Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Field Sobriety Tests in North Dakota

Field sobriety tests are roadside observations, not a laboratory measurement and not a medical diagnosis. When an officer uses the standardized battery…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota field sobriety tests, Fargo DUI lawyer, horizontal gaze nystagmus, HGN test, walk-and-turn test, one-leg stand, roadside video, NHTSA SFST manual, medical conditions, DUI probable cause, drug impairment, and field sobriety defense

Field Sobriety Tests in North Dakota

Field sobriety tests are roadside observations, not a laboratory measurement and not a medical diagnosis. When an officer uses the standardized battery, the value of the evidence depends on whether the right tests were given to a suitable person, under workable conditions, with the trained instructions, timing, stimulus placement, scoring, and interpretation.

The defense should never accept “failed field sobriety tests” as a complete description. The recording must be compared clue by clue with the report and the governing training. The location, weather, footwear, surface, age, injury, vision, hearing, language, anxiety, fatigue, and drug or medical issues can change what the performance fairly proves.

Get the original video before analyzing the score. Preserve every squad, body, booking, station, and bystander recording; the dispatch and stop timeline; officer notes and worksheets; training records; the manual and refresher materials in effect; photographs or measurements of the surface; footwear; and relevant medical records. A written conclusion cannot substitute for the event itself.

The standardized tests have a defined investigative role

The standardized battery contains three tests

The NHTSA DWI Detection and Standardized Field Sobriety Testing participant manual teaches horizontal gaze nystagmus, walk-and-turn, and one-leg stand as a three-test battery. HGN is an eye observation. Walk-and-turn and one-leg stand are divided-attention psychophysical exercises.

Alphabet recitation, backward counting, finger counting, Romberg balance, finger-to-nose, modified balance, lack-of-convergence, and other exercises may appear in an alcohol or drug investigation. They are not automatically part of the standardized alcohol battery and should be identified by their actual name and claimed purpose.

Standardization means details matter

The tests were standardized through specified instructions, demonstrations, administration, and scoring. If the officer materially changes those features, the performance should not be presented with the same confidence attached to the validated procedure. The issue is not ritualistic perfection; it is whether the change affects the scientific or observational meaning.

Obtain the offense-date NHTSA manual, the agency’s course materials, the officer’s initial certification, instructor status, refresher dates, and any local checklist. Ask which edition the officer actually used and whether the witness can explain every required step.

Field tests are different from the preliminary breath test

A handheld screening device estimates breath alcohol and is governed by N.D. Cent. Code § 39-20-14. The three standardized exercises rely on observations. Reports sometimes group all four under “field sobriety testing,” obscuring the different legal and scientific foundations.

List each event, result, time, device, and purpose separately. A challenge to HGN administration does not by itself invalidate a preliminary breath result, and a preliminary breath result does not establish that the walk-and-turn was scored correctly.

Probable cause and proof beyond a reasonable doubt are not the same

Probable cause asks whether the facts known to the officer warranted a reasonable belief that a DUI offense occurred. Trial asks whether the prosecution proved the charged elements beyond a reasonable doubt. An observation can contribute to probable cause without carrying the same weight at trial.

North Dakota opinions repeatedly treat odor, signs of impairment, admissions, traffic behavior, red or watery eyes, and one or more field-test results as relevant probable-cause factors. No single list decides every case. The court examines the actual totality known at arrest.

The prosecution must identify the charged DUI theory

N.D. Cent. Code § 39-08-01 includes a timely-test alcohol theory, alcohol impairment, drug-caused unsafe-driving incapacity, combined influence, and refusal provisions. Field-test evidence relates differently to each. Poor balance does not establish a numerical alcohol concentration, and an over-limit test may make some performance disputes less central to the per-se count.

For an impairment count, the recording can be central. For a drug count, the State must connect the observed function to a drug or combination and the statutory degree. For refusal, probable cause may be litigated in a suppression motion or administrative forum even when it is not a jury element.

Consent and refusal should be described accurately

Officers often ask a driver to perform field exercises, but the exact language varies. Determine whether the request was voluntary, an order, or accompanied by a warning. The legal consequences of declining physical roadside exercises are not identical to those governing an officer-directed chemical test or qualifying preliminary breath test.

A person may decline one exercise, stop because of pain, attempt an alternative, or misunderstand instructions. “Refused all testing” can be inaccurate. Preserve the recording and quote the exchange.

