Continuances in North Dakota Criminal Cases
A continuance is a court order postponing a criminal hearing or trial. It may be essential when discovery arrives late, a material witness is unavailable…
Postponing a hearing or trial without surrendering the defense record
Continuances in North Dakota Criminal Cases
A continuance is a court order postponing a criminal hearing or trial. It may be essential when discovery arrives late, a material witness is unavailable, counsel has a genuine conflict, an expert needs time, or a new charge changes trial preparation. But delay can also extend bond conditions, custody, anxiety, expense, and the life of the prosecution. North Dakota requires prompt requests, good cause, a record supporting the need, and attention to the public interest in timely resolution.
The North Dakota rules and statutes governing continuances
Several authorities operate together. Rule of Court 6.1 supplies the filing and good-cause framework. Criminal Rule 50 addresses calendar control and the interest of justice. Chapter 29-19 defines and regulates criminal continuances. Other rules may impose additional limits when the request follows late witness endorsement, discovery violation, amendment, substitution of counsel, or a statutory speedy-trial election.
Current Rule of Court 6.1
N.D.R.Ct. 6.1, effective in its current form March 1, 2024, requires prompt filing as soon as grounds are known and good cause shown by declaration or otherwise. For a motion filed fewer than twenty-one days before trial or hearing, the movant must first attempt to contact the opposing party and must state whether that party agrees or objects.
An agreed postponement still needs good cause
Rule 6.1 says stipulations for continuance will not be recognized except for good cause. The calendar belongs to the court as well as the litigants. Witnesses, jurors, alleged victims, public resources, and docket standards are affected even when counsel agree. A joint request should explain the reason rather than merely present a new date.
Attorney actually engaged elsewhere
Rule 6.1(a) entitles a party to a continuance when the attorney is actually engaged in another trial or hearing, but only for the duration of that proceeding. A calendar conflict with a routine appointment or speculative setting is different from counsel actually being in another trial. Counsel should provide the case, court, date, expected duration, and efforts to resolve the conflict.
Criminal Rule 50 and the interest of justice
N.D.R.Crim.P. 50 requires calendar preference for criminal cases as far as practicable and permits advancement or continuance as necessary in the interest of justice. Its explanatory note emphasizes good cause, no longer than necessary, and consideration of both the parties’ request and the public interest in prompt disposition.
Chapter 29-19
N.D.C.C. ch. 29-19 defines a continuance as postponement for any period. Section 29-19-03 authorizes postponement upon sufficient cause. Section 29-19-05 permits application before trial or when the action is called. Sections 29-19-06 through 29-19-10 regulate supporting facts, written presentation, hearing, and entry of reasons.
Good cause is concrete, timely, and proportional
Good cause is not a fixed list. The judge evaluates the reason for delay, diligence, timing, prior postponements, length requested, effect on fairness, available alternatives, calendar, witness and victim interests, custody, and speedy-trial concerns. The moving party should connect those considerations to evidence.
New information that changes preparation
A genuinely new disclosure may justify delay when it creates investigation, expert, motion, or witness work that cannot responsibly be completed. The motion should identify when the material arrived, its volume and significance, what counsel did immediately, the tasks remaining, and why a shorter remedy is inadequate.
Foreseeable work is less persuasive
Ordinary trial preparation, known witnesses, routine scheduling, and evidence disclosed long ago rarely explain an eve-of-trial request. If counsel delayed, the motion must address why. Courts are more receptive when the record shows repeated requests for missing information, prompt expert contact, subpoenas issued early, or an unexpected event outside the party’s control.
The requested length matters
A request should propose the minimum time needed and provide availability. “Continue indefinitely” leaves the court unable to balance interests. If laboratory testing needs thirty days, say so. If an expert can complete review by a specified week, attach that estimate. A targeted postponement demonstrates proportionality.
Prior continuances matter
The judge will consider who requested earlier delays and why. Repeated defense requests can weaken a later speedy-trial claim and an additional request. Repeated prosecution requests may strengthen an objection, especially if witnesses were not diligently secured. But every request should be evaluated on its actual cause rather than attributed mechanically.
Alternatives should be addressed
The court may ask whether a shorter adjournment, remote testimony, deposition, stipulation, order compelling discovery, exclusion, limited reopening, substitute witness, or narrower hearing would work. The movant should explain why those options do or do not protect fairness. A court can fashion relief short of moving the whole trial.
