Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Chain of Custody in North Dakota Criminal Cases

A chain of custody is not paperwork for its own sake. It connects the item tested or shown to the jury with the item seized in the case and helps…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

Rule 901, physical evidence, drugs, biological samples, firearms, phones, digital files, evidence seals, property rooms, transfers, shipping, laboratory intake, contamination, substitution, destructive testing, hashes, metadata, missing links, authentication, expert reports, confrontation, discovery, objections, and postconviction DNA testing

Chain of Custody in North Dakota Criminal Cases

A chain of custody is not paperwork for its own sake. It connects the item tested or shown to the jury with the item seized in the case and helps establish that no material substitution, contamination, alteration, or loss occurred. The necessary proof depends on the evidence. A uniquely marked firearm presents different risks from powder, blood, urine, DNA swabs, a phone extraction, or a laboratory subsample.

Follow the evidence, not just the envelope. A complete custody analysis identifies the source item, every transfer, every opening and resealing, storage conditions, sampling, testing, consumption, derived material, digital processing, and the precise exhibit offered at trial.

Chain of custody is part of authentication, not a mechanical formula

The foundational question is whether the evidence permits a reasonable juror to find that the offered item is what the proponent says it is. A chain may prove identity and substantially unchanged condition through testimony, labels, serial numbers, seals, logs, photographs, barcodes, hashes, and laboratory records. No single form is universally required.

The chain should be evaluated against the claim. If the State offers a firearm only as a visibly identifiable object recovered at a scene, testimony and a serial number may suffice. If the State offers a swab as the source of a DNA profile, the foundation must connect collection, packaging, storage, laboratory receipt, extraction, amplification, analysis, and the reported profile.

Authentication is a threshold, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt that nothing happened to the item. The court may admit evidence despite a minor gap and let the jury assess weight. But a gap that creates a genuine question whether the item was substituted, contaminated, or materially altered can undermine the threshold itself, especially when the evidence is fungible or the disputed result depends on its condition.

Readily identifiable objects require a different showing from fungible material

Kroeplin remains the clearest North Dakota statement. The Court explained that continuous possession is less important for real evidence “impervious to change,” such as a gun identified by serial number and other characteristics, than for items easily diluted, altered, or substituted. 266 N.W.2d at 540. The strength of the required chain rises with the risk of undetected change.

A uniquely damaged tool, serialized device, or marked firearm may be recognized directly. White powder, pills without unique markings, liquid, blood, urine, tissue, hair, residue, and mixed biological material are less self-identifying. The same principle applies to digital data: a physical phone may have a serial number, but a screenshot or exported database may be transformed without visible signs.

A custody gap can affect admissibility, weight, or both

Courts often treat unexplained gaps as weight issues when the item is otherwise reliably identified and alteration is unlikely. That does not mean every gap is immaterial. The defense should show why the gap matters: an unsealed bag, conflicting item numbers, unexplained weight change, missing sample, storage outside required temperature, access by unknown persons, or a digital file with inconsistent hashes.

The distinction is factual. “There is a missing signature” is weaker than “the package was unsealed during the unlogged interval and the laboratory weight exceeded the seizure weight.” The more the defect connects to substitution, contamination, degradation, or the tested characteristic, the stronger the request for exclusion or a limiting ruling.

Condition is part of the claim when testing depends on condition

An item may be the same physical object yet no longer be in materially the same condition. Wet biological evidence can degrade in sealed plastic. Volatile substances can evaporate. A phone can receive remote commands. A firearm can be cleaned or test-fired. A specimen can be consumed. The chain must address preservation when condition affects the inference.

Ask what condition the State claims remained unchanged and why. Some changes are expected and documented, such as opening a package for analysis or creating a DNA extract. The foundation should explain each transformation, the controls used, and the relationship between the original item, derived sample, test result, and courtroom exhibit.

The evidentiary risk changes with the kind of item

Controlled substances and pills

Drug evidence is fungible and often central to identity and weight. Review collection location, separation of packages, field testing, gross and net weights, scales, packaging, seals, evidence-room storage, laboratory receipt, subsampling, confirmatory testing, retained material, and final weight. An unexplained increase, decrease, or package mismatch deserves focused inquiry.