Performance begins before the formal test

Officers observe the response to emergency lights, parking, exiting, document production, conversation, walking, and standing. These activities can support or contradict later scoring. Note whether the person handled complex ordinary tasks normally while the report emphasizes a single misstep.

Pre-test conduct also supplies context for safety decisions. If an officer allowed the person to stand near traffic, walk on ice, or remove corrective lenses, those choices may illuminate what conditions the officer believed existed.

Horizontal gaze nystagmus must be administered and interpreted carefully

HGN is an involuntary eye movement observation

Nystagmus is an involuntary jerking of the eyes. The standardized HGN procedure looks for lack of smooth pursuit, distinct and sustained nystagmus at maximum deviation, and onset before forty-five degrees in each eye. The maximum standardized score is six clues, one of each type per eye.

The officer is not watching balance or asking the person to perform a memory task. The evidence depends on a properly positioned, smoothly moved stimulus and a reliable view of the eyes. Body camera often cannot show the eye movement even when it captures the officer’s hands.

The officer should first check for tracking and resting issues

Training calls for checking equal pupil size, resting nystagmus, and equal tracking before scoring HGN. Unequal pupils, inability to track together, resting nystagmus, or a reported medical condition may require medical attention or limit interpretation.

Ask what the officer saw during those preliminary checks and where it was documented. A worksheet with six boxes checked but no preliminary observations leaves important foundation unexplained.

Stimulus distance, height, and movement speed affect the observation

The stimulus should be held at the trained distance, slightly above eye level, and moved according to the timing for each pass. Moving too quickly can make smooth pursuit appear jerky. Holding at maximum deviation too briefly can undermine a sustained-nystagmus observation; holding excessively can create fatigue issues.

Video may permit timing even when it does not reveal the eyes. Use frame timestamps or a clear stopwatch analysis. Measure the officer’s passes, holds, repetitions, stimulus location, and whether the person turned the head because instructions or positioning were inadequate.

The forty-five-degree estimate must be more than guesswork

For onset before forty-five degrees, training uses the relationship between the stimulus and the person’s shoulder as a field estimate and requires a slow movement. The officer must identify the first sustained jerking while the stimulus remains short of the trained angle.

A fast sweep, wandering stimulus, head movement, poor vantage, traffic distraction, or undocumented estimate can weaken the clue. The defense need not prove a perfect angle to show that the claimed onset was not reliably observed.

Environmental distractions can matter

Flashing lights, passing traffic, moving backgrounds, wind, precipitation, darkness, glare, and an officer standing off center can interfere with fixation or observation. NHTSA training discusses positioning the person away from distracting motion when practical.

Document where the driver faced and what moved through the visual field. Squad video showing emergency lights reflected directly behind the stimulus provides better evidence than a later statement that conditions were “fine.”

Medical and neurological causes should be proved, not assumed

Eye disorders, vestibular conditions, neurological disease, head injury, seizure disorders, certain medications, and other conditions may produce or affect nystagmus. The relationship between a particular diagnosis and the observed eye movement usually requires records and qualified testimony.

Schwindt relied on City of Fargo v. McLaughlin in treating other physiological causes as weight rather than an automatic admissibility bar. A defense should therefore create the record: diagnosis, timing, symptoms, physician opinion, prior examinations, and why the condition could explain the claimed clue.

HGN should not be converted into an exact BAC

North Dakota recognizes the general relationship between alcohol and properly observed HGN, but the roadside score is not a chemical measurement. An officer should not tell the jury that four or six clues establish a specific alcohol concentration unless a legally admissible, scientifically supported opinion permits it.

Challenge any attempt to use the test beyond its foundation. The appropriate conclusion may be that observations were consistent with alcohol influence, not that the eyes measured a particular number.

The walk-and-turn tests divided attention under specific conditions

The instruction stage is part of the test

The person is placed heel-to-toe on a line, arms at the sides, and told to remain in that position while instructions are given. The officer explains and demonstrates nine heel-to-toe steps, a trained series of small turning steps, and nine return steps while counting aloud and watching the feet.

Scoring conduct before the instruction is complete or without establishing the stance can manufacture clues. The recording should show what was said, demonstrated, understood, and attempted.

The standardized test uses eight clue categories

The taught clues include inability to maintain balance during instructions, starting too soon, stopping, missing heel-to-toe beyond the stated tolerance, stepping off line, using arms for balance, making an improper turn, and taking the wrong number of steps. The same clue category is ordinarily scored once even if repeated.

