Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Lesser-Included Offenses in North Dakota Criminal Cases

A lesser-included offense is not simply a charge that sounds less serious or carries a lower penalty. It must be legally contained within the charged…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota lesser-included offenses, N.D.R.Crim.P. 31(c), same-elements analysis, rational-evidence test, lesser-offense instructions, attempt, homicide, assault, sexual offenses, culpability, notice, amendments, verdict forms, merger, double jeopardy, preservation, and appeal

Lesser-Included Offenses in North Dakota Criminal Cases

A lesser-included offense is not simply a charge that sounds less serious or carries a lower penalty. It must be legally contained within the charged offense, and the trial evidence must support the particular verdict option. Those two questions—legal inclusion and evidentiary support—should be analyzed separately.

The decision to request, oppose, or accept a lesser instruction can determine whether the jury faces an all-or-nothing choice or has a supported middle verdict.

Compare elements, not labels or shared facts. Two crimes arising from the same episode are not necessarily greater and lesser offenses.

Rule 31(c) authorizes conviction only of an offense necessarily included in the charge

The charged offense supplies notice of genuine included offenses

Rule 31(c) is short: “A defendant may be found guilty of an offense necessarily included in the offense charged.” The rule permits a verdict on an uncharged lesser offense because the greater charge necessarily alleges all of the lesser offense’s elements. It does not authorize conviction of a merely related crime or one that would require an additional fact never required by the charge.

In State v. Vance, 537 N.W.2d 545, 548–49 (N.D. 1995), the Court explained that an information charging the greater offense inherently gives notice of a necessarily included offense. The decision permitted amendment from a sexual-act theory to a sexual-contact offense under the statutes then in force because the latter required no fact beyond the charged theory and the defendant did not show prejudice.

Legal inclusion and evidentiary support are different questions

The first question is categorical: looking at the legally relevant elements and charged statutory alternatives, can the greater offense be committed without committing the proposed lesser? If yes, the proposed offense is not necessarily included. If no, the legal-inclusion requirement is satisfied.

The second question is record-specific: could a rational jury, on the evidence actually admitted, find the defendant not guilty of the greater but guilty of the lesser? A lesser offense may fit inside the greater as a matter of law yet have no rational evidentiary basis in a particular trial. Both requirements must be met before submission.

A lower penalty does not create an included offense

“Lesser” can be misleading. A Class A misdemeanor is not automatically included in a Class C felony involving similar conduct. A lower-grade offense may contain a different victim status, location, purpose, result, mental state, type of property, value range, or act. If it adds any element not required for the charged offense, it is not necessarily included under Rule 31(c).

Penalty comparisons matter after the legal analysis, not instead of it. Counsel should prepare two columns of elements, choose the exact charged subsections, and circle every difference. Broad offense names such as assault, theft, restraint, sexual offense, or obstruction conceal statutory distinctions.

The rule is not limited to defense requests

Either the prosecution or the defense may request a lesser-included instruction when law and evidence support it. Vance recognized that both sides may seek submission. The court also has responsibility for an accurate charge, although North Dakota decisions generally reject a rule requiring every conceivable lesser instruction without a request.

A prosecution request late in trial deserves careful scrutiny. The defense should test legal inclusion, evidentiary support, fair notice, timing, prejudice, and whether the State is trying to replace an unproved charged theory with a different offense. Rule 31(c) is not permission to rescue a case with a charge that is not actually included.

Attempt requires separate analysis

Older versions of Rule 31(c) expressly mentioned attempt; the current rule states only that a defendant may be found guilty of an offense necessarily included in the charged offense. Whether attempt is available depends on the charging instrument, the attempt statute, the completed offense, current precedent, and the evidence. Do not assume every charged crime contains a viable attempt verdict.

Attempt has its own culpability and substantial-step requirements. Some offenses are conceptually incompatible with attempt, and some statutory schemes treat inchoate liability specially. If either side requests attempt, submit a complete elements comparison and explain how the evidence permits acquittal of the completed offense while proving attempt.

The constitutional floor is limited but important

In Beck v. Alabama, 447 U.S. 625, 637 (1980), a capital case, the United States Supreme Court warned that the absence of a supported lesser option “enhances the risk of an unwarranted conviction.” The holding addressed a statute that prohibited lesser-included instructions in capital trials; it does not create an automatic federal right to every lesser instruction in every noncapital case.

