Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Joinder and Severance of Criminal Charges in North Dakota

North Dakota permits related offenses and participants to be charged and tried together when Rule 8 is satisfied. Separate cases may also be consolidated…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

When charges or defendants may be tried together—and when fairness requires separation

Joinder and Severance of Criminal Charges in North Dakota

North Dakota permits related offenses and participants to be charged and tried together when Rule 8 is satisfied. Separate cases may also be consolidated under Rule 13. But trial efficiency does not override the right to a fair determination of each count against each accused person. Rule 14 authorizes separate trials, severance of defendants, or other tailored relief when joinder creates substantial prejudice that instructions and careful trial management cannot cure.

“Too many charges” is not a complete severance argument. A persuasive motion explains the exact prejudice: evidence admissible on one count but not another, conflicting testimony decisions, a co-defendant’s statement, antagonistic positions that prevent a reliable verdict, unequal evidence, jury confusion, or a geographic count improperly anchoring the rest. The proposed remedy should be as precise as the harm.

North Dakota uses a three-rule framework

Joinder and severance analysis begins with three separate questions. Rule 8 asks whether the prosecution was allowed to place offenses or defendants together in one charging document. Rule 13 asks whether independently filed cases could be tried together as though they had been charged together. Rule 14 asks whether a technically permissible combined trial would cause unfair prejudice requiring separation or another remedy.

Rule 8 defines permissible joinder

N.D.R.Crim.P. 8 addresses both offenses and defendants. Its categories are not identical. Offenses against one accused may be joined based on same or similar character alone. Multiple defendants require alleged participation in the same act, transaction, or series of acts or transactions constituting one or more offenses.

Rule 13 permits consolidation

N.D.R.Crim.P. 13 allows a court to try separate cases together only if every offense and every defendant could have been joined in one indictment, information, or complaint. Consolidation cannot evade Rule 8. The court must compare the actual allegations, participants, evidence, and transactions before combining files.

Rule 14 protects fairness

N.D.R.Crim.P. 14(a) provides that when joinder or consolidation appears to prejudice a defendant or the prosecution, the court may order separate trials of counts, sever defendants’ trials, or provide any other relief justice requires. Rule 14(b) permits an in-camera review of defendant statements the prosecution intends to use before the court rules on severance.

Improper joinder differs from prejudicial joinder

If Rule 8 never authorized the combination, the issue is misjoinder. The explanatory note to Rule 14 says that when original joinder was improper, severance is not discretionary. When joinder was proper, Rule 14 gives the court discretion to manage demonstrated prejudice. A motion should present these as alternative arguments rather than treating them as the same test.

The court’s duty continues during trial

Prejudice may become clear only after testimony begins, a statement is offered, a co-defendant changes position, or the State’s proof develops differently from its pretrial proffer. Rule 14’s explanatory note and North Dakota cases recognize a continuing duty to reassess. Counsel should renew the request at the point the feared prejudice becomes concrete.

When several offenses against one defendant may be joined

Rule 8(a) permits separate counts in the same charging document under three alternatives: the charges are of the same or similar character; they arise from the same act or transaction; or they are connected with or form parts of a common scheme or plan. Felonies and misdemeanors may be combined. Each offense must appear in a separate count.

Same or similar character

This category can permit joinder even when incidents involve different dates or victims. Similar statutory charges, methods, targets, or surrounding circumstances may support the State’s position. But broad labels should not replace analysis. Two accusations do not become similar merely because both are crimes, involve relationships, or require police testimony.

Same act or transaction

A single episode may produce several counts: an alleged driving event could generate DUI, refusal, driving under suspension, and fleeing counts; one confrontation might generate assault, terrorizing, weapon, and restraint allegations. Overlapping time, place, witnesses, and evidence strongly support joinder, though Rule 14 still applies if one count creates unusual prejudice.

Connected acts or a common scheme or plan

Separate events may be connected by a common objective, continuing course of conduct, repeated order violations, coordinated financial activity, concealment, or another factual link. The connection must be more than prosecutorial convenience. The defense should ask what evidence proves the alleged link and whether that evidence would be admissible in separate trials.

State v. Castleman

In State v. Castleman, 2024 ND 93, ¶¶ 2–9, the State charged thirteen offenses including stalking, harassment, evidence tampering, and multiple violations of a judicial order. Although dates, locations, and some facts differed, overlapping witnesses and a common scheme supported one trial. The Supreme Court affirmed because the defendant did not show specific substantial prejudice.

