Jury Instructions in North Dakota Criminal Cases
Jury instructions are the legal architecture of a criminal verdict. They tell jurors what the State must prove, what defenses apply, how evidence may be…
North Dakota criminal jury instructions, N.D.R.Crim.P. 30, pattern instructions, elements, culpability, defenses, lesser offenses, limiting instructions, verdict forms, instruction conferences, jury questions, preservation, obvious error, and appeal
Jury Instructions in North Dakota Criminal Cases
Jury instructions are the legal architecture of a criminal verdict. They tell jurors what the State must prove, what defenses apply, how evidence may be used, and what verdicts are legally available. A trial can be hard fought from voir dire through closing argument and still turn on one omitted element, one inaccurate definition, or one unanswered jury question.
Good instruction work begins before trial, follows the evidence as it develops, and ends only after the verdict is returned and the jury is discharged.
The governing framework is more than a book of patterns
Criminal Rule 30 controls requests, objections, timing, and form
A party may file and serve written instruction requests at the close of the evidence or at an earlier reasonable time set by the court. After the evidence closes, a party may request an instruction on an issue that could not reasonably have been anticipated. The court also may permit another untimely request. Each request may be required on a separate sheet, and a North Dakota pattern instruction may be requested by its number.
The court must tell the parties what instructions it proposes to give and how it will rule on their requests before the jury is instructed and before final arguments. The parties then must be allowed to object on the record and outside the jury’s hearing. This order matters. Counsel should know the legal rules that will govern deliberations before framing the closing argument.
Written instructions ordinarily go into the jury room
Rule 30 requires final instructions to be written unless the parties agree otherwise. Signed written instructions are provided to the jury during deliberations. Oral instructions may accompany the jury only if they are transcribed and the court orders it. The jury must return all instructions with the verdict.
Because jurors will read the document without lawyers standing beside them, wording, organization, cross-references, count numbers, defendant names, defined terms, and verdict-form labels deserve exacting review. A harmless typographical defect may be obvious to counsel but genuinely confusing in a jury room.
North Dakota pattern instructions are advisory
The North Dakota Pattern Jury Instruction Commission develops civil and criminal forms, and the judiciary publishes them for judges, lawyers, and self-represented litigants. The court system expressly warns that the patterns are “advisory only” and that publication does not constitute Supreme Court approval or authoritative construction. Some subjects have no pattern at all.
A pattern may predate a statutory amendment, a new appellate decision, a renamed offense, or a changed burden. It may present optional language that does not fit the evidence. It may contain alternatives that must be selected rather than read together. A lawyer should compare every proposed pattern with the statute in effect on the alleged offense date, the information, the current rules, and the newest controlling cases.
The instructions are judged as one integrated document
The appellate court reviews the charge as a whole, not by isolating a phrase that favors one side. State v. Landsberger, 2025 ND 108, ¶¶ 4–9, explains that reversal is appropriate only when the charge as a whole is erroneous, concerns a central subject, and affects a substantial right. The decision also illustrates a practical limit: a requested instruction should not add a statutory element or make the State prove more than the statute requires.
Reading the whole charge does not make a central omission disappear. In State v. Smith, 2023 ND 6, ¶¶ 10–18, the felony tampering instruction omitted the requirement that the conduct substantially obstruct, impair, or pervert prosecution for a felony. The Supreme Court held that omitting an essential element was obvious error affecting substantial rights.
Due process requires a finding on every essential element
The State bears the burden to prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt. That constitutional rule, recognized in In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358, 364 (1970), must appear in instructions that actually identify the elements jurors must find. A correct general burden instruction does not necessarily cure an element instruction that leaves out a fact required for conviction.
Element review should begin with the enacted text, not a charge label or police report. Counsel should identify the conduct, culpability, attendant circumstances, result, grading fact, jurisdiction, venue, statutory definition, and any fact that increases the permissible punishment. The instruction must match the offense actually charged and the legally valid theory tried.