North Dakota practice is governed principally by Rule 31(c), state decisions, due process, and the evidence. Still, Beck captures the practical concern: a jury convinced that serious wrongdoing occurred may hesitate to acquit entirely even when the State failed to prove the greater offense’s distinguishing element.

Legal inclusion requires exact element comparison

Start with the operative charging theory

Obtain the latest information, every amendment, bill of particulars if any, and the court’s rulings limiting the prosecution’s theory. Identify the precise statutory subsection, alternative, grade, and alleged facts that function as elements. A comparison using the broadest imaginable version of a statute may answer the wrong question.

For each offense, list forbidden conduct, attendant circumstances, required result, culpability, nonexistence of a raised defense, and any fact governing grade that must be found by the jury. Use the law in effect on the offense date. Then ask whether proof of the charged greater, as legally defined, necessarily proves the proposed lesser.

The same-elements test rejects a same-evidence shortcut

Crimes do not merge merely because the State uses the same witnesses, photographs, recording, or physical act to prove them. In State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127, ¶¶ 7–10, the Court applied the same-elements rule and rejected a same-evidence test. Felonious restraint and forcible gross sexual imposition each required something the other did not, as did aggravated assault and the sexual offense.

That analysis also guards against an instruction error. If a proposed “lesser” needs proof of restraint but the greater does not, or needs injury where the greater needs sexual contact, the jury would be deciding an additional offense, not simply a subset of the charged crime.

Compare subsections, not only statute numbers

A statute may contain several distinct methods, victim categories, mental states, or grades. One subsection may contain a proposed lesser while another does not. Schaf, 2023 ND 81, stressed compatibility between the charged sexual-act subsection and the proposed sexual-contact subsection. A categorical statement that “sexual contact is lesser than sexual act” is too broad without the statutory details.

The same is true for assault, homicide, theft, drug, driving, weapons, and obstruction statutes. Build the comparison at the subsection and alternative level. If the information pleads alternatives, determine which remain after the evidence and whether the jury must receive an election or alternative-means instruction.

Culpability can determine inclusion

North Dakota’s culpability hierarchy may allow proof of a higher culpability level to satisfy a lower level under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-02-02(4), but the whole offense still must be compared. A negligent offense is not automatically included in every intentional offense if the conduct, result, circumstances, or statutory structure differs.

For homicide, the distinction among intentional or knowing murder, extreme-indifference murder, manslaughter, and negligent homicide requires separate attention to result, circumstances, and mental state. For assault, “willfully,” “knowingly,” “recklessly,” bodily injury, substantial bodily injury, serious bodily injury, weapon use, and victim status may alter the comparison.

Different grading facts may define a lesser degree

Many statutes grade one offense by value, quantity, injury, age difference, location, prior record, weapon, or status. A lower bracket may be included when it contains the same base elements and simply omits the aggravating fact or requires a nested threshold. But some grades use genuinely different conduct or circumstances rather than a nested scale.

Write out the statutory language for every grade. Ask whether a jury can make a clean finding that the State proved the base offense but not the aggravating fact. The verdict form should record the supported grade without inviting an unauthorized compromise.

Definitions can add decisive elements

Defined terms may turn what sounds like a subset into a different offense. “Sexual act” and “sexual contact,” “bodily injury” and “serious bodily injury,” “possesses,” “dangerous weapon,” “dwelling,” and “thing of value” carry statutory content. Inclusion cannot be decided by everyday meaning.

Vance compared the then-applicable statutory definitions of sexual act and sexual contact. Its method remains instructive even though statutes can change: unpack the defined terms, identify what additional contact or purpose each requires, and compare the actual charged alternatives.

Jurisdiction and venue do not make unrelated crimes included

Shared date, county, defendant identity, and victim identity do not transform separate offenses into greater and lesser forms. Those propositions may appear in both instructions, but inclusion turns on the substantive elements. Likewise, evidence that several offenses occurred during one continuous incident does not collapse them into one.

Unit-of-prosecution and multiplicity questions are related but distinct. One statute may punish each act, each victim, each item, each transaction, or a continuing course. Determine the allowable unit before deciding what instructions and verdict forms are needed.