Castleman’s practical lesson

The Court described the burden as “arduous” and held that a better chance of acquittal in separate trials does not suffice. The defense presentation had relied on general assertions that the number of charges would overwhelm the jury and had not explained how joinder hindered a particular defense. A useful motion must go count by count and show what unfair event will occur in the combined trial.

Evidence overlap is important but not decisive

When the same witnesses and exhibits would appear in each trial, separate proceedings consume resources and repeat testimony. That favors joinder. But overlap does not answer whether highly inflammatory proof on one count will be used improperly on another, whether the jury can compartmentalize, or whether the accused has incompatible testimony decisions.

When multiple defendants may be charged and tried together

Rule 8(b) authorizes joinder when the defendants allegedly participated in the same act or transaction, or in the same series of acts or transactions constituting one or more offenses. Defendants may appear together in some counts and separately in others; every participant need not be charged in every count.

A shared transaction supplies the link

Allegations that two people jointly committed robbery, conspired and took overt acts, aided the same assault, possessed property during a single search, or participated in a coordinated financial transaction can support joinder. Mere similarity of separate conduct is insufficient for multiple defendants unless the alleged series connects them.

Not every defendant needs identical evidence

Joint trials frequently involve different roles and different quantities of proof. One accused may appear in video; another may be tied by messages or witness testimony. Unequal evidence alone does not require severance. The defense must explain why the disparity will prevent a reliable individual decision despite count-specific instructions and separate verdict forms.

State v. Stridiron

In State v. Stridiron, 2010 ND 19, ¶¶ 5–9, two defendants faced charges arising from the same contemporaneous series of acts directed at the same victim. The Court held joint trial served economy and affirmed denial of severance. It quoted the principle that bare claims of spillover or a better acquittal chance do not compel separate trials.

Mutual finger-pointing is not automatically enough

Co-defendants often minimize their own role and blame another. North Dakota decisions recognize that an attempt by one accused to exculpate himself by inculpating another does not, standing alone, require separate trials. The motion needs to show that the positions are genuinely irreconcilable or that the jury cannot follow limiting instructions and evaluate each person separately.

The State may not combine unrelated defendants by label

Calling events a “series,” “group,” or “scheme” is not a substitute for alleging and proving a factual connection. If defendants committed separate similar offenses without participation in a common act or connected series, Rule 8(b) may not authorize joinder even though Rule 8(a) could have allowed similar charges against one person.

Rule 13 consolidation of separately filed cases

Separate complaint numbers do not guarantee separate trials. Rule 13 permits consolidation when the offenses and defendants could all have appeared in one charging document. The analysis therefore returns to Rule 8 and then proceeds to Rule 14.

The court must evaluate all cases together

A consolidation order should identify why each offense satisfies Rule 8(a) and why every defendant satisfies Rule 8(b). Combining a case with one accused and another case with two accused people may require more than showing similar evidence. The entire proposed grouping must have been permissible at the charging stage.

Timing affects defense preparation

Late consolidation can change witness strategy, exhibit preparation, motion deadlines, trial length, plea evaluation, and investigation. Even if Rule 13 permits a joint trial, counsel may request adequate preparation time, targeted discovery, revised deadlines, or severance when lateness creates concrete prejudice that a continuance will not cure.

Consolidation does not merge legal identities

Each count retains its elements, burden, defenses, and verdict. Each defendant remains entitled to an individualized determination. The court should use separate verdict forms, clear instructions, and evidence limitations. Counsel should object whenever argument or presentation invites the jury to treat the number of allegations as proof.

Geographic consequences

N.D.C.C. § 29-01-06.1 may permit a properly joined multiple-count indictment or information to be tried in a county where one offense occurred. That makes joinder more than a scheduling matter. If one count supplies the only county connection, the defense should examine misjoinder, severance, venue proof, and what happens if the anchor count is dismissed.

Substantial prejudice is the central Rule 14 inquiry

A combined trial creates some disadvantage for nearly every accused person. Rule 14 does not promise the most favorable trial arrangement. It protects against substantial prejudice that threatens a fair trial and cannot be adequately reduced by instructions, evidentiary rulings, redaction, separate verdict forms, or another measured response.