Preliminary instructions shape the trial jurors will hear
Immediately after the jury is sworn, the court may instruct on juror duties and conduct, the order of proceedings, elementary legal principles, and any permitted written-question procedure. The North Dakota Jury Standards contemplate preliminary orientation about the parties’ roles, evidence, issues, and basic principles, followed by final instructions on substantive law and deliberation.
Defense counsel should review preliminary instructions with the same care as the final set. They may address the presumption of innocence, burden of proof, the difference between questions and evidence, note taking, outside research, electronic communications, implicit bias, media exposure, and the defendant’s right not to testify. If a preliminary instruction becomes inaccurate as the case develops, request a final correction.
Build the instruction set from the charge, proof, and actual disputes
Create a count-by-count elements chart before trial
For every count, place the information beside the statute and proposed element instruction. Mark each culpability word, defined term, enhancement, alternative, date, county, named person, property description, value threshold, injury level, weapon allegation, age, status, and predicate offense. Then identify the evidence each side says proves or disproves the item.
This exercise exposes quiet problems: the information alleges one subsection while the pattern tracks another; the statute changed between the alleged offense and trial; an enhancement appears in the caption but not the elements; an “or” becomes an “and”; a required result is described as mere conduct; or the verdict form does not reveal which grade the jury found.
Use the correct culpability for each material element
North Dakota’s culpability rules require careful element-by-element analysis. “Intentionally,” “knowingly,” “recklessly,” “willfully,” and “negligently” are not interchangeable. Some offenses expressly assign a mental state; others require application of general culpability provisions. A definition may operate differently for conduct, a circumstance, or a result.
Do not paste a complete block of mental-state definitions into every charge. Give the definition the jury needs, connect it to the element it modifies, and delete inapplicable alternatives. When the prosecution’s theory shifts during trial, compare the final proposed language with the charging instrument and any amendment ruling.
Define technical terms without arguing the evidence
A statutory definition belongs in the charge when the term has a specialized legal meaning material to the verdict. Ordinary words usually need no judicial gloss. Too few definitions leave jurors to invent legal meaning; too many bury the elements under abstractions and can make the judge appear to emphasize one side’s theory.
Proposed definitions should quote or faithfully paraphrase controlling law and remain neutral. Avoid embedding disputed facts inside the definition. If “dangerous weapon,” “serious bodily injury,” “official proceeding,” “consent,” “value,” or another defined term controls guilt or grading, state the definition near the count where it matters rather than forcing jurors to hunt through unrelated pages.
Match the instructions to the evidence without commenting on credibility
An instruction needs a legal and evidentiary foundation. The court may refuse language that is irrelevant or inapplicable, and it need not use counsel’s exact words if the charge fairly covers the law. Krall, 2026 ND 7, ¶¶ 33–40, affirmed refusal of a requested circumstantial-evidence instruction because the instructions as a whole correctly addressed evidence and reasonable doubt.
At the same time, the court should not decide which testimony is true through the wording of the charge. Use conditional language for disputed facts. Identify the legal consequence if the jury finds a fact, not whether the fact occurred. A neutral instruction preserves the jury’s responsibility to assess weight and credibility.
Separate multiple counts and multiple defendants
The jury should be told to consider each count and each defendant separately. Evidence admitted against one defendant or for one count may not be usable against another. Names, count numbers, date ranges, alleged victims, and verdict-form options must remain consistent from the information through the final charge.
In a long case, a verdict map helps: one page listing each count, its elements instruction, applicable definitions, limited-use evidence, defense, lesser offense, and verdict form. The map is not a substitute for the instructions. It is a quality-control device for counsel and, if the court approves a neutral version, may help jurors avoid mixing charges.
Alternative means and factual theories require special attention
A statute may state several ways to commit an offense. The charging document may allege one, several, or all. The State’s proof may narrow the issue further. Counsel must decide whether the alternatives are separate elements requiring unanimity, alternative means, or merely evidentiary facts. That question affects the element instruction, election requests, unanimity language, closing argument, and verdict form.
A generic instruction that repeats every statutory alternative can authorize conviction on a theory never charged or supported. Conversely, deleting alternatives too casually can distort the offense. The analysis must use statutory text, legislative structure, current case law, and the trial record. The separate unanimity guide addresses this subject in depth.