The trial evidence must support acquittal of the greater and conviction of the lesser

The rational-evidence requirement prevents speculative compromise

A lesser instruction is proper only when evidence would allow a rational jury to reject at least one element distinguishing the greater offense while finding every element of the lesser beyond a reasonable doubt. It is not enough that jurors might feel mercy, distrust part of the State’s case generally, or prefer a lower punishment.

Identify the exact disputed element and the evidence on each side. If the only rational choices are that the charged offense occurred as alleged or no offense occurred, a lesser instruction may be unsupported. If testimony, physical evidence, expert opinion, or reasonable inference permits a third factual finding, submission may be warranted.

View the request through the appropriate evidentiary lens

When the defense requests an instruction, it should identify record evidence supporting the defense-favorable view and explain why credibility determinations belong to the jury. The court should not reject a supported lesser merely because the prosecution’s evidence is stronger. Conflicting testimony, uncertain identification, disputed injury, ambiguous intent, or competing causation evidence may create the rational distinction.

But “some evidence” cannot be disconnected from the legal elements. A witness’s uncertainty about a collateral detail does not necessarily support a different crime. The request should connect evidence to the precise greater element the jury could reasonably reject and the lesser elements it could find.

Partial disbelief is possible, but not limitless

Jurors may accept part of a witness’s testimony and reject another part. That principle can support a lesser verdict where the testimony separates conduct, intent, result, or circumstance. It does not authorize a verdict constructed from speculation that contradicts all evidence.

For example, injury evidence may support bodily injury but leave reasonable doubt about serious bodily injury. A recording may prove contact but not a statutorily defined sexual act. Evidence may show reckless causation while leaving doubt about an intentional result. The actual statute and record control each example.

Self-defense does not automatically require every lesser offense

North Dakota homicide decisions have discussed the relationship among self-defense, manslaughter, and negligent homicide. But later cases caution that courts do not automatically instruct on every lesser without a request and evidentiary support. State v. Wiedrich, 460 N.W.2d 680, 686–87 (N.D. 1990), turned on its particular homicide record and prior decisions.

State v. Mathre, 1999 ND 224, ¶¶ 5–10, rejected a claim that assault lessers had to be given without a proper request merely because self-defense was instructed. The prosecution and defense share responsibility to request instructions appropriate to their theories.

The evidence may change the analysis during trial

A pretrial comparison can show which lesser offenses are legally possible, but the evidentiary decision may remain open until the proof closes. A witness may change an account, an expert opinion may be limited, an exhibit may be excluded, or the prosecution may abandon an alternative. Counsel should update the requested set as those events occur.

Under N.D.R.Crim.P. 30(a)(2), a party may request an instruction after the close of evidence on an issue that could not reasonably have been anticipated earlier, and the court may permit other untimely requests. Make the request promptly and explain what new evidence created it.

Insufficient evidence of the greater does not always mean a lesser should go to the jury

If the State has no evidence on a required greater element, the defense should move for judgment of acquittal under Rule 29. A supported lesser may remain for decision, but the existence of a lesser does not relieve the court of deciding whether the greater may lawfully be submitted.

Keep the motions separate. A Rule 29 motion argues that no rational fact finder could convict on the greater. A lesser-instruction request argues that a rational fact finder could acquit on the greater and convict on the lesser. Those positions can be consistent when the defense preserves alternative relief, but counsel should state each ground precisely.

Requesting a lesser offense is a client-centered strategic decision

The lesser can protect against an overcharged verdict

When evidence strongly establishes some wrongdoing but leaves a real gap on the aggravating element, a lesser option lets jurors apply the law without choosing between an unsupported greater conviction and complete acquittal. It can focus deliberations on the fact that genuinely separates the offenses.

The request also gives defense counsel a coherent closing: the State has not proved the greater, and if jurors find the narrower conduct proved, the legally correct verdict is the lesser. That argument may be more credible than insisting on total acquittal against undisputed evidence.

The lesser can also create conviction risk

An all-or-nothing submission forces the State to prove the charged offense. Adding a lesser may give divided jurors a compromise and reduce the chance of acquittal or deadlock. It may also undermine a defense theory that the event never happened, the wrong person was charged, or the evidence is fabricated in its entirety.

