Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Fargo Interference with Telephone During Emergency Call Defense

North Dakota makes it a crime to remove, damage, or obstruct a telephone, telephone line, or connected apparatus—or sever a connected wire—so as to…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota Emergency-Communication Interference Defense Guide

Fargo Interference with Telephone During Emergency Call Defense

North Dakota makes it a crime to remove, damage, or obstruct a telephone, telephone line, or connected apparatus—or sever a connected wire—so as to interfere with an emergency telephone call. The grade turns on culpability: intentional interference is a Class C felony; knowing or reckless interference is a Class A misdemeanor.

The statute is narrower than a general accusation that someone “stopped a 911 call.” The State must prove the specified conduct involving a telephone system and its connection to an emergency call, along with the mental state supporting the selected grade. A dropped phone, ended call, disconnected router, dead battery, poor signal, struggle over a device, or demand to stop calling does not answer those elements by itself.

This guide is general information, not legal advice for an individual matter, and creates no attorney-client relationship.

North Dakota’s Emergency-Call Interference Statute

N.D.C.C. § 12.1-21-06.1 applies when a person removes, damages, or obstructs a telephone or telephone line, any part or apparatus on the line, or severs a connected wire, so as to interfere with an emergency telephone call. The Legislature enacted the offense in 1999, and the current text preserves the same basic act-and-grade structure.

The offense is a Class C felony when done intentionally and a Class A misdemeanor when done knowingly or recklessly. Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-01, the ordinary maximum for Class C is five years and a $10,000 fine; Class A misdemeanor exposure is 360 days and a $3,000 fine. These ceilings are not predictions.

Words the charge should identify

A useful charging audit asks: What telephone, line, wire, part, or apparatus was involved? Was it removed, damaged, obstructed, or severed? What emergency call existed or was attempted? How did the act interfere? Did the accused act intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly? A complaint that merely says the accused “prevented 911” may conceal missing statutory detail.

Related charges

The same event may generate domestic violence, assault, unlawful restraint, criminal mischief, terrorizing, protection-order violation, or evidence-tampering allegations. Each charge requires separate proof. The emergency-call offense should not become a substitute for proving an assault, and an assault allegation should not automatically prove interference.

Domestic-violence context

Many allegations arise during household or relationship conflict, but the statute is not limited to domestic cases. It can apply to medical emergencies, fires, crashes, workplace incidents, crimes, and other calls. When domestic-violence designations or programming provisions are invoked, counsel should examine the statutory basis and the disposition’s collateral consequences.

What the State Must Prove

Identity

The State must prove the accused performed the act. A caller may be frightened, distracted, injured, or unable to see who disconnected a line. Shared devices, chaotic scenes, speakerphone, Bluetooth, and multiple people can complicate identification. Audio, video, device logs, fingerprints where meaningful, witnesses, admissions, and the physical condition should be compared.

A telephone-related object covered by the statute

The text identifies a telephone, telephone line, part or apparatus on the line, and connected wire. Traditional wall phones fit easily. Modern mobile phones, internet calling, cordless handsets, charging cables, routers, base stations, and wireless accessories raise fact and interpretation questions. The State should identify how the object fits the enacted language rather than assume every communications device is self-evidently covered.

One of the specified acts

The accused must remove, damage, or obstruct the covered object, or sever a connected wire. “Damage” and “sever” concern physical conditions. “Remove” and “obstruct” may be broader, but still must be tied to the telephone or apparatus. Verbal persuasion, lying, blocking a person, or taking some unrelated object may support another charge without necessarily satisfying this section.

Interference with an emergency telephone call

The specified act must interfere with the call. The call may already be connected or may be in the process of being made, depending on the facts and legal interpretation. The State should establish the emergency nature, timing, call status, device status, and causal relationship. If dispatch already received location and essential information, later disconnection may still be interference, but its significance and causation require evidence.

The charged mental state

The act must be intentional, knowing, or reckless at the appropriate grade. Accident, negligence, or an unrelated purpose is insufficient. The State may use words, physical actions, repetition, observation of the screen, prior knowledge, the call audio, and conduct afterward, but the grade cannot be inferred solely from the seriousness of the emergency.

Intentional, Knowing, and Reckless Interference

Intentional Class C felony

Intentional conduct requires the conscious object or purpose connected to the prohibited result under North Dakota’s general culpability framework. The prosecution may argue that grabbing and smashing a phone after hearing “911,” pulling a wall cord while dispatch is speaking, or repeatedly disabling devices after calls restart proves purpose to interfere. Context remains essential.