Aggregation can change offense grading. If substances from different people, rooms, or dates are combined, the chain may destroy information relevant to possession and weight. Pills should be documented by count, markings, packaging, and source. A visual identification or database lookup may differ from chemical confirmation.

Field-test kits can consume or contaminate small quantities. The officer should document which material was tested, kit lot and expiration, procedure, result, and disposal. A presumptive result is not the same as laboratory confirmation. The chain should show that the tested laboratory sample came from the seized exhibit rather than merely a similarly labeled package.

Blood and urine

Impaired-driving and toxicology evidence requires careful identity and preservation proof. Identify the subject, collector, collection time, tube or cup, preservative, anticoagulant, kit expiration, mixing, seal, refrigeration, transport, laboratory receipt, and analysis. A medical sample drawn for treatment may follow different procedures from a law-enforcement kit.

Timing can affect interpretation even when custody is sound. Compare alleged driving time, draw time, receipt, analysis, and report. Storage temperature and preservative matter for some analytes. Review whether the laboratory recorded leakage, clotting, insufficient volume, unusual color, broken seal, or other condition.

DNA and other biological evidence

DNA evidence requires source control and contamination prevention from collection through interpretation. Examine gloves, tools, substrate, drying, packaging, control swabs, elimination samples, collection order, shared workspaces, reagent blanks, extraction batches, amplification plates, instrument runs, software analysis, and profile comparison.

The chain extends beyond the swab. Laboratory-created extracts, amplification products, electronic data, analyst projects, and interpretation files are derived evidence. Each should trace back to the original sample through unique identifiers and documented transfers. A correct report cannot cure a sample switch earlier in the process.

Mixtures and low-level DNA are especially sensitive to transfer and contamination. The defense should distinguish custody from interpretation: a pristine chain does not prove who deposited DNA, when, how, or through direct rather than secondary transfer. Conversely, an interpretation dispute does not necessarily show a custody defect.

Firearms, tools, and other durable objects

Serial numbers, model, caliber, markings, damage, photographs, and witness recognition can identify durable objects. Under Kroeplin, continuous custody is less critical when undetected alteration is unlikely. 266 N.W.2d at 540–41. Still, condition matters when the State relies on operability, fingerprints, DNA, residue, toolmarks, or test-firing results.

Document unloading, safety handling, cleaning, fingerprint processing, swabbing, firing, disassembly, and repairs. Test-fired bullets and cartridge cases become new evidence requiring identifiers. If the firearm was handled by multiple officers before prints or DNA collection, that history affects contamination and interpretation.

Clothing, weapons, and trace evidence

Clothing can carry blood, fibers, hairs, residue, soil, or biological material. Packaging multiple garments together can transfer trace evidence. Wet items can degrade. Knives, tools, and blunt objects may be durable but their surfaces can change through handling, swabbing, cleaning, or environmental exposure.

Trace evidence often involves very small material that moves through lifts, tape, vials, slides, stubs, or envelopes. The chain must connect the microscopic material tested to the collection location. Batch processing and shared laboratory areas raise contamination questions not apparent from the outer evidence bag.

Documents and money

Original documents may be identified through signatures, handwriting, paper, printing, folds, or serial numbers. Money can be identified by recorded serial numbers, photographs, packaging, or witness testimony. When fingerprints, DNA, chemicals, or counterfeit features are tested, condition and handling become more important than mere object identity.

Photocopying, scanning, annotation, and evidence stickers can obscure relevant features. Preserve the original when content, alterations, indented writing, ink, or physical characteristics matter. A courtroom copy should be connected to the original and accurately described as a duplicate.

Laboratory custody includes analytical and constitutional questions

Laboratory accession is a new custody stage

At receipt, the laboratory should record package condition, seals, identifiers, contents, weight or volume, discrepancies, and storage. Accession may assign a new laboratory number. The defense should map agency item numbers to laboratory numbers and every subsample. Similar case numbers or simultaneous submissions create switch risks that labels and controls are designed to prevent.