Evidence spillover

Spillover occurs when evidence admitted for one count or defendant may influence the jury on another. The strongest motion identifies the exact exhibit or testimony, explains why it would be inadmissible in a separate trial, describes its inflammatory force, and shows why the jury cannot realistically limit its use. General claims that all damaging evidence will spill over are rarely enough.

Propensity reasoning

Multiple similar accusations can invite an improper “where there is smoke” inference. Counsel should assess whether the State could offer each incident in a separate trial under Evidence Rule 404(b) or another rule. If cross-admissibility is weak, the risk of jurors using one allegation to prove character on another becomes more serious.

Jury confusion

Many counts, recurring witnesses, repeated exhibits, different mental states, alternative theories, and separate defendants can make compartmentalization difficult. A motion should demonstrate confusion with a proposed evidence matrix, explain overlapping names or dates, and identify inconsistent limiting instructions. Complexity is more persuasive when made concrete.

Gross disparity in proof

A weak count tried beside an exceptionally strong and disturbing count may benefit from the stronger case. Disparity alone is not decisive, but it matters when the evidence is not cross-admissible and the lesser count risks being decided by association. The defense should compare the trial proof expected for each count rather than merely compare charging levels.

Loss of a meaningful testimony choice

An accused may wish to testify about one incident but remain silent about another. To support severance, counsel should provide enough information—often under seal or through careful proffer—to show important testimony on one count and a strong reason not to testify on the other. A bare statement that the client might choose differently resembles the insufficient assertion in Castleman.

Cumulative punishment is a separate issue

Joinder decides trial structure, not whether convictions merge or whether punishments may be cumulative. Double-jeopardy and statutory-unit questions should be preserved independently. Severance does not cure multiplicitous charging, and a single trial does not authorize multiple punishments forbidden by law.

Co-defendant statements and the confrontation problem

A joint trial becomes especially sensitive when the State plans to introduce one defendant’s statement that also incriminates another. Rule 14(b) allows the judge to inspect intended statements in camera before deciding severance. Counsel should obtain the exact recording, transcript, report, proposed redaction, and planned foundation.

Bruton v. United States

In Bruton v. United States, 391 U.S. 123, 126, 135–37 (1968), the United States Supreme Court held that admitting a non-testifying co-defendant’s confession expressly implicating the accused violated confrontation rights even though the jury was instructed to use it only against the declarant. The constitutional issue can make ordinary limiting instructions inadequate.

Redaction must be meaningful

Replacing a name while leaving obvious blanks, nicknames, unique descriptions, or contextual clues may still identify the co-defendant. The defense should read the redaction alongside the indictment, opening statement, other testimony, and exhibits. A theoretically neutral pronoun can become unmistakable in context.

Testifying declarant changes the analysis

If the declarant testifies and is subject to effective cross-examination, the confrontation concern differs. But the defense cannot assume the co-defendant will take the stand. Trial planning should address what happens if expected testimony does not occur, privilege is invoked, or the defense rests without calling the declarant.

Options short of severance

The court may exclude the statement, require constitutionally adequate redaction, limit its scope, reorder proof, use a separate jury in unusual circumstances, or sever trials. The choice depends on content, evidentiary purpose, confrontation law, and whether alteration would distort the statement or impair the prosecution’s legitimate use.

Co-defendant testimony and conflicting defense positions

Severance disputes often arise because one accused wants testimony from another, or because the defenses appear antagonistic. These issues require more than speculation. The moving party should make a careful record without sacrificing privilege or revealing unnecessary strategy.

Seeking exculpatory testimony from a co-defendant

A motion should identify the substance and significance of the expected testimony, the basis for believing the co-defendant would testify in a separate proceeding, and why the evidence is unavailable elsewhere. Courts are appropriately skeptical when the anticipated witness has not committed to testify or would retain a valid privilege.

Conflicting defenses

Defenses are not irreconcilable merely because each accused says the other was more responsible. The key question is whether the jury would have to reject one defense to accept the other, and whether that conflict threatens a reliable individualized verdict. Cross-examination by co-defense counsel can intensify prejudice when it functions as a second prosecutor.

One defendant’s silence

The jury must not use one accused person’s decision not to testify against that person or anyone else. Joint presentation should avoid comments that invite comparison between a testifying co-defendant and a silent one. Counsel should request appropriate instructions and object to arguments that burden the constitutional choice.