Reports sometimes count every gap or sway as a separate failure, add unvalidated observations, or omit successful steps. Reconstruct the standardized score and then separately describe any nonstandard behavior without inflating the validated tally.

A real line and suitable surface matter

The person needs a reasonably level, dry, hard, nonslippery surface with sufficient room and safety. A natural seam or imaginary line may be used in some training circumstances, but the clarity and instructions become important. Gravel, snow, ice, sloped shoulders, rumble strips, curbs, and debris can change performance.

Photograph or revisit the location promptly. Squad video can flatten grades and hide ice. Weather records, road-maintenance data, officer footwear, and the officer’s own movement may provide useful comparison.

Footwear can change balance and heel-to-toe placement

High heels, boots, sandals, loose shoes, damaged footwear, orthotics, and bare feet on a cold or rough surface matter. Training addresses an opportunity to remove significantly elevated heels. Determine what the officer asked and whether removing footwear would have created another hazard.

Save or photograph the actual shoes. Generic testimony that the footwear looked normal is less useful than measurements and images.

Age, weight, injury, and neurological or orthopedic limitations require attention

Knee, hip, ankle, foot, back, balance, neuropathy, stroke, brain injury, and inner-ear conditions can affect tandem walking and turning. Age and substantial weight can make the exercise more difficult. Pain may not be visible on video.

The officer should ask about limitations and listen to the answer. The defense should obtain contemporaneous records and a qualified explanation rather than relying solely on a later assertion that the test was unfair.

Language and hearing can look like divided-attention failure

A driver processing instructions in a second language, struggling with hearing, or facing noisy traffic may begin too soon, miscount, or turn incorrectly without alcohol impairment. Rapid instructions, idioms, interruptions, and poor demonstrations increase the risk.

Use the full audio. Determine whether the officer confirmed understanding or merely asked “okay?” Interpreter evidence and prior language history may be relevant.

The turn must be compared with the demonstrated turn

People naturally pivot, but the standardized instruction calls for a series of small steps while keeping the lead foot on the line. If the officer demonstrates an unclear pivot or a different method, the driver may follow what was shown and still be scored against the written standard.

Play the demonstration and performance side by side. The issue is not whether the turn looked graceful; it is whether the person received and followed a reliable standardized instruction.

The one-leg stand is a timed balance-and-attention exercise

The officer should give a complete instruction and demonstration

The trained procedure directs the person to stand with feet together and arms at the sides, raise either foot about six inches, keep both legs straight, look at the elevated foot, and count aloud in the specified manner until told to stop. The officer demonstrates the position.

Missing instructions can affect both balance and counting. A person who lifts the foot before being told may be responding to an ambiguous demonstration rather than showing divided-attention difficulty.

The test uses four standardized clue categories

The clues are swaying while balancing, using arms for balance, hopping, and putting the foot down. Reports should distinguish ordinary body movement from the trained threshold and should not count the same category repeatedly.

Also document successful time, correct counting, arm position, foot height, and recovery. A complete performance is more informative than a checklist containing only alleged errors.

The thirty-second timing must be verified

The exercise is designed around an officer-timed period. If the officer stops early, allows it to run long, counts silently at the wrong rate, or restarts inconsistently, the standardized interpretation changes. Video timestamps can establish the true duration.

Compare instruction time, first foot lift, each foot-down event, any restart, and the stop command. A report’s “approximately thirty seconds” may be testable to the frame.

Surface and safety are critical

Standing on one leg beside traffic on a sloped, icy, windy, dark, or uneven shoulder is different from performing on a dry level floor. Emergency lights, passing trucks, cold, and fear of falling can affect concentration and balance.

Officers may relocate a driver for safety. If a safer nearby location existed but was not used, ask why. The answer can affect the weight of the score even if the encounter was otherwise lawful.

Physical limitations may be more important than appearance

Joint replacements, ankle instability, plantar pain, neuropathy, vertigo, back injury, pregnancy, recent surgery, and old trauma can impair single-leg balance. A person may walk normally for a short distance yet struggle with a prolonged one-leg stance.

Obtain treatment records close to the incident, imaging where relevant, braces or orthotics, work restrictions, and medical testimony. Connect the condition to the particular demand of the test.

Counting errors require context

A person may count in an unfamiliar format, change cadence to maintain balance, misunderstand the stopping instruction, or be interrupted by traffic or an officer. Counting accurately while making a balance correction can show divided attention even if a physical clue is scored.

Transcribe the audio precisely. Do not rely on the report’s “could not follow instructions” when the recording shows continuous correct counting.

