Fargo, West Fargo & Cass CountyCriminal defense informationCall 701-929-4886
Fargo and North Dakota criminal defense guide

Fargo Criminal Solicitation Defense

North Dakota criminal solicitation requires more than angry talk, fantasy, generalized approval of crime, or an offensive suggestion. Under N.D.C.C. §…

ElementsPenaltiesEvidenceNext steps

North Dakota criminal solicitation defense

Fargo Criminal Solicitation Defense

North Dakota criminal solicitation requires more than angry talk, fantasy, generalized approval of crime, or an offensive suggestion. Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-06-03, the State must prove that the accused commanded, induced, entreated, or otherwise attempted to persuade another person to commit a particular felony as a principal or accomplice; intended to promote or facilitate that felony; acted under circumstances strongly corroborative of that intent; and caused the solicited person to commit an overt act in response.

Those limits are important. The proposed offense must be a felony and must be particularized. The speech or conduct must amount to real instigation. The circumstances must show a serious criminal intent. And the person approached must do something in response. A private thought, idle boast, emotional outburst, fictional discussion, political statement, or rejected proposal without a responsive act is not automatically criminal solicitation.

A defense should identify the exact words, intended felony, alleged recipient, response, overt act, chronology, and source evidence before accepting the label used in a police report.

What the State Must Prove for Criminal Solicitation

An effort to persuade another person

The accused must command, induce, entreat, or otherwise attempt to persuade another. The statute focuses on instigating another person to commit the felony, either directly or as an accomplice. Describing a crime, expressing anger, predicting what someone might do, or passively agreeing with another person’s plan is not necessarily persuasion.

A particular felony

The solicitation must concern a particular felony. The State should identify the target crime by statute, victim or property, conduct, objective, and grade. A general statement favoring lawlessness or violence is not the same as asking someone to commit a defined felony.

Intent to promote or facilitate the felony

The accused must intend that the solicitation advance the commission of the specified felony. Sarcasm, role-play, testing loyalty, venting, bluffing, performance, journalism, fiction, or an attempt to expose wrongdoing can produce words that sound criminal when removed from context. Intent must be proved from reliable evidence.

Strongly corroborative circumstances

The statute demands circumstances strongly corroborative of the intent. That requirement prevents serious punishment based on speech alone or an ambiguous remark. Payment, detailed planning, target information, tools, surveillance, repeated instructions, deadlines, secrecy, travel arrangements, or concrete preparation may be relevant. The absence of such facts can be equally important.

An overt act in response

The solicited person must commit an overt act in response to the solicitation. North Dakota therefore requires more than a communication that is ignored or flatly rejected. The State must identify the act, prove who committed it, show it was done because of the solicitation, and connect it to the proposed felony.

Proof beyond a reasonable doubt

Each element is separate. A disturbing message may show persuasion but no responsive act. A recipient may act, but for an independent reason. A plan may be serious but concern a misdemeanor. The State cannot combine gaps into a general impression of dangerousness.

The Alleged Solicitation Must Concern a Particular Felony

The official drafting materials explain that the word “particular” helps keep the statute from reaching general exhortations and protected speech. The prosecution should define the proposed felony with enough precision for the accused to defend against it and for jurors to agree on the same crime.

Felony, not a generic crime

Section 12.1-06-03 is limited to felonies. A request to commit an infraction, Class B misdemeanor, or Class A misdemeanor does not satisfy this general solicitation statute, although another offense may specifically prohibit the request.

Grading facts matter. Theft may be a felony or misdemeanor depending on value, property type, circumstances, and history. Assault can have different grades based on injury, weapon, victim status, and culpability. Drug offenses depend on substance, weight, conduct, and sometimes location or history. The State must prove the solicited conduct would constitute a felony.

Victim, object, and criminal objective

A statement such as “someone should teach him a lesson” does not necessarily identify aggravated assault, robbery, terrorizing, or another particular felony. The State may rely on surrounding conversations, payment, target information, weapons, or instructions to supply specificity. The defense should insist that inference not replace evidence.

Principal or accomplice conduct

The person solicited can be asked to commit the felony personally or to assist another as an accomplice. A request to provide a weapon, drive, unlock a door, supply credentials, identify a victim, or hide a device could be solicitation if the accused intended to persuade the recipient to become an accomplice to a particular felony and the other requirements are met.

Conditional proposals

A proposal can be conditional—act if a payment arrives, if a victim appears, if a partner agrees, or if an event occurs. The condition may still support a charge when the request is serious and particular. A condition that shows fantasy, impossibility, joking, or lack of commitment can undermine intent and corroboration.

Alternative crimes and unanimity

If the State alleges the accused proposed burglary, robbery, theft, assault, or murder in the alternative, the defense should examine notice and unanimity. Jurors should not be allowed to convict even though different jurors believe different felonies were solicited unless the law permits the particular formulation.

What Counts as Commanding, Inducing, Entreating, or Attempting to Persuade?

Direct commands and requests

“Kill him,” “burn the building,” “steal that truck,” or “break in and take the files” can be direct when used seriously and linked to a specific felony. Questions or offers—“Will you do it for $5,000?”—can also be attempts to persuade.

Inducements

Money, debt forgiveness, drugs, property, status, employment, threats against a third person, promises of protection, or a share of proceeds can be alleged as inducements. The State should prove the offer, who made it, whether it was serious, the proposed exchange, and how the recipient understood it.