Grading facts must appear where jurors can find them
Value, injury, victim age, weapon use, prior convictions when lawfully submitted, quantity, location, and other facts may determine the grade or sentence. If the law requires a jury finding, the fact belongs in an element instruction and ordinarily in a verdict form that records the finding. It should not be left only in a preliminary statement or definition.
Smith is the cautionary example. The omitted “substantially obstructs, impairs, or perverts” language separated misdemeanor conduct from felony conduct. A lawyer reviewing only the base prohibition could miss the fact that controlled the permissible conviction and punishment.
Verdict forms and instructions must say the same thing
A correct instruction can be undermined by an inconsistent verdict form. The form should identify the count, defendant, offense, lesser offense if any, and every special finding the law requires. It should not combine mutually exclusive findings, use a different offense name, or invite a compromise verdict not authorized by law.
Under N.D.R.Crim.P. 31, a criminal verdict must be unanimous and returned to a judge in open court. The rule also addresses partial verdicts in multi-defendant or multi-count cases, polling, and verdicts on lesser offenses. Review the forms under the same preservation procedure as the written instructions.
Defense instructions must translate the defense theory into law
A theory instruction should be legally correct and tied to evidence
The defense is entitled to have a genuinely raised legal issue decided under accurate instructions. That does not mean the court must adopt a closing argument in judicial language. A proposed theory instruction should state the governing rule neutrally, identify the evidence supporting submission, and explain how the rule affects the State’s burden or the verdict.
When requesting the instruction, cite the transcript or expected testimony and the controlling authority. Explain why general instructions do not cover the issue. Provide a clean written version and, when useful, a redline against the closest pattern. This gives the judge a workable choice and creates an appellate record.
Justification and excuse instructions require count-specific drafting
Self-defense, defense of others, duress, necessity, and related doctrines depend on statutory conditions and the evidence. Do not assume one general defense instruction automatically applies to every count. Identify which charged offenses permit the defense, what facts raise it, who bears what burden, and whether the nonexistence of the defense becomes an additional proposition the State must prove.
Smith, 2023 ND 6, ¶¶ 6–8, shows the preservation danger. The jury received general self-defense language and the defense was included in the attempted-murder elements, but not in the reckless-endangerment elements. Because the defendant requested the reckless-endangerment instruction and did not object, the Court treated the asserted error as invited and waived.
Do not turn alibi or simple denial into a defense burden
An alibi is evidence that the accused was elsewhere, not an affirmative obligation to prove innocence. Misidentification, lack of possession, accident, or a claim that the event did not occur likewise may simply negate the State’s elements. The charge should not suggest that the defendant must establish these propositions before the jury can acquit.
When a special instruction would clarify the issue, draft it around the continuing burden of proof. Avoid labels that make the defense sound exceptional or suspect. Closing argument can identify the reasonable doubt created by the evidence; the judge’s charge should preserve the allocation of proof.
Lesser-included offenses require a deliberate decision
A lesser-offense request can protect against an all-or-nothing verdict, but it also gives jurors a conviction option they otherwise would not have. Counsel must analyze legal inclusion, evidentiary support, notice, the client’s objectives, sentencing exposure, collateral consequences, and how the verdict sequence will work.
The instructions should state the elements of each lesser offense, distinguish them from the greater, and explain when jurors may consider them without pressuring a compromise. The verdict forms must track the sequence and preserve unanimity. Because the doctrine is detailed, it is treated separately in the next guide.
The right not to testify may require a requested instruction
A defendant’s silence cannot be used as evidence of guilt. If the defense requests a no-adverse-inference instruction, federal constitutional law requires it. Carter v. Kentucky, 450 U.S. 288, 300–03 (1981). Counsel should discuss the instruction with the client because some defendants prefer not to highlight the absence of testimony, while others want the rule stated plainly.
The final language should be direct: the defendant has an absolute right not to testify; the jury must not consider the choice for any purpose; and the burden remains entirely with the State. Related preliminary instructions and voir dire can identify jurors unwilling to follow that rule.