Continuances based on an absent witness have detailed statutory requirements
Section 29-19-06 demands more than saying a witness is unavailable. The Legislature requires a showing that lets the judge evaluate diligence, materiality, necessity, and whether the absence is genuine. A motion should follow each statutory item in order.
Due diligence and its nature
The application must state that the party used due diligence to prepare and describe that diligence. Include contact attempts, investigator work, subpoenas, service dates, travel arrangements, medical verification, employer communication, and follow-up. A subpoena first sought days before a long-scheduled trial may not demonstrate diligence.
Name, residence, and expected testimony
The witness’s name and residence must be provided, along with what the party expects the witness would say under oath. The proffer should be specific enough to show relevance without becoming argument. If safety or confidentiality creates concern, counsel can request sealed or in-camera handling rather than omit the required substance.
Materiality
Material testimony bears on a disputed issue that matters to the decision. A cumulative character witness or a witness offering uncontested background may not justify moving trial. Explain which element, defense, impeachment issue, or evidentiary foundation the testimony affects and why the point is consequential.
No satisfactory substitute evidence
The statute requires a showing that the same facts cannot be established satisfactorily through other evidence. Address recordings, reports, stipulations, another witness, business records, deposition testimony, or prior sworn testimony. The fact that another source exists does not always make it equally useful; explain any difference in admissibility, credibility, or completeness.
No arranged absence
The motion must state that the witness is not absent through the applicant’s connivance or counsel. Courts will not reward a party for causing or encouraging nonappearance. Preserve communications that show the party instructed the witness to comply and took reasonable steps to secure attendance.
Documents associated with the witness
If the request involves a missing document, § 29-19-06 calls for its nature and where it may be found. Identify the custodian, source, request or subpoena, expected contents, materiality, and why an authenticated substitute is unavailable. General claims that records “may exist” are weak.
Late discovery, new witnesses, and expert work
Discovery-related continuances require a focused prejudice showing. The defense should distinguish material that is merely new in format from information that genuinely changes investigation or trial strategy. Courts will consider whether counsel already knew the substance from reports, interviews, or earlier disclosures.
State v. Glaum
In State v. Glaum, 2024 ND 47, ¶¶ 36–40, the State added two endorsed witnesses near trial. The Supreme Court affirmed denial of a continuance because the witnesses had already been disclosed in discovery and the defendant did not demonstrate prejudice. The court also considered the State’s and alleged victim’s interest in timely trial.
Witness endorsement has a specific limit
N.D.R.Crim.P. 7(g) states that failure to endorse a witness name does not invalidate the information. It also restricts a continuance for nonendorsement unless the application was made at the earliest opportunity and continuance is necessary in the name of justice. Counsel should identify what was unknown despite earlier discovery and what preparation the endorsement newly requires.
Discovery violation remedies
N.D.R.Crim.P. 16 permits the court to order disclosure, grant a continuance, prohibit undisclosed evidence, or enter another just order when a party fails to comply. The remedy should account for willfulness, reason, prejudice, feasibility of cure, and trial integrity. Exclusion is not automatic, and delay may be the least severe adequate response.
Large digital productions
Volume alone is not the whole showing. State when data arrived, whether it is searchable, what devices and date range it covers, which formats require special tools, whether passwords or extraction reports are missing, and what review remains. Sampling may reveal significance, but counsel should avoid claiming millions of pages are all equally important.
Expert review
Explain when expert need became apparent, contact efforts, retention status, materials provided, testing needed, expected completion date, and why the subject is material. If funding approval or laboratory access caused delay, document the request and follow-up. An unexplained late search for an expert resembles lack of diligence.
Changed charging theory
An amended count may require new legal research, investigation, witness interviews, or expert analysis even if the factual reports were previously disclosed. Compare the old and new elements, defenses, penalties, and admissible evidence. Request the time necessary to answer the change, not a generic reset.
Continuances for counsel, substitution, and adequate preparation
The right to counsel includes meaningful assistance, but it does not give an unlimited right to delay trial by repeatedly replacing attorneys. Courts balance the reason for substitution, timing, prior representation, case age, preparation, conflicts, the defendant’s conduct, and harm from postponement.