Knowing Class A misdemeanor

Knowing conduct differs from purpose. A person may act with awareness that interference is practically certain even if the person’s broader purpose is to leave, retrieve property, stop recording, or end an argument. The defense should identify exactly what the accused perceived and what result the person understood would follow.

Reckless Class A misdemeanor

Recklessness involves conscious disregard of a substantial and unjustifiable risk. A struggle over a phone, throwing an object near equipment, unplugging a router during an obvious emergency, or pulling a line without checking may be alleged as reckless. The State still must prove conscious disregard, not ordinary carelessness.

Willful is not the grading word here

Some police reports use “willfully” as a generic description. The statute instead specifies intentional, knowing, or reckless grading. State v. Roller, 2024 ND 180, ¶¶ 12–15, explains relationships among culpability terms in another statute, including that “intentional conduct is a subset of willful conduct.” The charging document here should still use the actual culpability alleged under § 12.1-21-06.1.

Grade-specific verdict

When felony and misdemeanor culpability are both supported by some evidence, instructions and the verdict form should allow a clear finding. A general verdict that does not reveal whether jurors unanimously found intent can complicate sentencing and review. Lesser-offense instructions require both legal inclusion and a rational evidentiary basis.

What Makes the Telephone Call an Emergency Call?

The section does not provide an internal definition. The call’s content and circumstances ordinarily matter: a request for police, fire, ambulance, rescue, or other urgent help; a report of current violence, medical distress, fire, crash, threat, or danger; and information known to the accused. A call to a friend about a past disagreement is not transformed into an emergency call merely because 911 was mentioned later.

Connected calls

Dispatch records can establish dial time, answer, duration, audio, location, transfers, callback, and response. A caller may whisper, leave a line open, disconnect accidentally, or be unable to answer questions. The defense should obtain the native recording and computer-aided dispatch record rather than rely on an officer’s summary.

Attempted calls

A device log may show 9-1-1 digits, an emergency-SOS activation, a failed attempt, or no outgoing event. Whether interference with an attempted call satisfies the statute depends on the exact facts and governing interpretation. The State should not claim a completed emergency call if the device evidence contradicts it; the defense should not assume failure to connect eliminates every theory.

Calls already conveying essential information

If dispatch already knows the address and nature of the emergency, disconnection can still delay updates, safety instructions, medical guidance, suspect description, or occupant information. The statutory question is interference, not whether responders ultimately arrived. Prompt callback and complete information may affect proof, harm, mitigation, and causation.

False or non-emergency calls

If the caller deliberately misuses 911 or no objective emergency exists, the accused’s knowledge and the call’s legal character may be disputed. A person should not physically disable a phone based on a unilateral conclusion that help is unnecessary. The defense must examine what the accused knew, what the caller communicated, and the statutory meaning—not simply attack the caller.

Applying a 1999 Statute to Modern Communication

Mobile phones

A smartphone is plainly used as a telephone, but the alleged act still must be specified. Taking it, throwing it, powering it off, locking it, removing a battery where possible, breaking a screen, or disabling service present different proof. A cracked screen may not interrupt a call; a phone taken from one hand may remain connected through a watch or car.

Internet and Wi-Fi calling

Some calls travel through a router or internet connection. Unplugging power or disconnecting a modem may be alleged as obstruction of apparatus on the line. The defense should develop how the system actually worked, whether cellular fallback existed, what the accused knew, and whether the act caused the disconnection.

Emergency SOS and connected devices

Phones, watches, vehicles, and home systems can initiate emergency contact automatically or through button sequences. Logs may show activation, cancellation, location, crash detection, or callback. An accidental cancellation differs from knowingly dismissing a visible emergency session. Product documentation and forensic data can be more reliable than memory.

Bluetooth and speakerphone

A phone may be across the room while audio routes through earbuds, a vehicle, speaker, or watch. A witness can believe the handset was “disconnected” while dispatch still recorded audio. The State and defense should obtain full recordings and connection data when available.

Dead batteries, poor signal, and network failure

Not every dropped call was caused by a person. Battery level, device health, carrier records, signal, tower handoff, Wi-Fi, airplane mode, damaged hardware, location, and software can explain failure. A later-broken phone does not establish that damage interrupted the earlier call.