Limiting instructions need a purpose, subject, and time
Evidence admitted for one purpose but not another requires practical guidance. “Consider this only for a proper purpose” says almost nothing. Identify the evidence, the permitted issue, the forbidden inference, the affected count or defendant, and whether the instruction should be given when the evidence arrives, in the final charge, or both.
Common subjects include other-acts evidence, impeachment convictions, hearsay admitted for a nontruth purpose, an accomplice’s statement, expert-basis material, evidence admissible against only one defendant, and a redacted confession. A limiting instruction cannot cure every constitutional or prejudice problem, so admissibility must be decided first.
Witness instructions should remain neutral
Instructions may address credibility factors, inconsistent statements, expert opinions, informants, accomplices, law-enforcement witnesses, interpreters, and child witnesses where the law and evidence support them. They should not tell jurors that a class of witness is truthful, unreliable, disinterested, or entitled to extra weight.
If a witness received benefits, has pending charges, was paid, violated an agreement, or has a motive to curry favor, the primary tools are disclosure, cross-examination, exhibits, and argument. A special instruction may be warranted, but it should describe permissible evaluation without deciding the witness’s credibility.
Evidence instructions must fit modern exhibits
Digital trials raise instruction issues that older patterns may not answer. A compilation, transcript, timeline, enhanced recording, translated message, map, animation, demonstrative, summary exhibit, or screenshot may be admitted evidence, a limited aid, or inadmissible argument. Jurors should know which category applies and what controls if an aid conflicts with the original.
Request the instruction when the exhibit is first used, not after confusion has set in. Identify whether jurors will receive the item during deliberations and ensure the evidence list matches the court’s ruling. Remove excluded pages, annotations, metadata, comments, and alternate versions from the jury materials.
The instruction conference is a trial proceeding, not housekeeping
Submit a complete defense set and a decision chart
A complete submission should include general instructions that matter to the defense, each count’s elements, definitions, defenses, limited-use rules, lesser offenses, deliberation rules, and verdict forms. Number every request. Cite authority. Identify which language is standard, modified, or original. Provide editable copies in the format the court requests.
Maintain a chart showing the request, State’s position, court’s ruling, final instruction number, objection, ground, and verdict-form consequence. Update it as testimony changes. The chart prevents a late ruling on one instruction from quietly breaking another.
Audit the court’s final proposal line by line
Compare the proposal with the operative information, statutes, granted amendments, evidentiary rulings, and proof. Check headings, dates, counties, names, pronouns, numbering, cross-references, punctuation, alternatives, and quotation marks. Read the elements aloud. Then read only the verdict forms and ask what findings they actually record.
Do not assume the version displayed during the conference is the version printed for jurors. Ask to inspect the signed final set and any electronic copy. If last-minute edits occur, repeat the review. A single word—especially “and,” “or,” “not,” “may,” or a culpability term—can change the rule.
State objections distinctly and obtain rulings
Rule 30(c) requires an on-record objection that distinctly identifies the matter and grounds. “Same objections,” “we object to the State’s set,” or “we stand on our filings” may leave uncertainty about what survived revisions. State the instruction number, quote or describe the disputed language, identify the missing language, cite the rule, and explain the legal consequence.
For a refused defense request, confirm that the written request is filed and marked, identify supporting evidence, and obtain a ruling. If the judge modifies the request, object to the final language if necessary. If the court reserves decision, renew before the jury is charged and before closings.
Use the settled instructions to structure closing argument
Closing should follow the verdict task jurors will receive. Display or quote the actual elements accurately, take them in order, and connect reasonable doubt to a proposition the State must prove. Explain a defense using the court’s wording. If an item has a limited purpose, respect the limiting instruction rather than inviting error.
Listen for the prosecutor misstating the burden, diluting reasonable doubt, shifting proof to the defendant, arguing an uncharged theory, contradicting a defense instruction, or treating a limiting instruction as optional. Object in time for the court to correct the statement. A final charge does not automatically erase a serious misstatement in argument.