New counsel needs a factual preparation record
A motion should describe the appointment or retention date, discovery volume, completed work, uncompleted necessary work, motions requiring investigation, witness needs, and the proposed date. Merely stating that counsel is new may be insufficient when prior counsel prepared the case and files transferred promptly.
Ethical conflicts require careful presentation
Counsel may be unable to disclose privileged details. A motion can state the governing professional obligation, provide nonprivileged timing facts, request an in-camera conference, and explain why continued representation is impermissible or impaired. The court still needs enough information to distinguish a genuine conflict from strategic delay.
State v. Lewellyn
In State v. Lewellyn, 2025 ND 98, ¶¶ 16–18, the Supreme Court affirmed denial of an eve-of-trial continuance after a 467-day-old case, multiple appointed attorneys, prior postponements, and the defendant’s last-minute dismissal of counsel. The Court quoted Rule 6.1’s requirement that motions be filed promptly when grounds are known.
Preparation claims must be made to the trial court
Lewellyn also demonstrates preservation. On appeal the defendant argued he lacked time to prepare for self-representation, but he had not made that reason to the district court and had said the case was simple enough to proceed. A continuance motion must state every material reason when the judge can address it.
Actual trial conflict
When counsel is actually engaged in another trial or hearing, Rule 6.1(a) protects the party for that proceeding’s duration. Provide formal settings and expected length. If both matters are merely scheduled, counsel should promptly contact courts, explain priority and custody issues, and seek coordinated resolution rather than wait for an unavoidable collision.
Every continuance should address speedy-trial consequences
A continuance and a speedy-trial claim can pull in opposite directions. Defense-requested delay commonly weighs against a later claim that the State or court was too slow. But requesting necessary preparation does not erase all constitutional protection. The record should identify responsibility for the underlying event and whether the defense waives, preserves, or objects to particular delay.
There is no universal ninety-day rule
Section 29-19-02 contains a special ninety-day election for a charging instrument with a felony under § 19-03.1-23 or chapter 12.1-20 when a party elects within fourteen days after arraignment. The court may set trial later for good cause. Other cases generally use constitutional balancing and Rule 48 rather than that statutory ninety-day election.
State v. Solomon
In State v. Solomon, 2025 ND 133, ¶¶ 9–18, the Supreme Court upheld a trial beyond the special ninety-day period where scheduling conflicts, counsel agreement, court availability, failure to accept an earlier offered date, and lack of prejudice supported good cause. Agreement and courtroom conduct can matter as much as the initial demand.
State who is requesting and why
The order and transcript should identify whether delay results from the prosecution, defense, court calendar, counsel conflict, witness emergency, discovery failure, or joint request. Ambiguous docket entries complicate later analysis. If defense needs time because of a late State disclosure, the record should not describe the delay simply as “defense continuance.”
Custody and release conditions
For a detained person, even a short postponement can be severe. A motion or objection should identify custody length, inability to work, family effects, treatment interruption, and defense preparation limits. Counsel can request renewed release review or modification of conditions when the trial date moves materially.
Prejudice from delay
Lost witnesses, fading memory, unavailable video, employment consequences, anxiety, restrictive conditions, and impaired defense can matter. Preserve concrete facts and dates. A generalized preference for speed is weaker than proof that a specified defense source will disappear or a restraint will cause irreparable harm.
How the defense can oppose a prosecution continuance
The defense should not reflexively oppose every delay. Some postponements may improve preparation or resolve uncertainty. But when delay harms the client, the objection should address diligence, statutory requirements, alternatives, speedy-trial interests, and actual prejudice.
Test prosecutorial diligence
Ask when the State learned of the conflict, when it subpoenaed the witness, what service efforts occurred, why another prosecutor cannot proceed, whether the evidence is cumulative, and what alternatives were considered. An unavoidable medical emergency differs from failure to contact a known witness until the week of trial.
Require an adequate witness proffer
Chapter 29-19’s absent-witness factors provide a useful structure. The State should identify material testimony and show why other evidence cannot present it satisfactorily. The defense may offer a narrow stipulation that removes the claimed need while avoiding admission of disputed or prejudicial facts.
Offer a narrower solution
A short adjournment, reordered witnesses, remote appearance if legally permissible, deposition, authentication stipulation, or exclusion may preserve the trial date. Proposed alternatives make an objection more credible and assist the judge in balancing justice.