Different admissibility for each defendant

An exhibit may be admissible against one accused but hearsay, irrelevant, or unfairly prejudicial against another. Evidence Rule 105 requires restriction to the proper scope upon timely request. If repeated limiting instructions cannot realistically prevent misuse, that supports Rule 14 relief.

Conflict among defense lawyers

Separate counsel is essential where interests diverge, but separate lawyers do not eliminate trial prejudice. Joint-defense communications, privilege, cross-examination, plea negotiations, and witness strategy require care. Counsel should not assume a cooperative pretrial position will remain aligned after the State offers a plea or new evidence appears.

Rule 14 permits more than an all-or-nothing decision

A court can tailor relief to the problem. A motion that offers workable alternatives demonstrates that the defense is addressing fairness rather than merely seeking delay or tactical advantage.

Separate trials of count groups

Counts may be divided into logical sets rather than tried individually. For example, allegations involving one complainant could be separated from unrelated allegations involving another, while closely connected counts remain together. Grouping can reduce repeated witnesses while preventing the most serious spillover.

Severance of defendants

Defendant severance may be necessary for a co-defendant statement, irreconcilable defenses, unavailable exculpatory testimony, radically unequal evidence, or another concrete threat. The order can establish trial sequence and discovery obligations. Sequence matters when a later witness may no longer have a privilege after the first case concludes.

Exclusion or redaction

If one exhibit creates the primary prejudice, excluding or redacting it may preserve a fair joint trial. Counsel should evaluate whether redaction alters meaning, creates an obvious omission, or impairs the ability to cross-examine. Any agreed redaction should be reviewed in the exact format the jury will see or hear.

Limiting instructions and verdict forms

Count-specific instructions, defendant-specific instructions, repeated limiting directions, separate evidence summaries, and individual verdict forms can reduce confusion. The defense should propose precise language rather than merely assert instructions will fail. If even the best instruction cannot cure the problem, explain why.

Continuance and preparation relief

When late joinder creates a preparation problem, time may cure prejudice without separate trials. But a continuance does not cure a confrontation violation or inherently unfair evidence spillover. Counsel should distinguish harm caused by insufficient preparation from harm caused by the combined trial itself.

How to build a North Dakota severance record

The record must permit the trial judge to make a reasoned decision and the appellate court to evaluate it. Castleman shows the risk of relying on naked assertions. A disciplined filing connects facts, evidence, and law.

Identify the joinder basis the State claims

Quote the relevant Rule 8 language and require the prosecution to specify whether it relies on similarity, the same transaction, connected transactions, or a common scheme. For multiple defendants, identify the alleged shared act or series. Attack misjoinder first if that foundation is absent.

Use an evidence cross-admissibility chart

List every major witness and exhibit, the counts and defendants for which it is offered, the evidentiary rule supporting admission, and its prejudicial effect elsewhere. This shows whether a joint trial saves meaningful proof or mainly exposes the jury to material it otherwise would not hear.

Make a careful testimony proffer

If testimony choice supports severance, identify the important subject on which the accused wishes to testify and the substantial reason for silence on other counts. If co-defendant testimony is sought, establish likely availability and content. Request sealed or in-camera treatment when necessary to protect rights.

Address proposed safeguards

Anticipate the State’s argument that instructions, redaction, or separate verdict forms will cure prejudice. Explain the exact wording and context that make those safeguards inadequate. Alternatively, propose a safeguard that resolves the issue if the court declines full severance.

Renew at meaningful trial points

Renew after opening statements, before a challenged statement or exhibit, when a co-defendant’s strategy becomes clear, at the close of the State’s evidence, and when instructions are settled if the circumstances warrant it. State what changed and request a ruling. Repetition without a new basis is less useful than a focused renewal tied to the record.

Preserve conditional-plea requirements carefully

Castleman reached the severance question after conditional pleas under Rule 11(a)(2). Conditional appellate preservation requires compliance with that rule, including the necessary writing and consent. Not every joinder issue will be dispositive or appropriate for conditional review, so counsel should confirm the record before a plea.

Frequently asked questions about joinder and severance

What does joinder mean in a North Dakota criminal case?

Joinder means placing multiple offenses or multiple defendants in one charging document or trial. Rule 8 defines when joinder is allowed. Rule 13 permits separate files to be consolidated when they could have been joined originally.

What does severance mean?

Severance separates defendants’ trials or separates counts into different trials. Under Rule 14, the judge may also grant narrower relief such as exclusion, redaction, limiting instructions, or another measure that protects fairness.