Watch and listen while the judge reads
The judge may miss a line, repeat a paragraph, substitute a word, or orally clarify the written version. Follow with a clean copy and mark any variance. If the oral charge differs materially, raise the issue outside the jury’s hearing immediately and request a correction in open court plus a corrected written copy.
Make sure the full charge is reported. Confirm all exhibits and instructions going to the jury are the admitted, redacted, approved versions. If jurors have already seen an error, the record should show what they saw, for how long, and what correction was given.
Instruction work continues during deliberations
Every jury communication belongs on the record
A jury question can reveal a genuine legal misunderstanding. The court should notify counsel, place the exact note on the record, hear positions, decide the response, and communicate in open court or through an approved written response. The Jury Standards contemplate that communications from voir dire through discharge be in writing or on the record with counsel informed and heard.
Ask to preserve the original note, including markings and time received. A paraphrase can lose the issue. The response should answer the legal question accurately without invading deliberations, commenting on evidence, or introducing a new theory.
“Refer to the instructions” is not always enough
If the existing charge directly and accurately answers the question, directing jurors to a particular instruction may be sensible. If the question exposes ambiguity, contradiction, or an omitted rule, a generic referral can deepen confusion. Counsel should propose exact responsive language and explain why the original set does or does not resolve the concern.
A supplemental instruction must be reviewed in context with the entire charge. It may require a related reminder about burden, unanimity, the presumption of innocence, or limited use. Give counsel a meaningful chance to object before the response reaches jurors.
A deadlock response must not coerce a verdict
When jurors report difficulty agreeing, the court may encourage continued deliberation but should not pressure minority jurors, demand surrender of honest convictions, imply that retrial is unacceptable, ask for a numerical division in a way that creates coercion, or set an artificial deadline. Time of day, length of trial, length of deliberations, wording, and repeated messages all matter.
Defense counsel should request balanced language reminding every juror to decide individually after fair discussion, to remain open to reasoned reconsideration, and not to abandon an honestly held view merely to return a verdict. Object before the supplemental charge is delivered and renew if a later message changes the context.
Verdict return requires a final legal check
Rule 31 requires the verdict in open court and permits polling on request or on the court’s initiative. Polling must occur before discharge. If the poll reveals lack of unanimity, the court may direct further deliberation or discharge the jury. Counsel should compare every returned form with the instructions and confirm signatures, count labels, special findings, and consistency.
Do not let the jury leave while an ambiguity can still be clarified lawfully. An unsigned form, inconsistent greater-and-lesser findings, a blank special interrogatory, or a verdict on an offense not submitted demands immediate attention. Once the jury is discharged, available remedies narrow sharply.
Preservation is exacting because the trial judge must get a fair chance to correct the charge
A written request preserves the refusal only if it is legally usable
Rule 30(d) permits assignment of error for failure to give an instruction when the party properly requested it. The request should be timely, written, accurate, supported by evidence, and filed. If the court changes the legal issue or the evidence creates a new one, use Rule 30(a)(2) and request the instruction as soon as the basis becomes apparent.
Preserve the proposed text, authorities, supporting record citations, opposition, ruling, and final charge. A request mentioned in chambers but absent from the record is fragile. A correct principle hidden inside an argumentative or partly incorrect instruction may not require the judge to rewrite it for counsel.
An objection must identify both the language and the reason
To challenge an instruction actually given, object on the record at the Rule 30 opportunity and distinctly state the ground. Explain whether the problem is a missing element, wrong subsection, burden shift, unsupported theory, inaccurate definition, duplicative emphasis, constitutional defect, inconsistency, or refusal of defense language. If more than one ground applies, state each.
N.D.R.Crim.P. 51 similarly preserves a claimed ruling or order error by telling the court what action is sought or objecting with grounds when the ruling is made or requested. Formal exceptions are unnecessary; specificity is not.
Invited error can be worse than forfeiture
Failure to object generally narrows review to obvious error. Affirmatively requesting or agreeing to the defective language may waive the issue altogether. Smith, 2023 ND 6, ¶¶ 7–8, applied the invited-error principle to the reckless-endangerment instruction the defendant had requested.