Fact Patterns That Require Different Element Findings

Phone taken before any number is dialed

A caller may testify that she announced an intention to call 911 and the accused immediately took the phone. The State may argue removal obstructed an emergency call before connection. The defense should determine whether the statute reaches the alleged attempted call on those facts, whether an emergency actually existed, what appeared on the screen, what the accused heard, and whether another phone remained available. The case should not be described as a disconnected completed call if dispatch records show no call.

The accused’s purpose also matters to grade. Taking a phone specifically to prevent emergency contact can support an intent inference. Taking it during a dispute over ownership, recording, messages, or possession may still create risk but does not automatically establish the conscious object required for a felony. Full video, messages, prior use, ownership, and immediate conduct can distinguish competing explanations.

Connected 911 call during a physical struggle

Audio may capture voices, movement, a warning from dispatch, impact, and sudden disconnection. The prosecution may argue the accused knew exactly what was happening. Yet the recording can also show that both people grabbed the device, it struck the floor, Bluetooth disconnected, or the caller accidentally ended the call. A forensic extraction and inspection can test whether a button press, power loss, network event, or physical damage ended it.

If the accused deliberately throws the phone after hearing the dispatcher, felony intent may be strongly disputed but supported by circumstantial evidence. If the accused reaches for a different object and knocks the phone away, accident may be credible. If the person consciously wrestles over the device without a purpose to interrupt the call, misdemeanor recklessness or knowledge may be the State’s alternative. The verdict must preserve these distinctions.

Phone removed but the call stays connected

A person may take a handset and carry it away while dispatch continues to hear audio or communicate through speakerphone, a watch, a vehicle, or another connected device. The statutory question is interference, which can include more than complete disconnection, but the State should identify what communication was impeded. Did the caller lose the ability to answer? Did dispatch lose location or receive distorted information? Did the act have no effect at all?

Native audio is essential. A report saying “he took the phone and ended the call” can be contradicted by a ten-minute open-line recording. Conversely, an open line can still reflect serious interference when the caller is deprived of the handset and cannot provide medical instructions or a suspect description. Precise facts serve both sides better than a binary connected/disconnected label.

Router or base station unplugged

In homes using Wi-Fi calling or a cordless base, unplugging power can stop telephone service without touching the handset. The State may characterize the router, modem, base, or cord as apparatus on the line or an obstruction. The defense should obtain network design, cellular coverage, device settings, logs, outage history, and testimony explaining what actually carried the call. A person who unplugs a router to reset internet service without awareness of an emergency presents a different culpability question from someone who pulls power after hearing dispatch.

Call ends, then the phone is damaged

Timing can defeat causation. A caller may voluntarily end a conversation, then the phone is broken during a later argument. The damage can support criminal mischief or another allegation while failing to interfere with the completed emergency call. Call-detail records, audio end time, video, body-camera observations, and device events should be synchronized rather than relying on approximate memory.

Emergency SOS canceled by mistake

Modern phones can trigger SOS from repeated button presses, crashes, or device settings. A person may cancel an accidental alarm without knowing a genuine emergency exists, or may knowingly cancel another person’s request. System logs, screen prompts, product design, prior activations, spoken words, and the surrounding event bear on intent, knowledge, and recklessness. A software label saying “user canceled” identifies a device event, not necessarily which person acted or why.

Multiple phones and a successful alternative call

Successful contact from another device does not automatically erase interference with the first call. It can, however, affect causation, duration, harm, credibility, mitigation, and the reasonableness of inferences. The prosecution should prove the particular call and device named in the charge; the defense should document when the alternative call began, what information was transmitted, and whether the accused knew emergency help had already been summoned.

Evidence That Commonly Decides the Case

911 audio and dispatch data

The recording may capture the caller, accused, struggle, warnings, disconnection, background events, and callbacks. In State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 7–24, the Supreme Court held a 911 call properly authenticated and addressed present-sense-impression hearsay and confrontation on its record. It stated authentication requires evidence sufficient to support a finding the item is what the proponent claims.

Different statements within one call may have different primary purposes. Statements seeking help during an ongoing emergency are analyzed differently from later statements aimed at proving past events. The declarant’s availability, dispatch questions, timing, and circumstances matter.