Repeating the test can change performance

An officer may restart after an interruption, demonstration error, safety issue, or foot-down event. Repetition can improve performance through practice or worsen it through fatigue, pain, cold, or anxiety. The report should identify each attempt and the reason for it.

Preserve every attempt. The State should not select the worst segment while omitting a later clean performance, and the defense should not ignore an earlier complete test.

Testing conditions can explain observations without disproving all impairment

Video is the starting point, not an infallible observer

Body cameras have wide-angle lenses, automatic exposure, compression, stabilization limits, and microphone placement that can distort distance, grade, color, eye appearance, and sound. Squad video may be fixed far from the test. Important feet or eyes may leave the frame.

Use the recording for what it shows and identify what it cannot show. Metadata, original quality, camera position, buffering, dropped frames, and missing segments may matter.

Weather and cold affect more than comfort

Wind can move clothing and the body. Cold can produce shivering and stiffness. Rain and snow affect traction and visibility. A driver wearing clothing suited to the car rather than the roadside may deteriorate during a long investigation.

Obtain official weather data, but connect it to the exact location and time. Video of blowing snow or the officer bracing against wind may be more persuasive than a regional hourly summary.

Fatigue can mimic selected impairment signs

Late-night wakefulness, shift work, sleep deprivation, sleep apnea, and long travel can produce red eyes, slowed responses, yawning, inattention, and balance changes. Fatigue can coexist with alcohol or drugs, so the defense should not present it as a universal explanation.

Collect work schedules, phone or vehicle time data, travel history, witness observations, and medical records where relevant. Ask the State’s expert which signs distinguish the proposed causes.

Anxiety can affect speech, memory, tremor, and instruction processing

A police stop with emergency lights and possible arrest creates stress. People may talk rapidly, repeat themselves, shake, misunderstand, or focus on consequences. Preexisting anxiety or panic can magnify the response.

The existence of stress does not erase objective clues. It requires the officer and factfinder to compare the whole video and avoid treating every nervous behavior as intoxication.

Medical screening questions should be preserved verbatim

Officers may ask about eye problems, head injury, leg or back conditions, diabetes, seizures, medication, or recent treatment. The question may be rushed, compound, or asked before the driver understands the exercise. A negative answer does not always exclude a diagnosed condition.

Quote the answer and compare it with records. Determine whether the driver had corrective lenses, whether they were removed, and whether the officer responded to disclosed limitations.

Injury from a crash can change later performance

Adrenaline, pain, concussion, whiplash, bleeding, airbag deployment, and shock may not be immediately obvious. An ambulance setting can make HGN or balance testing difficult. Hospital records and later diagnoses can illuminate the roadside condition.

In Schwindt, HGN was administered while the driver sat in an ambulance after a collision. The decision admitted the evidence on that administrative record; it does not make crash injury irrelevant in every case.

Disability accommodations affect fairness and proof

A mobility, hearing, vision, neurological, or communication disability may require a different evaluation. The question at trial is not whether the person completed a conventional exercise perfectly but what the observed conduct reliably proves about the charged offense.

Document aids, baseline function, accommodation requests, and officer response. Expert testimony may explain which observations are attributable to the disability and which remain probative.

Alcohol SFSTs do not translate automatically to every drug

HGN is associated with some drug categories and not others

Central-nervous-system depressants, dissociative anesthetics, and certain inhalants may produce HGN signs, while cannabis or stimulants alone generally do not produce the same HGN pattern. A no-clue HGN result can therefore affect an officer’s differential reasoning without proving sobriety from all substances.

The drug-specific opinion should come from qualified training and reliable facts. A generic statement that “drugs cause nystagmus” is too broad.

Walk-and-turn and one-leg stand remain nonspecific

Many drugs, medical conditions, fatigue, injury, and environmental factors can affect balance or divided attention. Poor performance may support an impairment investigation but rarely identifies the substance by itself.

The expert must connect the suspected drug, timing, toxicology, signs, and observed function. A positive urine test combined with a balance clue does not automatically prove drug-caused unsafe-driving incapacity.

A DRE examination is broader than the three-test battery

Drug-recognition evaluation protocols add breath testing, interviews, eye examinations, vital signs, dark-room pupil measurements, muscle tone, injection-site inspection, statements, and toxicology. The standardized field exercises are only part of that process.

Obtain both the SFST and DRE materials. Compare the evaluator’s predicted category with the confirmed compounds and consider medical alternatives. Do not let the broader opinion retroactively validate an incorrectly administered roadside test.