No universal rule resolves the choice. Counsel should evaluate the strength of each element, likely juror reactions, sentencing difference, collateral consequences, immigration consequences, registration, firearm restrictions, licensing, restitution, enhancements, and the client’s informed objectives.

The lawyer should discuss the decision with the client

Instruction requests are legal strategy, but the client bears the consequences. Explain the greater and lesser elements, maximum and mandatory penalties, likely sentencing framework, collateral effects, the evidence supporting each outcome, and the possibility that a lesser option changes jury dynamics.

Document the consultation. The discussion should occur before the instruction conference whenever possible, not during a rushed recess. If testimony changes the analysis, revisit it. A client cannot make an informed decision from offense titles alone.

Oppose an unsupported prosecution lesser with a complete record

The State may seek a lesser after its greater theory weakens. The defense should identify the additional element that defeats legal inclusion or the missing evidence that defeats factual submission. Object to any constructive amendment, prejudice, inconsistent theory, inadequate notice, and verdict-form defect as applicable.

Do not rely only on “unfair surprise.” Rule 31(c) itself provides notice of genuine included offenses. The stronger objection is that the proposed offense is not necessarily included, the evidence does not rationally separate the verdicts, or the late change causes specific prejudice that cannot be cured.

Plea discussions should use the same disciplined analysis

Prosecutors and defense lawyers often use “lesser included” loosely in negotiation. A reduced charge may be a related offense accepted by agreement even if it is not legally included. That can be a valid resolution, but the record and plea paperwork should identify the actual offense rather than assume Rule 31(c) would authorize it after trial.

Compare elements, factual basis, sentence, collateral consequences, restitution, enhancements, and dismissal terms. A plea to a non-included related offense requires the procedural authority and defendant’s informed consent applicable to the agreement; it should not be mislabeled as an automatic jury alternative.

The instruction and verdict form must make the greater–lesser relationship understandable

Give complete elements for every submitted offense

Do not tell jurors merely that one offense is a lesser form of another. State every element of the greater and every element of the lesser, with applicable definitions and burden. Highlight the distinguishing proposition through structure and closing argument, not argumentative judicial language.

Check mental states carefully. If the greater and lesser use different culpability, define each and attach it to the correct element. If the distinction is injury, value, quantity, age, weapon, or status, the instructions and evidence must let jurors make that finding without guessing.

Use a clear deliberation sequence without coercion

Courts may instruct jurors on the order in which to consider greater and lesser offenses. The wording should promote orderly decision-making without forcing jurors to surrender views on the greater, falsely suggesting they must convict of something, or obscuring the requirement of unanimity.

Review whether the charge uses an “acquittal-first,” “unable-to-agree,” or another sequence and whether North Dakota authority and local practice support it. The verdict forms must match. Counsel should object to a sequence that creates inconsistent or ambiguous findings.

One count may have more than one supported lesser

A hierarchy may include several nested offenses, but each step requires its own legal and evidentiary foundation. A court should not populate the charge with every lower grade as a menu. Too many unsupported choices increase confusion and compromise risk.

Create a comparison chart showing what distinguishes the greater from lesser one, lesser one from lesser two, and so on. Then determine whether the evidence supplies a rational stopping point at each level. The instructions should explain the sequence and the forms should prevent multiple convictions for the same greater–lesser chain.

Verdict forms should identify one lawful outcome per count

For a count submitted with a lesser, the forms should permit not guilty, guilty of the charged offense, or guilty of the supported lesser in a manner consistent with the court’s sequence instruction. They should not allow guilty verdicts on both the greater and its included lesser for the same offense unit.

Inspect the final forms for offense names, statutory alternatives, count numbers, signatures, and special findings. If grading depends on a fact, decide whether the offense label alone records it adequately or whether a separate finding is required. Raise ambiguity before the jury retires.

Closing argument must respect every submitted option

The defense may argue for complete acquittal while also explaining why, if jurors reject that position, the greater’s distinguishing element is unproved. Make clear that the State bears the burden on every offense and that the presence of a lesser option is not evidence that any crime occurred.

Object if the prosecutor suggests the jury should use the lesser as a compromise, punishment discount, or fallback despite reasonable doubt on its elements. Jurors must decide guilt, not negotiate. The court should correct any argument implying that they are required to select one of the conviction forms.