Device forensics

Call logs, system events, battery data, screen activity, lock status, damage, photographs, cloud records, emergency-SOS data, Bluetooth, and location can test the narrative. Forensic collection should preserve source data and time settings. Screenshots can omit deleted, failed, or system-generated entries and may not establish who used the device.

Body cameras and scene photographs

Video may show where the phone was found, its condition, who possessed it, spontaneous statements, and the physical scene. Recording begins after the call, so later condition is not automatically earlier condition. Officers should photograph cables, ports, bases, routers, wall jacks, and damage before moving equipment.

Witness testimony

The caller, dispatcher, other occupants, neighbors, and responders may describe the call and act. Stress, divided attention, intoxication, injury, darkness, and prior conflict affect perception. The defense should compare the first account with later reports without assuming every inconsistency is deliberate.

Admissions and messages

Statements such as “I stopped you from calling” can be significant if authentic and complete. An apology may acknowledge taking a phone without admitting knowledge of an emergency call. Full threads, account identity, context, sarcasm, and timing matter.

Other-act and relationship evidence

The State may seek evidence of prior violence, calls, threats, or phone interference. Relevance, permissible purpose, notice, unfair prejudice, and limiting instructions should be examined. A defendant should be tried on the charged event, not a generalized relationship narrative.

Defense Issues

No covered physical act

Words, argument, refusal to lend a personal phone, or movement unrelated to telephone apparatus may not satisfy the listed acts. The State must prove removal, damage, obstruction, or severing as applied to the covered object.

No emergency call

The evidence may show a non-emergency conversation, a call after danger ended, no dial attempt, or a device screen misunderstood by a witness. Dispatch and device records should be obtained before accepting a characterization.

No interference

The phone may remain connected, dispatch may hear everything, the call may end before the act, or network failure may cause disconnection. The act must interfere with the emergency telephone call, not merely occur near it.

Accident

A phone can drop during a struggle, cable can detach, battery can die, and a call can fail without intentional, knowing, or reckless interference. Video, audio, device data, damage pattern, and immediate conduct may support accident.

Lack of required culpability

The accused may not know a call is in progress or an emergency exists. A person may move a phone to prevent recording, retrieve owned property, or clear a hazard without awareness that emergency communications will be obstructed. Those purposes do not automatically defeat knowing or reckless proof, but they make mental state a factual issue.

Wrong actor

Several people may be near a shared phone or router. A caller who cannot see may infer who disconnected it. Original audio, video, fingerprints where useful, possession, access, and statements should be tested.

Felony intent not proved

Evidence may support awareness or conscious risk without proving purpose to interfere. The defense can seek acquittal entirely and, in the alternative, argue the State has not proved Class C intent. The verdict form should preserve that distinction.

Unlawful search or inadmissible proof

Phones, cloud records, carrier information, homes, and messages raise warrant, consent, scope, and authentication issues. Statements require voluntariness and applicable Miranda compliance. Calls and out-of-court assertions face hearsay and confrontation analysis.

North Dakota Authorities

No reported North Dakota Supreme Court opinion located for this guide squarely construes every element of § 12.1-21-06.1. The current statute and general evidence and culpability decisions should be used precisely rather than presenting unrelated cases as offense-specific holdings.

State v. Burton

State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 7–24, is the principal recent official source for authentication, hearsay, and confrontation involving a 911 call. It involved domestic violence, not telephone interference. Its evidentiary rules apply according to the particular statements and record.

State v. Ruot

State v. Ruot, 2024 ND 205, ¶ 3, summarily addressed testimony referring to a 911 call. The Court noted the call itself was already admitted and upheld the ruling under the preserved posture. The short opinion illustrates why trial objections and requested relief must be precise.

State v. Roller

State v. Roller, 2024 ND 180, ¶¶ 12–15, discusses North Dakota culpability concepts in another offense. It does not decide § 12.1-21-06.1, but its explanation of intentional, knowing, reckless, and willful terminology helps prevent casual substitution of one mental state for another.

State v. Smith

State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127, ¶¶ 8–10, states the same-elements framework for multiple convictions and lesser-included analysis. When emergency-call interference accompanies assault, restraint, or criminal mischief charges, counsel must compare exact statutory elements rather than assume merger from shared evidence.

1999 enactment

The official 1999 session law enacted the same core description and intentional-versus-knowing-or-reckless grade structure. Legislative text provides authority for what was enacted, but it does not resolve every modern-device question. Those questions should be briefed from text, definitions, culpability law, and the technology proved.