Do not approve the package merely because most of it is acceptable. State that there is no objection except for identified requests and objections. If the court asks whether language is “agreed,” clarify whether the defense agrees it accurately reflects a ruling while continuing to object to the ruling itself.
Obvious error is a narrow safety valve
Rule 30(d)(2) allows review of unpreserved plain error affecting substantial rights, and N.D.R.Crim.P. 52(b) supplies the broader obvious-error rule. The defendant generally must show an error, that it was plain under current law, and that it affected substantial rights. Even then, correction is reserved for serious injustice affecting the fairness, integrity, or public reputation of proceedings.
An omitted essential element can satisfy the standard, as Smith demonstrates. But unclear or unsettled law may prevent an error from being “plain,” and invited error may foreclose review. Trial preservation is therefore part of the merits, not appellate paperwork.
Appellate review uses the whole record
Jury instructions are fully reviewable as legal issues, but reversal requires more than spotting an imperfect sentence. The reviewing court asks whether the whole charge correctly stated the law, whether the issue was central, whether a substantial right was affected, how the parties tried and argued the case, and whether the error was harmless under the applicable standard.
Build that record at trial. Identify the disputed issue, evidence supporting the defense, argument the instruction permits or prevents, verdict-form consequence, and prejudice. If the court refuses relief, request a clear ruling. If a later event changes the analysis, renew. A precise record helps the trial judge fix the problem and allows meaningful review if the problem remains.
A practical defense checklist for North Dakota jury instructions
- Obtain the operative information and every amendment.
- Compare each count with the statute in effect on the alleged offense date.
- List every conduct, circumstance, result, culpability, grading, venue, and jurisdiction proposition.
- Check current pattern instructions, explanatory notes, statutes, rules, and controlling cases.
- Identify defense theories, lesser offenses, limited-use evidence, multiple-defendant issues, and special findings.
- Draft count-specific instructions and matching verdict forms.
- File numbered written requests with authority and evidentiary support.
- Update requests as rulings and testimony change.
- Review the court’s complete proposal and signed final set line by line.
- Make distinct on-record objections and obtain rulings before argument.
- Structure closing around the settled charge and object to material misstatements.
- Follow the oral reading and confirm jurors receive only approved materials.
- Place every jury question, response, supplemental charge, and objection on the record.
- Inspect verdict forms and poll the jury when appropriate before discharge.
This checklist cannot decide a case-specific issue. It does show why instruction work should not be postponed until the evidence closes. By then, the legal theory, exhibit rulings, witness examinations, and closing strategy may already depend on decisions that should have been made earlier.
Frequently asked questions about North Dakota criminal jury instructions
Are North Dakota pattern jury instructions binding?
No. The North Dakota Court System describes them as advisory and warns users to review statutes, rules, and case law. They are valuable drafting resources, but the trial judge and lawyers remain responsible for ensuring the final charge accurately fits the current law, charging document, evidence, and issues.
When must requested instructions be filed?
Rule 30 permits requests at the close of the evidence or at an earlier reasonable time directed by the court. Scheduling orders commonly set an earlier deadline. After the evidence closes, a party may request an instruction on an issue that could not reasonably have been anticipated, and the court may allow another late request.
Can a lawyer request a pattern instruction just by number?
Yes. Rule 30(a)(3) permits a request by North Dakota pattern-instruction number. Modified or original language should be submitted in full. Even when requesting by number, counsel should verify the current version and explain which optional language applies.
Must the judge use the defense lawyer’s exact wording?
No. The question is whether the instructions as a whole accurately and adequately state the law without misleading or confusing the jury. A court may refuse redundant, argumentative, unsupported, or inaccurate wording. The defense should explain why the general charge does not fairly cover the requested legal issue.
What happens if an essential element is omitted?
An element omission is a serious constitutional problem because the jury has not been required to find every fact necessary for conviction. In State v. Smith, the North Dakota Supreme Court found obvious error where the felony instruction omitted the fact distinguishing felony tampering from the lower offense. Remedy and prejudice remain case-specific.
