsel at public expense or a jury trial under § 12.1-32-03.1. That does not make the matter insignificant. The proceeding remains criminal in nature, proof beyond a reasonable doubt applies, and a conviction may affect business licensing, leases, financing, insurance, reputation, and a later injunction request.

An organization may face different fine provisions and special sanctions. The State may also pursue an individual agent if the statutory requirements for personal accountability are met. Counsel should determine whether the citation names the company, a person, or both, and whether service, appearance, and authorization are proper.

Do not confuse this layout infraction with fornication in a public place, indecent exposure, obscenity, prostitution, disorderly conduct, or local nuisance rules. Those offenses have different conduct, culpability, classifications, and defenses. An actual sexual act may prompt a separate charge even when the operator disputes responsibility under § 12.1-20-24.

Defense issues to investigate

  • The facility does not meet the definition. Covered explicit videos were not offered for viewing at that commercial facility.
  • The defendant lacked the required relationship. The accused did not own, rent, lease, manage, or control the portion cited.
  • No willfulness. The condition was unknown, newly created, outside the accused’s authority, or not consciously disregarded.
  • No qualifying opening. The physical opening did not connect relevant subdivisions or facilitate a statutorily defined sexual act.
  • No fee-based viewing area. The room was not offered for a fee incident to viewing covered entertainment.
  • The visibility requirements were met. One side was open to adjacent public space and occupants were visible under the actual lighting.
  • Private-office exclusion. The enclosure was used by ownership, management, or staff and was not available to customers for paid viewing.
  • Unlawful or unreliable evidence. The inspection or search exceeded lawful scope, and photographs, records, or summaries lack foundation or context.
  • No pattern. An isolated alleged condition does not establish the repeated violations needed for subsection 4 injunctive relief.

Correcting a condition is often prudent, especially when health or safety is implicated, but it should not be described carelessly as an admission. Counsel can preserve the original state, coordinate remediation, respond to agencies, and contest the historical elements at the same time.

North Dakota decisions relevant to the defense

No located reported North Dakota Supreme Court decision directly resolves all elements of § 12.1-20-24. These official decisions address principles likely to matter in a prosecution or companion injunction.

State v. Roller, 2024 ND 180

“Willfully” includes intentional, knowing, and reckless conduct. The culpability instruction must track the Code and charged conduct.

State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8

Statutory words and culpability requirements require independent effect; courts should not convert a willful offense into strict liability.

State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83

Photographs, recordings, and other exhibits may be authenticated circumstantially, while completeness and weight remain disputed.

State v. Gietzen, 2024 ND 5

Consent searches depend on actual or apparent authority and scope; access to premises does not convey authority over everything inside.

State v. Ochoa, 2004 ND 43

Informant information is evaluated through basis of knowledge, reliability, corroboration, and the totality supporting probable cause.

What to do after a citation or inspection

  1. Preserve the cited condition. Take dated photographs and continuous walk-through video from public and private vantage points; record dimensions and light levels if feasible.
  2. Identify the legal theory. Determine whether the citation alleges a partition opening, an enclosed paid viewing area, repeat-infraction enhancement, or a pattern supporting an injunction.
  3. Map control. Collect deeds, leases, subleases, management contracts, corporate documents, work orders, keys, and communications showing responsibility for the portion.
  4. Document business operation. Preserve media systems, payment menus, access rules, point-of-sale data, customer policies, signage, and evidence of on-site versus off-site use.
  5. Reconstruct notice. Gather prior inspections, warnings, complaints, repair requests, employee reports, and responses relevant to willfulness.
  6. Audit the government’s evidence. Obtain original photographs, video, measurements, notes, warrants, consent forms, citations, and witness identities.
  7. Remediate safely. Address genuine safety or compliance issues while preserving evidence and avoiding inaccurate admissions.
  8. Coordinate all proceedings. A criminal answer, licensing response, zoning appeal, and injunction defense should use a consistent, accurate factual record.

Official authorities

Source note: Verify the charged date, the current Century Code, the precise local ordinance or license condition, and the official opinion before relying on a summary.

Get advice before responding to the citation or injunction demand

A $1,000 infraction can become the factual basis for a licensing case, repeat allegation, or injunction threatening the business. A Fargo defense lawyer can inspect the actual layout, preserve the evidence, separate property ownership from operational control, evaluate willfulness, and coordinate any correction with the criminal and regulatory response.


Call nowChoose a time