Can felonies and misdemeanors be charged together?

Yes. Rule 8(a) permits felony and misdemeanor offenses in separate counts of one charging document when the charges satisfy the same-or-similar, same-transaction, connected-transaction, or common-scheme criteria.

Can charges involving different dates be joined?

Yes. Different dates do not defeat joinder when charges are similar, connected, or part of a common scheme. Castleman affirmed joinder of charges from different dates and locations where witnesses overlapped and the allegations formed a common plan.

Can charges involving different alleged victims be tried together?

Potentially. The State still must satisfy Rule 8, and the court must consider Rule 14 prejudice. The defense should examine evidence overlap, cross-admissibility, inflammatory proof, jury confusion, and whether one accusation will be used improperly to bolster another.

Can several defendants be joined just because they face similar charges?

No. Rule 8(b) requires alleged participation in the same act, transaction, or series of acts or transactions. Similar but independent offenses do not become jointly triable merely because the statutory charge or method resembles another person’s case.

Does every defendant have to be named in every count?

No. Rule 8(b) allows defendants to be charged together or separately in one or more counts, and all defendants need not appear in each count. The shared transaction or series still must support joinder.

Is a better chance of acquittal enough for severance?

No. North Dakota cases repeatedly say that a better acquittal chance in separate trials does not establish substantial prejudice. The moving party must identify a concrete harm to a fair trial that available safeguards cannot adequately cure.

What is evidence spillover?

Spillover is the risk that jurors will use proof admitted for one count or defendant when deciding another. The strongest argument identifies evidence that would not be admissible separately and explains why its emotional or inferential force cannot be compartmentalized.

What if one co-defendant confessed and named the other?

A non-testifying co-defendant’s incriminating confession can create a confrontation problem under Bruton. The court may inspect the statement under Rule 14(b) and consider exclusion, constitutionally sufficient redaction, or separate trials. Context matters; replacing a name may not be enough if identity remains obvious.

Do antagonistic defenses always require separate trials?

No. Finger-pointing and differing accounts are common. Severance becomes stronger when the defenses are genuinely irreconcilable, acceptance of one requires rejection of the other, or one defense effectively turns co-defense counsel into a second prosecutor in a way instructions cannot cure.

What if I want to testify about only one charge?

That can support severance, but a general assertion is usually insufficient. The defense should proffer the important testimony to be given on one count and the substantial reason for not testifying on another, using sealed or in-camera procedures when appropriate.

Can the judge consolidate cases with different file numbers?

Yes, under Rule 13, but only if all offenses and defendants could have been joined in one charging document under Rule 8. Rule 14 remains available if the consolidated trial would create substantial prejudice.

When should a severance motion be filed?

File within the pretrial-motion deadline once the factual basis is known. Renew if trial developments make the prejudice concrete. Counsel should also seek timely disclosure and in-camera review of co-defendant statements before the court rules.

Can the court grant something less than separate trials?

Yes. Rule 14 authorizes any relief justice requires. Options include count grouping, statement redaction, evidence exclusion, limiting instructions, separate verdict forms, reordered proof, additional preparation time, or other tailored measures.

Does severance eliminate double-jeopardy or merger issues?

No. Trial structure and permissible punishment are different questions. Multiplicity, lesser-included offenses, statutory units of prosecution, merger, and cumulative sentencing should be analyzed and preserved separately.

Can the prosecution request severance?

Yes. Rule 14 protects both a defendant and the prosecution from prejudicial joinder. The defense should evaluate whether the requested division affects speedy-trial rights, evidence rulings, venue, plea posture, witness availability, and trial sequence.

What should a strong severance motion include?

It should identify the Rule 8 basis, challenge misjoinder if applicable, chart evidence by count and defendant, explain cross-admissibility, describe specific prejudice, address instructions and redaction, make any necessary testimony proffer, and propose workable relief.

Severance is won with specificity

North Dakota courts value efficient trials, especially where witnesses and evidence overlap. The defense therefore must show more than the ordinary disadvantage of facing several allegations at once. The question is whether this combined trial will prevent a reliable, individualized decision and whether a practical safeguard can cure the danger.

Early review of statements, evidence overlap, venue, anticipated testimony, and count-specific defenses gives counsel the best chance to shape a fair trial. When later events confirm the concern, a prompt, focused renewal turns prediction into a preserved record.


Call nowChoose a time