Preserve speedy-trial and prejudice facts
State the accusation date, custody, prior delay, assertion of rights, defense readiness, lost evidence risk, and effect on witnesses. Object to mischaracterizing the continuance as agreed if the defense merely acknowledges the court’s ruling. If the judge grants delay, request the shortest date and written reasons.
Consider conditions and costs
When the State’s avoidable action causes delay, the defense can request relief tailored to resulting harm: renewed bond review, preservation orders, expense allocation where authorized, a firm disclosure deadline, limits on late evidence, or another just order. The goal is to protect the client, not merely register disagreement.
What a strong continuance motion contains
A continuance motion should be filed as soon as the need is known. If time is short, counsel should file a supported motion promptly rather than wait to assemble a perfect record, then supplement as permitted. Current Rule 6.1 has special requirements inside twenty-one days.
Procedural facts
List the current hearing or trial date, charge, filing and arraignment dates, prior continuances and requesting party, custody status, statutory election, and relevant scheduling orders. State whether the other side was contacted and agrees or objects when Rule 6.1 requires it.
The triggering event and timing
Identify precisely what created the need, when it occurred, when counsel learned it, and what counsel did next. Attach the disclosure notice, medical verification, subpoena return, expert schedule, conflict notice, amended information, or other nonprivileged proof.
Necessary work and requested duration
Describe tasks, estimated hours or sequence, third-party availability, and the earliest responsible new date. Provide counsel’s and essential witness availability. If only one hearing needs to move, do not ask to reset unrelated deadlines without a reason.
Fairness and alternatives
Explain how denial would impair a substantial right, not simply make work inconvenient. Address shorter alternatives and why they fail or suffice. If the defense will accept a narrower remedy, say so. If no alternative cures the issue, connect that conclusion to the evidence.
Speedy-trial position
State whether the defense maintains a constitutional demand, whether a statutory election applies, how the requested period should be attributed, and why the event causing delay should or should not count against the defense. Avoid an unnecessary blanket waiver broader than the requested period.
Proposed order and record
Submit an order with findings on good cause, request source, duration, new date, speedy-trial position, custody, and deadlines. Section 29-19-10 requires reasons for continuance to be entered in the court minutes. A clear order protects everyone from later disagreement.
Review, preservation, and practical consequences
Continuance decisions are ordinarily reviewed for abuse of discretion. That deferential standard makes the trial-court record critical. The appellate court asks whether the judge acted arbitrarily, unreasonably, or unconscionably, failed to use a rational process, or misapplied the law.
State v. Glaum’s standard
Glaum states that denial of continuance receives abuse-of-discretion review and affirms where the defendant did not establish prejudice from previously disclosed witnesses. An appellate brief cannot supply facts or a preparation explanation that was never presented to the trial judge.
Make the requested work specific
Identify unreviewed material, witnesses not interviewed, motions that require facts, expert testing, and how those tasks affect trial. Offer exhibits under seal when necessary. “Counsel is not ready” can be read as conclusory; a task-based record permits meaningful review.
Object after an adverse ruling
If trial proceeds, renew objections when the predicted prejudice occurs. Request exclusion, a recess, mistrial, limiting instruction, or other relief that fits the event. Demonstrating actual effect is stronger than relying only on the original forecast.
A continuance can change other deadlines
Do not assume a new trial date automatically changes motion, disclosure, expert, plea, witness, or subpoena deadlines. Ask the order to identify what remains and what moves. Verify the new final conference, jury demand, exhibit exchange, and transportation arrangements.
Client communication
Explain why delay is requested or opposed, the likely new period, custody and bond implications, work and family effects, witness risk, plea impact, and speedy-trial consequences. The lawyer makes legal decisions within professional responsibility, but the client should understand the real cost and benefit.
Frequently asked questions about North Dakota criminal continuances
What is a continuance?
Under N.D.C.C. § 29-19-01, it is a postponement of a case for any period. It can move a hearing, motion, trial, or another proceeding, depending on the court’s order.
Who may request a criminal continuance?
The defense or prosecution may request one, and the court has calendar authority under Rule 50. The moving party must show the governing standard, and the judge considers fairness, diligence, timing, and the public interest.