Preserve the request and objection under Rule 30

Submit the requested lesser instruction and verdict form in writing. Identify the charged and proposed statutory subsections, provide the element comparison, cite the trial evidence, and explain the rational acquittal-and-conviction finding. Obtain a ruling on both legal inclusion and evidentiary support.

If the court proposes a lesser over objection, state each ground distinctly. If the court refuses a defense lesser, preserve the exact text, record citations, authorities, and prejudice. Under Rule 30(c) and (d), a specific request and objection are far safer than relying on obvious-error review.

Submission, conviction, merger, and punishment are related but separate

A jury may consider alternatives without imposing multiple punishment

Greater and included lesser offenses may be presented as alternative verdicts on one count. If separate counts produce convictions for both based on the same offense unit, double-jeopardy and statutory-merger principles may require vacating one conviction. Concurrent sentences do not necessarily cure an unauthorized second conviction.

Analyze the unit of prosecution, same elements, legislative intent, actual verdicts, and judgment. Ask the court to resolve merger before sentencing and ensure the written judgment accurately identifies the surviving conviction.

The Blockburger comparison overlaps but does not answer every instruction issue

Smith, 2024 ND 127, ¶ 8, applied the federal same-elements test: if each offense requires proof of a fact the other does not, they are different offenses. That analysis is central to double jeopardy and strongly informs whether one offense is necessarily included in another.

But an instruction request also requires evidence supporting the lesser verdict. Conversely, even when two offenses are distinct under the same-elements test, other constitutional or statutory rules may limit cumulative punishment in a particular scheme. Keep the issues analytically separate.

An invited lesser can limit a later inconsistent-verdict argument

When the defense requests a lesser instruction and the jury returns verdicts the defense later calls inconsistent, invited-error doctrine may bar relief. The official opinion summary in State v. Aune, 2021 ND 7, identifies that consequence.

Before requesting multiple options, inspect how the count, sequence, and forms interact. Preserve objections to inconsistent forms even if the lesser itself is requested. The defense can support a lawful lesser while objecting to a structure that permits mutually incompatible findings.

Appellate review depends on what was requested and why

A preserved refusal presents legal and evidentiary questions using the trial record. An unrequested lesser usually does not produce reversible error merely because it might have been available. Mathre limited review to obvious error after the defendant failed to request the lesser instructions properly.

On appeal, the record should show the exact proposed language, the element comparison, evidentiary basis, strategic position, court’s reasoning, final charge, verdict forms, closing arguments, and verdict. Without that record, a reviewing court cannot determine whether the proposed lesser was legally included, factually supported, central, and prejudicial.

A practical lesser-included-offense checklist

  1. Identify the operative count, statutory subsection, alternatives, grade, and offense date.
  2. List every element of the charged offense, including culpability and grading facts.
  3. List every element of the proposed lesser using current statutes and definitions.
  4. Ask whether the greater can be committed without committing the proposed lesser.
  5. Identify any additional fact required only by the proposed lesser.
  6. Identify the exact greater element a rational jury could reject.
  7. Cite evidence supporting every lesser element and the greater-offense acquittal.
  8. Evaluate sentencing, mandatory penalties, collateral consequences, restitution, and enhancements.
  9. Discuss the all-or-nothing versus lesser-option consequences with the client.
  10. Submit complete written instructions and matching verdict forms.
  11. Object distinctly to unsupported language, sequence, or forms.
  12. Check the verdict and merger issues before the jury is discharged and before sentencing.

The checklist deliberately separates law, evidence, strategy, and remedy. Calling an offense “lesser” before completing all four stages is how unrelated charges, unsupported compromise verdicts, and avoidable preservation problems enter a case.

Frequently asked questions about lesser-included offenses in North Dakota

What is a lesser-included offense?

It is an offense whose elements are necessarily contained within the charged greater offense. The greater cannot be committed without also committing the lesser. A similar name, shared evidence, lower penalty, or occurrence during the same incident does not by itself establish inclusion.

What rule governs lesser offenses in North Dakota criminal trials?

N.D.R.Crim.P. 31(c) states that a defendant may be found guilty of an offense necessarily included in the offense charged. Rule 30 governs requests, the instruction conference, objections, preservation, and review of instruction error.

Does every legally included offense go to the jury?