Does a correct reasonable-doubt instruction cure a missing element?
Not necessarily. The burden instruction tells jurors how certain they must be about propositions submitted to them. It does not supply a proposition the court never told them to decide. Counsel must review both the general burden language and every offense-specific element.
How does the defense preserve an objection to an instruction?
Object on the record at the Rule 30 conference, identify the instruction and disputed language or omission, and distinctly state each legal ground. Confirm the final ruling after revisions. For a refused instruction, timely submit a correct written request supported by evidence and authority and ensure it remains in the record.
Is a written motion enough without an oral objection?
Do not assume it is. Rule 30 gives counsel an on-record opportunity to object to the court’s final proposal. Use it. State whether the written ground remains applicable after revisions and identify the final instruction. A short, precise renewal eliminates needless preservation disputes.
What is invited error?
Invited error occurs when a party asks for, agrees to, or helps create the ruling later challenged. It can bar review rather than merely limit review to obvious error. Counsel should not approve a complete instruction set without clearly preserving specific objections and refused requests.
Can the jury receive instructions before the evidence is finished?
Yes. Rule 30 allows instructions at any time after trial begins and before discharge, and expressly permits preliminary instructions after the jury is sworn. Final substantive instructions usually follow the evidence, but a court may explain basic principles or recurring evidence limits earlier.
Does the jury take the written instructions into deliberations?
Ordinarily yes. Final instructions must be written unless the parties agree otherwise, and signed written instructions are provided for deliberation. Counsel should inspect the exact final copy for omissions, inconsistent edits, and formatting problems before it reaches the jury.
When is a limiting instruction needed?
When evidence is admissible for one purpose, count, or defendant but not another, a clear limiting instruction may be appropriate. It should identify the evidence, permitted use, forbidden inference, and affected count or person. Counsel should decide whether it is needed immediately, finally, or both.
Can the defendant receive a self-defense instruction without testifying?
Potentially. The issue is whether evidence in the record is legally sufficient to raise the defense, not whether the defendant personally supplied it. Other witnesses, recordings, physical evidence, or the State’s proof may provide the foundation. The instruction must be tailored to the counts to which the defense applies.
Should the jury be instructed that the defendant did not testify?
If the defense requests a no-adverse-inference instruction, the court must give an accurate one. Whether to request it is a strategic decision counsel should discuss with the client. The instruction should make clear that silence cannot be considered for any purpose and does not shift the burden.
What happens when jurors ask a legal question?
The exact question should be preserved, counsel should be notified and heard, and the response should be placed on the record. The court may refer jurors to an adequate existing instruction or give a focused supplemental instruction. The answer must not comment on facts or coerce deliberations.
Can the court urge a deadlocked jury to keep deliberating?
It may give balanced encouragement, but the message cannot coerce jurors to abandon honestly held views. Counsel should evaluate wording, timing, repeated messages, and the trial’s circumstances, propose neutral language, and object before an improper supplemental instruction is delivered.
Must a North Dakota criminal verdict be unanimous?
Yes. Rule 31(a) requires a unanimous verdict returned to a judge in open court. Unanimity becomes more complicated when a count contains multiple statutory alternatives or factual theories, which is why the element instruction, any special unanimity language, closing argument, and verdict form must be reviewed together.
What should counsel do before the jury is discharged?
Inspect every verdict form for signatures, count labels, special findings, blanks, and inconsistencies. Request polling when appropriate. Raise any uncertainty immediately while the jury remains available to clarify a lawful verdict. After discharge, correction is far more difficult.
Official authorities
- N.D.R.Crim.P. 30 — Jury Instructions
- N.D.R.Crim.P. 31 — Jury Verdict
- N.D.R.Crim.P. 51 — Preserving Claimed Error
- N.D.R.Crim.P. 52 — Harmless and Obvious Error
- North Dakota Pattern Jury Instructions
- North Dakota Jury Standards
- State v. Krall, 2026 ND 7
- State v. Landsberger, 2025 ND 108
- State v. Smith, 2023 ND 6