Fargo Felony or Misdemeanor Procedure

First appearance and release

The court advises the accused of the grade and rights and addresses release. In relationship cases, no-contact and residence restrictions are common. They remain enforceable even if the caller invites communication.

Preliminary hearing in a felony case

When intentional Class C interference is charged, a preliminary hearing may test probable cause unless waived or resolved. It can identify the State’s act, device, emergency call, causation, and intent evidence. The burden is lower than at trial.

Discovery

Discovery should include native 911 audio, dispatch, caller data, callbacks, body cameras, reports, photos, the device, forensic extraction, carrier records, video, messages, witnesses, warrants, and alleged related offenses. The defense should preserve devices and accounts without altering them.

Motions

Motions may address device searches, home entry, statements, call authentication, hearsay, confrontation, other-act evidence, expert testimony, and unclear charging language. A targeted motion should explain how the ruling affects an element or fair trial.

Negotiation

Possible resolutions include dismissal, misdemeanor reduction, another charge, deferred imposition, probation, programming, restitution, or trial. A plea factual basis should identify the covered act, apparatus, emergency call, interference, mental state, and grade. It should not rely on the vague phrase “stopped a call.”

Trial and verdict form

The instructions should track the statutory acts and distinguish intent from knowledge and recklessness. When Class C and Class A grades are submitted, the verdict should reveal the unanimous culpability finding. Separate accompanying charges require separate element findings.

Sentencing and collateral consequences

A felony can affect firearms, employment, licensing, housing, immigration, and future sentencing. Even a misdemeanor can have serious relationship and background-check consequences. Sentencing preparation may address context, treatment, programming, record, employment, caregiving, restitution, acceptance, and device damage while correcting unsupported allegations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is interfering with a 911 call a felony?

It is a Class C felony if done intentionally. It is a Class A misdemeanor if done knowingly or recklessly.

What are the maximum penalties?

Class C ordinarily carries up to five years and a $10,000 fine; Class A misdemeanor carries up to 360 days and a $3,000 fine.

Does the call have to connect?

The statute concerns interference with an emergency telephone call. Attempted-call facts require close analysis of the text, device data, and prosecution theory; do not assume connection is irrelevant or always required.

Does the phone have to be broken?

No. The statute also lists removal and obstruction, as well as damage and severing a connected wire. The State must prove a listed act and interference.

Is taking a phone always enough?

No. The State must connect removal to interference with an emergency call and prove the required mental state. Timing and awareness matter.

What if dispatch already had the address?

Disconnection may still interfere with updates or instructions, but the completed information can affect the evidence, harm, and mitigation. The entire recording and dispatch record should be reviewed.

What if the call dropped because of poor service?

Network failure, battery, software, and signal can defeat causation. Carrier, device, Wi-Fi, location, and call records may distinguish technical failure from human interference.

Can grabbing a phone during a struggle be reckless?

Possibly, if the State proves conscious disregard of a substantial unjustifiable risk of interference. Accident or negligence alone is insufficient.

Can this charge accompany domestic violence?

Yes. It often does, but each charge requires separate proof. The emergency-call count does not establish an assault by itself.

Can 911 audio be admitted if the caller does not testify?

Sometimes. Authentication, hearsay exceptions, and confrontation depend on the statements and circumstances. State v. Burton provides current guidance.

Can police search my phone?

A warrant, valid consent, or another exception is generally required depending on the search. Scope, extraction method, cloud data, and seizure duration should be reviewed.

What if I did not know it was an emergency?

Lack of awareness may defeat intent or knowledge and affect recklessness. The call audio, words, screen, surroundings, and conduct are central.

Is the misdemeanor automatically a lesser offense?

The grades share core conduct but differ in culpability. The legal and evidentiary requirements for a lesser instruction should be evaluated in the specific case.

Can device damage be ordered as restitution?

Potentially, if directly caused by the offense and supported. Repair, value, insurance, prior damage, and duplicate recovery can be disputed.

Should I contact the caller to explain?

Not if a no-contact order prohibits it. Even without an order, the communication may create evidence or a new allegation. Speak with counsel first.

Can the record later be sealed?

Possibly, depending on the final grade, disposition, history, eligibility, waiting rules, and law then in effect. It is not automatic.

Primary Authorities


Call nowChoose a time