No. The evidence also must allow a rational jury to find the defendant not guilty of the greater while finding every element of the lesser beyond a reasonable doubt. A legally possible lesser with no trial support should not be submitted merely to offer a compromise.

Can the prosecution request a lesser-included instruction?

Yes. Either side may request a supported lesser. The defense may oppose the request by showing that the proposed offense adds an element, the charged subsections are incompatible, the evidence does not rationally support the distinction, or the timing creates specific legally cognizable prejudice.

Can the judge give a lesser instruction neither side requested?

A court is responsible for an accurate charge, but North Dakota decisions generally do not require judges to give every possible lesser without a proper request. If the court proposes one, counsel should address legal inclusion, evidentiary support, sequence, verdict forms, and strategy on the record.

Is a misdemeanor automatically included in a related felony?

No. Classification does not decide inclusion. Compare each statutory element. A misdemeanor may require a fact the felony does not, in which case it is a separate offense even though its maximum penalty is lower.

Does using the same evidence mean one offense is included in another?

No. North Dakota rejects a same-evidence shortcut. The question is whether each statutory offense requires proof of a fact the other does not. One event and one set of witnesses can prove several legally distinct crimes.

Can a different mental state create a lesser offense?

Sometimes, but not automatically. North Dakota law addresses when proof of a higher culpability satisfies a lower level, yet counsel must compare all conduct, result, circumstance, and grading elements. Statutory structure may make superficially similar offenses distinct.

Is negligent homicide always a lesser offense of murder or manslaughter?

No automatic answer should be assumed. The charged homicide theory, statutory elements, culpability, causation evidence, defenses, and trial record control. North Dakota homicide cases provide important guidance, but a proper request and rational evidentiary basis remain essential.

Does self-defense require instructions on every lower assault or homicide grade?

No. The defense and lesser-offense issues must each be supported and properly requested. Mathre rejected an automatic rule that every assault lesser had to be given without a proper request merely because self-defense was before the jury.

Can attempt be submitted as a lesser offense?

It may be available in an appropriate case, but counsel must analyze the current rule, attempt statute, charged offense, culpability, substantial step, notice, and evidence. Do not assume attempt is included in every completed offense.

What if the evidence is insufficient on the greater offense?

The defense should make a specific Rule 29 motion for judgment of acquittal. A supported lesser may remain, but the existence of a possible lesser does not justify submitting an unsupported greater. Preserve the acquittal motion and instruction position separately.

Can the defense ask for acquittal and a lesser verdict in the alternative?

Yes. Counsel may argue that the State proved no offense and also explain that, if jurors reject that view, the distinguishing greater element remains unproved. The lesser still must be legally included and supported by evidence.

Does requesting a lesser make conviction more likely?

It can. A lesser may protect against an overcharged greater verdict, but it also supplies a conviction option and possible compromise. The decision should follow a case-specific assessment of evidence, sentencing, collateral consequences, jury dynamics, and the client’s informed objectives.

How should lesser offenses appear on verdict forms?

The forms should identify the count and each authorized outcome clearly, follow the court’s deliberation sequence, and avoid convictions on both the greater and included lesser for the same offense unit. Any grading or special finding must be recorded accurately.

Do greater and lesser convictions merge?

When both convictions represent the same offense under the same-elements and unit-of-prosecution analysis, one may need to be vacated. The answer depends on statutes, verdicts, conduct units, and legislative intent. Concurrent sentences alone do not necessarily eliminate the problem.

How is a refused lesser instruction preserved?

File a timely written request containing complete elements and a matching verdict form. Identify the statutory subsections, show why the offense is necessarily included, cite evidence supporting acquittal of the greater and conviction of the lesser, and obtain a clear ruling under Rule 30.

Can failure to request a lesser be raised for the first time on appeal?

Review is generally much narrower. North Dakota cases commonly limit unpreserved instruction claims to obvious error, a demanding standard reserved for plain error affecting substantial rights and serious injustice. Deliberate trial preservation is far safer.

Official authorities

Legal information, not legal advice. Lesser-included-offense analysis depends on the exact charged subsection, offense date, statutory definitions, trial evidence, requested instructions, verdict forms, and client objectives. Anyone facing a North Dakota criminal charge should obtain advice about the specific case.


Call nowChoose a time