Obtain the complete case file, not only the final certificate: submission forms, receipt logs, photographs, chain records, worksheets, instrument data, quality controls, audit trails, notes, review records, corrective actions, and communications. The final report compresses a long process and may omit deviations important to the foundation.

Batch controls are part of reliability

Laboratories process multiple items together. Negative controls, blanks, positive controls, standards, calibrators, and quality checks help identify contamination or instrument failure. Review the entire relevant batch and sequence, not just the accused’s sample. An anomaly in a neighboring sample can explain carryover or misassignment.

Ask who prepared reagents, loaded instruments, named files, entered sample positions, reviewed results, and approved the report. Automated systems reduce some errors and introduce others. Manual transcription, copy-and-paste, barcode overrides, and reanalysis should remain visible in audit records.

Destructive or consumptive testing requires documentation

Some testing consumes all or part of the sample. Record pretest amount, sampling decision, consumed quantity, remaining material, and whether defense testing was feasible. If the item was entirely consumed, preserve raw data, photographs, instrument files, controls, and extracts where possible. The issue may implicate discovery and due process as well as chain of custody.

Destruction does not automatically establish bad faith or require exclusion. The legal result depends on the evidence’s apparent exculpatory value, availability of comparable evidence, government conduct, and governing law. But incomplete documentation can prevent meaningful review and strengthen a request for sanctions, limitation, or careful jury instruction.

The analyst who made testimonial assertions may be required

Chain testimony does not replace confrontation. Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts, 557 U.S. 305, 310–11, 329 (2009), treated sworn drug certificates as testimonial. The prosecution could not substitute a certificate for confrontation merely by calling it a business or official record.

Bullcoming v. New Mexico, 564 U.S. 647, 652, 661–65 (2011), rejected admission of a certified blood-alcohol report through a scientist who neither performed nor observed the analysis. A surrogate may know the laboratory generally without being able to answer what occurred in the defendant’s test.

Smith v. Arizona, 602 U.S. 779, 789–802 (2024), holds that an absent analyst’s statements are admitted for their truth when a substitute expert’s opinion depends on those statements being true. Identify which witness observed each material step and which assertions the State seeks to prove.

Digital chain of custody tracks bytes, devices, accounts, and processing

Seizure of a device is only the first link

Document where the device was found, who possessed it, make, model, serial number, hardware identifiers, condition, screen state, power state, network status, SIM and storage media, photographs, and packaging. Identify whether officers interacted with the device before forensic acquisition and whether remote access or synchronization remained possible.

A serialized phone can be readily identified like other durable objects, but its data can change. Incoming messages, background processes, cloud synchronization, battery loss, remote wipe, unlocking, and examiner actions may modify state. Isolation and preservation decisions should be recorded, including any limitations or failures.

Forensic acquisition creates derived evidence

Record acquisition type, date, examiner, tool and version, connection method, source identifiers, warnings, errors, encryption status, hash values, and output files. Logical, file-system, and physical acquisitions recover different material. A later extraction may not match an earlier one because the device or tool changed.

Hashes can show that a forensic image remained byte-for-byte unchanged. They do not establish who created the underlying data or whether it changed before acquisition. Parsed reports, screenshots, converted media, and analyst spreadsheets are new derivatives with their own hashes and transformation histories.

Cloud and provider evidence has two chains

One chain concerns provider creation and preservation; another concerns law-enforcement receipt and handling. Preserve the legal process, provider cover letter, native return, folder structure, load files, metadata, hashes, and download logs. Determine whether the provider produced stored content, account metadata, system logs, or a report generated for the request.

An investigator may import the return into review software, normalize time, filter accounts, select messages, export spreadsheets, and make trial screenshots. Each transformation should be reproducible. The provider’s certification does not automatically authenticate a later curated exhibit or prove the human author of user-generated content.

Chain of custody and authenticity overlap but are not identical

State v. Hendricks, 2025 ND 143, ¶¶ 16–19, upheld jail-call recordings through witness familiarity, voice identification, and the evidence as a whole. A complete custodian chain was not the only authentication method. The decision shows why counsel must identify the exact claim and available circumstantial proof.