State v. Cooper shows why successful tests matter

In State v. Cooper, 2026 ND 68, ¶¶ 3–7, the trooper observed no HGN clues and testified that the driver passed walk-and-turn, which in his view excluded alcohol impairment. Other observations and an admission to earlier marijuana use continued the drug investigation.

The case does not establish that passing those exercises excludes every drug. It demonstrates that the actual results must be recorded accurately and interpreted according to the suspected substance rather than converted into a generic pass-or-fail DUI conclusion.

Prescription medication requires medication-specific analysis

Benzodiazepines, opioids, sleep medications, muscle relaxants, antiseizure drugs, antihistamines, antidepressants, and stimulants have different possible signs. Dose, formulation, timing, tolerance, interactions, medical condition, and practitioner cautions matter.

A lawful prescription is not itself proof of impairment. It may support a statutory affirmative defense if current requirements are met. Field performance should be integrated with the full medical and toxicology record.

Cannabis investigations should not use HGN as a THC meter

Cannabis can affect attention, perception, reaction, and coordination, but HGN is not a validated numerical THC test. Blood or urine cannabinoid findings have their own timing and impairment limits. The prosecution must prove North Dakota’s statutory unsafe-driving degree.

Analyze use route, product, time, active THC versus metabolites, collection delay, frequent-use residuals, alcohol, video, and DRE evidence. The physical exercises are one part of the record.

Combined substances require a careful chronology

Alcohol below 0.08 may combine with medication or another drug. HGN, balance, speech, reaction, and toxicology can reflect overlapping causes. Build the dose, drink, driving, testing, and collection times before accepting an interaction opinion.

Require the expert to identify whether the claimed interaction is additive, synergistic, or merely possible, and what evidence connects it to observed driving ability.

A field-test defense is an evidence audit, not a claim that every clue is meaningless

Transcribe the entire roadside sequence

Create a timeline from emergency lights through arrest. Transcribe instructions, demonstrations, questions, answers, interruptions, clues, restarts, preliminary breath testing, warnings, and officer discussions. Mark the camera and clock for every event.

Then compare the transcript with the report, affidavit, Report and Notice, hearing testimony, and trial testimony. Small wording differences can reveal whether an instruction was omitted or a later conclusion replaced the original observation.

Use a clue matrix instead of a generalized attack

For each alleged clue, list the test, standardized definition, officer claim, video time, supporting image or audio, defense observation, condition issue, and legal use. Include successful performance and unscored behavior in separate columns.

This method prevents overstatement. The defense can concede a visible foot-down event while disputing the surface, timing, score, and conclusion. Precision improves credibility.

Challenge expert or officer overreach under the evidence rules

N.D.R.Ev. 702 requires qualified, helpful, reliable expert testimony. Ask whether the officer is offering lay observations, training-based expert interpretation, medical causation, drug-category opinion, or a BAC estimate. Each has a different foundation.

A focused motion can limit unsupported numerical claims, unvalidated nonstandard tests, drug-specific conclusions beyond training, or medical opinions. It need not seek wholesale exclusion when a narrower remedy fits the defect.

Make the right objection in the right forum

A criminal suppression motion can challenge probable cause or an unlawfully prolonged detention. A motion in limine can address admissibility and opinion scope. Trial cross-examination addresses weight. An NDDOT hearing has statutory issues, short deadlines, agency evidence rules, and a separate review record.

Schwindt was an administrative appeal and reviewed an evidentiary decision deferentially. Counsel should not cite it as though every HGN dispute in every forum has already been resolved.

Medical proof should connect diagnosis to the test demand

Collect records existing before or near the incident, treatment notes, imaging, restrictions, corrective lenses, medications, and a qualified opinion. Ask how the condition affects smooth pursuit, nystagmus, tandem walking, turning, single-leg stance, or instruction processing.

A long problem list without explanation can distract the court. A short, well-supported causal account is stronger.

Cross-examine from the manual and the video

Establish training, edition, required step, reason, actual action, and deviation. Use short questions tied to timestamps. Ask the officer to distinguish what can be seen on video from what depends on recollection.

Avoid arguing with the witness about every movement. Select the deviations and contradictions that change reliability, scoring, or the probable-cause totality.

Present normal and abnormal performance in context

A demonstrative can show nine outbound steps, turn, nine return steps, each standardized clue, and successful acts. Another can show HGN pass and hold timing. Keep the display faithful to the original recording and disclose any frame-rate limits.