Does the other side’s agreement guarantee a continuance?
No. Rule 6.1 states that even stipulations require good cause. The court considers jurors, witnesses, alleged victims, docket standards, speedy-trial interests, and the administration of justice.
What must a motion filed less than twenty-one days before trial say?
The movant must first attempt to contact the opposing party and state whether that party agrees or objects. The motion must still be prompt and supported by good cause under current Rule 6.1.
Can a lawyer’s other case justify delay?
Rule 6.1(a) provides a continuance when the attorney is actually engaged in another trial or hearing, limited to that proceeding’s duration. Known calendar conflicts should be raised promptly with enough detail for coordinated scheduling.
What is required when a witness is absent?
Section 29-19-06 requires diligence, the witness’s identity and residence, expected testimony, materiality, any needed document and location, inability to prove the same facts satisfactorily elsewhere, and confirmation that the applicant did not arrange the absence.
Can late discovery support a continuance?
Yes, when it creates necessary work that cannot reasonably be completed and causes real prejudice. Identify arrival date, significance, remaining tasks, diligence, and the shortest time needed. If the substance was disclosed earlier, Glaum shows the request may fail.
Can the court exclude late evidence instead of moving trial?
Potentially. Rule 16 permits disclosure orders, continuance, exclusion, or another just remedy. The court considers the violation, reason, prejudice, feasibility of cure, and trial integrity.
Does hiring a new lawyer automatically move trial?
No. The court evaluates timing, reason, prior counsel, case age, readiness, conflicts, prior delay, and whether substitution is genuine or manipulative. New counsel should document specific preparation needs and propose a realistic date.
What happened in State v. Lewellyn?
The Court affirmed denial of an eve-of-trial request after a 467-day case, multiple appointed attorneys, earlier continuances, and last-minute dismissal of counsel. The defendant also failed to present the preparation reason later advanced on appeal.
Will a defense continuance waive speedy-trial rights?
It can weigh against a later claim and usually attributes the requested period to the defense, but it does not necessarily erase every protection. The motion and order should state the cause, requested period, and the defense’s precise position rather than use an unnecessary blanket waiver.
Does every North Dakota case have a ninety-day trial deadline?
No. The specific ninety-day election in § 29-19-02 applies to a charging instrument containing a felony under § 19-03.1-23 or chapter 12.1-20 when timely elected. Other cases use constitutional and rule-based analysis.
Can the State obtain a continuance because its witness is unavailable?
Possibly, but the State should demonstrate diligence, material testimony, genuine unavailability, lack of a satisfactory substitute, and an appropriate duration. The defense may oppose, offer a narrow stipulation, or propose another remedy.
What if the defendant is in jail while trial is postponed?
Custody increases the cost of delay. Counsel should identify detention length and prejudice and may request renewed release review, modified conditions, or the earliest firm trial date.
Can a judge grant only a short delay instead of resetting everything?
Yes. The court can use a recess, brief adjournment, reordered proof, limited deadline extension, remote testimony when lawful, or another tailored remedy. The request should explain the minimum time that cures the problem.
How is denial of a continuance reviewed on appeal?
Ordinarily for abuse of discretion. The record must show the reason, diligence, necessary work, prejudice, alternatives, and requested duration. New appellate explanations generally cannot replace facts omitted below.
Do all deadlines move when the trial date moves?
Not automatically. The order should specify motions, discovery, expert disclosures, exhibit exchange, plea deadlines, subpoenas, and conferences. Counsel should verify each deadline after any reset.
What should the proposed continuance order include?
It should state good cause, requesting party, reason, duration, new date, speedy-trial position, custody or bond treatment, and revised deadlines. Section 29-19-10 requires the reasons to appear in the court minutes.
Delay should be requested only with a developed record
A continuance can protect the defense from an unprepared or unfair trial, but it can also impose serious personal and strategic cost. North Dakota’s rules reward promptness, diligence, specificity, and a request no broader than necessary. They also permit the court to protect witnesses, alleged victims, jurors, and public confidence in timely justice.
For the defense, the strongest practice is to identify the new event immediately, document the work it creates, evaluate alternatives, address speedy-trial consequences, and propose a definite order. If delay is opposed, the same disciplined record shows why time will harm the client and why a narrower response will suffice.