Conversely, an impeccable drive-custody log may not authenticate the contents of a screenshot stored on it. Custody proves handling of the medium; authorship and source require other evidence. Digital objections should specify whether the dispute concerns device identity, copy integrity, file origin, account attribution, human authorship, completeness, or interpretation.

Postconviction DNA testing has an express custody requirement

N.D.C.C. § 29-32.1-15 permits a convicted person to seek forensic DNA testing not available at trial under specified conditions. The applicant must make a prima facie showing that identity was at issue and that the evidence has been subject to a chain sufficient to establish it was not substituted, tampered with, replaced, or materially altered.

Long-term preservation records therefore matter beyond the original trial. Determine where the evidence remains, storage conditions, seals, inventories, transfers, prior testing, and remaining quantity. A property-room purge, laboratory retention policy, or unrecorded repackaging can affect whether meaningful testing remains possible.

Counsel pursuing testing should identify the exact item, biological material expected, proposed technology, comparison samples, and how a favorable result could demonstrate actual innocence under the statute. Custody proof should be concrete rather than inferred from the mere existence of an evidence label years later.

How defense counsel should investigate and litigate custody

Build the chain independently

Create a chronological table for each item: agency and laboratory number; description; person releasing and receiving; date and time; location; seal condition; purpose; action; new container or subsample; storage; and supporting document. Do not assume the prosecution’s summary includes every opening or transformation.

Reconcile reports, photographs, property logs, laboratory records, shipping data, body-camera footage, and testimony. Mark gaps, overlaps, impossible travel times, conflicting weights, mismatched identifiers, duplicate numbers, broken seals, and undocumented testing. A visual timeline often reveals discrepancies hidden across hundreds of pages.

Request complete discovery

Seek collection notes, scene images, evidence labels, property receipts, temporary-locker logs, audit trails, access records, inventory histories, refrigeration logs, shipping records, laboratory accession, photographs, worksheets, instrument data, batch controls, quality incidents, retained-sample information, and destruction records. For digital evidence, add acquisition logs, tool versions, warnings, hashes, native returns, and every derivative.

Ask for policies in effect on the relevant date, not only current manuals. A policy deviation does not automatically require exclusion, but it can explain risk and impeach a claim of routine handling. Determine whether the deviation was documented and whether a supervisor approved it.

Inspect the evidence when condition matters

Photograph seals, labels, containers, damage, leakage, initials, dates, and remaining quantity. Compare the item with original scene photographs and laboratory intake images. For biological evidence, use appropriate safety procedures and consider expert attendance. For digital media, work from forensic copies rather than altering originals.

An inspection can distinguish a clerical omission from a material problem. An unsigned line may be harmless when an intact uniquely marked seal and matching logs exist. A replaced package with a different item number, unexplained opening, or insufficient remaining sample may require further investigation or motion practice.

Make an item-specific objection

Identify the exhibit, the missing or conflicting link, the item’s susceptibility to change, the material characteristic at risk, and the relief requested. Tie the argument to Rule 901 rather than treating “chain of custody” as a freestanding phrase. If the issue also implicates hearsay, Rule 702, original-record proof, discovery, or confrontation, state those grounds separately.

Use Kroeplin accurately. It does not say all custody gaps affect only weight. It explains why a gap involving a readily identifiable, relatively impervious firearm did not require exclusion under those facts. 266 N.W.2d at 540–41. A fungible or easily altered item presents a different foundation question.

Cross-examine the risk, not merely the missing signature

For each witness, establish what the person actually observed, the seal condition, handling actions, storage, access, transfers, deviations, and documentation. Then connect the gap to a plausible evidentiary consequence: mixture, contamination, evaporation, degradation, mislabeling, substitution, or inability to reproduce the result.

Avoid claiming tampering without evidence. The stronger argument may be that the State cannot reliably connect the tested material to the accused, cannot rule out contamination built into its own process, or cannot establish the condition required for its expert inference. Precision is more persuasive than accusation.