The defense should not edit out unfavorable moments. A complete presentation lets the factfinder see why some observations are real but less probative than the report suggests.

Closing argument should track the charged element

For impairment, explain why the evidence does or does not prove influence to the required level at driving or actual control. For a timely-test charge, distinguish test foundation and statutory concentration from roadside balance. For drug DUI, emphasize the need to connect nonspecific behavior to the identified substance and unsafe-driving incapacity.

Do not ask the jury to treat SFSTs as worthless merely because they are imperfect. Show what was standardized, what changed, what alternative explanation is supported, and why the remaining inference does not satisfy the State’s burden.

Frequently asked questions about North Dakota field sobriety tests

1. What are the three standardized field sobriety tests?

They are horizontal gaze nystagmus, walk-and-turn, and one-leg stand. Other roadside exercises may be used, but they are not automatically part of the standardized alcohol battery.

2. Is a field sobriety test the same as a breath test?

No. SFSTs are officer-observed eye, balance, and divided-attention exercises. A preliminary breath test uses a device and is governed by separate statutory and scientific rules.

3. Does failing one test prove DUI?

No. Performance is one factor in the complete record. Administration, conditions, medical issues, driving, statements, chemical evidence, and the charged theory all matter.

4. What does the HGN test look for?

It looks for lack of smooth pursuit, distinct sustained nystagmus at maximum deviation, and onset before forty-five degrees in each eye, for up to six standardized clues.

5. Can a medical condition cause nystagmus?

Yes. Eye, neurological, vestibular, injury, medication, and other issues may affect nystagmus. North Dakota treats supported alternative causes as important to weight, and precise medical proof is necessary.

6. Can HGN determine my exact alcohol concentration?

No. It is not a chemical measurement and should not be converted into an exact BAC without a separately admissible scientific basis.

7. What are the walk-and-turn clues?

They include instruction-stage balance, starting early, stopping, heel-to-toe gap, stepping off line, arm use, improper turn, and wrong step count. Repeated conduct within one category is not automatically multiple clues.

8. What are the one-leg-stand clues?

The standardized categories are swaying, using arms for balance, hopping, and putting the foot down during the timed exercise.

9. Does an icy or sloped shoulder matter?

Yes. Surface, grade, traction, weather, wind, lighting, traffic, and safety can affect performance and should be documented with video, photographs, and records.

10. Do high heels or boots affect the test?

They can. Save or photograph the actual footwear and review whether the officer followed training concerning elevated or unsuitable shoes and whether removal was safe.

11. What if I have a knee, back, ankle, or balance condition?

Obtain records and connect the diagnosis to tandem walking, turning, or single-leg stance through qualified evidence. A normal short walk does not necessarily exclude a limitation.

12. Can anxiety or fatigue look like impairment?

They can affect eyes, speech, memory, tremor, attention, and balance. They may also coexist with substance effects, so the case needs corroboration and proportionate analysis.

13. Are SFSTs reliable for marijuana?

The alcohol battery does not translate automatically to cannabis. Balance and attention may be relevant, but HGN is not a THC meter and the State needs drug-specific evidence.

14. What is the difference between SFSTs and a DRE evaluation?

A DRE examination is broader and adds interviews, breath testing, eye checks, vital signs, pupil measurements, muscle tone, physical observations, and toxicology. SFSTs are one component.

15. Can body-camera video disprove the officer’s report?

It can confirm or contradict instructions, timing, scoring, conditions, statements, and performance. Camera angle and quality may not reveal fine eye movement or the true road grade.

16. What did Schwindt v. Sorel decide about HGN?

On its administrative record, it held that asserted physiological causes went to evidentiary weight rather than admissibility and upheld consideration of the test. It does not eliminate administration or medical challenges.

17. What records should a lawyer request?

Request original video, dispatch, officer notes and worksheets, reports, NHTSA and agency training materials, certification and refresher records, preliminary breath records, chemical-test files, location and weather evidence, footwear evidence, and relevant medical records.

18. What is the strongest field sobriety defense?

It is usually a verified clue-by-clue comparison of the manual, complete video, actual conditions, supported physical limitations, and charged element—not a generic assertion that all roadside tests are invalid.

Legal information, not individual advice. Field sobriety evidence depends on the charged subsection, offense-date law, officer training, manual edition, instructions, administration, scoring, video, surface, weather, footwear, medical and language issues, suspected substance, chemical evidence, forum, and current North Dakota precedent. The complete record must be reviewed.


Call nowChoose a time