Seek focused remedies

Depending on the defect, request exclusion, a pretrial hearing, additional discovery, independent testing, inspection, production of the responsible witness, redaction, limitation of the State’s claim, a missing-evidence instruction where law permits, or cross-examination before the exhibit is displayed. The remedy should match the evidentiary harm.

If admitted, preserve the issue and argue weight. Emphasize which links are proved, which are assumed, and why the missing proof matters to an element. The jury should not be told that a barcode or laboratory label answers source, identity, contamination, and accuracy when it documents only custody.

Frequently asked questions about chain of custody in North Dakota

Must every person who handled evidence testify?

Not always. Authentication may be established through testimony, records, identifying features, seals, and circumstances. A material gap can still require more proof when the item is easily altered or substituted.

Does any break in custody require exclusion?

No. Under Kroeplin, a gap involving a readily identifiable firearm affected weight under the facts. Fungible, biological, or easily altered evidence may require a stronger chain.

Why are drugs treated differently from a firearm?

Powder and liquid can be mixed, diluted, contaminated, or substituted without obvious visual change. A serial-numbered firearm is usually easier to identify, though its condition can still matter for forensic testing.

What should a drug-evidence chain include?

Source location, separation, packaging, seals, field tests, weights, storage, transfer, laboratory receipt, sampling, confirmatory tests, consumed quantity, retained material, and resealing.

What should a blood-sample chain include?

Subject identity, collector, draw time, tube and preservative, seal, kit condition, storage temperature, transport, laboratory receipt, testing, controls, and remaining sample.

Can a broken seal make evidence inadmissible?

It can create a serious foundation issue, especially if unexplained and the item is fungible. The court will consider the entire evidence, including documentation of authorized opening and resealing.

Does a property-room barcode prove the chain?

It can document intake and movement, but it does not prove collection source, seal condition, testing, contamination control, or every transformation.

What does an evidence hash prove?

A matching cryptographic hash supports byte-for-byte identity between compared digital files. It does not prove authorship, truth, or the data’s condition before the first hash was calculated.

Is the physical phone’s chain enough to authenticate its messages?

No. Device custody can establish which phone was examined. Message origin, account identity, authorship, completeness, and interpretation require additional evidence.

Can shipping records establish a laboratory transfer?

They can provide circumstantial proof without testimony from every carrier employee. Damaged packaging, tracking conflicts, or receipt discrepancies may require further explanation.

What if testing consumed the entire sample?

Review notice, documentation, photographs, raw data, controls, retained derivatives, and whether comparable testing was possible. The legal remedy depends on the evidence and government conduct.

Can a substitute analyst testify about the result?

A substitute may explain general procedures, but Bullcoming and Smith restrict the use of an absent analyst’s testimonial assertions when offered for their truth.

Does a laboratory certificate eliminate confrontation?

No. Melendez-Diaz held that testimonial drug-analysis certificates could not replace constitutionally required confrontation.

What is a derived sample?

It is material created from the original evidence, such as a DNA extract, aliquot, test-fired bullet, or forensic image. Its identifier and custody should trace back to the source.

Can evidence be authentic but materially changed?

Yes. It may be the same item but degraded, contaminated, cleaned, edited, recompressed, or partially consumed. Condition must be proved when the State’s inference depends on it.

What discovery is most important?

Original labels, photographs, custody and access logs, storage records, shipping, laboratory intake, worksheets, raw data, batch controls, deviations, destruction records, and all digital transformations.

How does chain of custody affect postconviction DNA testing?

N.D.C.C. § 29-32.1-15 requires a prima facie showing that the evidence was not substituted, tampered with, replaced, or materially altered.

What makes a chain objection persuasive?

Identify the precise gap, the evidence’s vulnerability, the material characteristic at risk, supporting records, and a focused remedy. A generic missing-signature argument is less effective.

Official authorities cited

Legal information, not legal advice. Chain-of-custody issues depend on the item, source, susceptibility to change, collection, packaging, seals, storage, transfers, opening, sampling, testing, consumption, retained material, digital processing, laboratory controls, identifying features, authentication claim, confrontation, discovery, objections, and current law.


Call nowChoose a time