Entreaties and repeated pressure

Pleading, repeated urging, emotional manipulation, or appeals to loyalty can fall within “entreats” or other persuasion. Repetition may strengthen the State’s case, but a complete conversation may show that the accused was repeating another person’s idea, trying to dissuade the recipient, or using sarcasm.

Suggestions and mere encouragement

The official drafting commentary distinguishes instigation from mere encouragement. General approval after another person announces a plan may be morally troubling without being an attempt to persuade that person to adopt the plan. The origin of the idea, sequence, exact words, and recipient’s existing intent matter.

Silence, presence, and association

Being present during a criminal discussion, failing to object, associating with a suspect, or knowing that others are angry is not a command or inducement. The State must attribute affirmative words or conduct to the accused.

Intermediaries

A solicitation may be relayed through another person. The prosecution must prove the accused intended the message to reach the proposed actor and that it accurately conveyed the request. Multiple layers create hearsay, attribution, and credibility issues.

Digital communications

Texts, direct messages, disappearing chats, gaming communications, email, social media, voice notes, videos, and encrypted platforms can carry a solicitation. Account ownership does not establish authorship. Shared devices, compromised accounts, spoofing, cloning, edits, generated content, and missing context must be examined.

Intent to Promote or Facilitate and Strong Corroboration

North Dakota requires both criminal intent and circumstances strongly corroborative of it. The State should not ask jurors to decide a serious felony-grade offense from words alone without reliable context.

Facts that may corroborate serious intent

Evidence may include a payment or deposit, target address, photographs, schedule, map, weapon, access code, vehicle, burner phone, disguise, surveillance, deadline, instructions for avoiding detection, planned alibi, disposal plan, or repeated follow-up. The evidence must be authenticated and connected to the accused.

Facts that may undermine serious intent

An obviously fictional setting, laughter, immediate retraction, absurd proposal, known role-play, artistic production, intoxicated rambling, heated argument, lack of follow-up, recipient disbelief, or inconsistent details may show the words were not intended to produce a felony. None is automatically decisive; the complete circumstances control.

Motive is evidence, not an element substitute

Jealousy, debt, anger, revenge, insurance, custody conflict, business rivalry, or fear can supply a possible motive. Motive does not prove that the accused made the solicitation or intended a felony. Objective acts and reliable communications remain necessary.

Law-enforcement stings and informants

An informant or undercover officer may record conversations, propose details, ask leading questions, and offer services. The defense should identify who introduced the criminal objective, who escalated it, what the accused actually requested, and whether the responsive overt act came from the solicited person.

North Dakota entrapment under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-05-11 is an affirmative defense with specific requirements. Merely providing an opportunity is generally different from using persuasion or other means likely to cause normally law-abiding persons to commit the offense.

Speech and constitutional limits

The First Amendment does not protect a serious request that another person commit a crime, but the statute’s particular-felony, corroboration, intent, and overt-act requirements prevent punishment of abstract advocacy, fiction, political rhetoric, or mere offensive speech. A court should examine the actual words and context.

Statements and Miranda

Police may treat an ambiguous apology or statement of anger as an admission of intent. Obtain the complete recording. State v. Spillum, 2021 ND 25, ¶¶ 11–18, explains the objective custody analysis for Miranda.

The Solicited Person Must Commit an Overt Act in Response

The act must be performed by the person solicited

The statute says “the person solicited” commits the overt act. An act by the accused alone may corroborate intent or support attempt, but it does not necessarily satisfy this element. The State must identify the recipient and that recipient’s act.

The act must respond to the solicitation

Temporal sequence is not enough. The recipient may visit a store, purchase an ordinary item, travel, call someone, or research a location for an independent reason. Communications, testimony, surveillance, receipts, and timing must show the act was responsive to the request.

The overt act need not complete the felony

Solicitation is designed to permit intervention before the target felony occurs. An overt act can be preparatory if it objectively responds to the solicitation. Returning for further discussion, inspecting a location, acquiring a tool, contacting an accomplice, or accepting a payment may be alleged, depending on the facts.

A rejected proposal without action

If the recipient refuses, reports the conversation, and takes no act in response toward the proposed crime, section 12.1-06-03 may not be complete. Police may investigate attempt or a specific solicitation statute, but the required overt act cannot be omitted.

Reporting to police

A recipient’s act of contacting law enforcement is a response to the communication, but it is not ordinarily an act to advance the felony. The statutory language and drafting purpose contemplate an act indicating movement beyond speech toward the criminal objective. The defense should contest an effort to use protected reporting as the overt act.

Undercover acts

An undercover officer or informant may pretend to accept and take steps under police control. Section 12.1-06-03(3) says the solicited person’s incapacity or defense is no defense to solicitation. The disputed questions may instead be whether the act was truly in response, whether the accused solicited a particular felony, and whether entrapment or lack of intent applies.

Murder-for-hire evidence

State v. Lail, 2020 ND 13, ¶¶ 9–24, 937 N.W.2d 558, addresses attempted murder in a murder-for-hire setting. The Court treated offering a specific payment and helping formulate the plan as concrete steps. Although Lail concerned attempt, it illustrates why payment, target details, and operational planning can be powerful corroboration in a solicitation investigation.

Statutory Defenses, Nondefenses, and Renunciation

Victim or inevitably incidental conduct

Section 12.1-06-03(2) provides a defense when, if the criminal object were achieved, the accused would be a victim of the offense; when the offense is defined so the accused’s conduct would be inevitably incident to its commission; or when the accused otherwise would not be guilty under the offense statute or accomplice law.

This defense prevents the State from punishing a protected victim or a person whose necessary participation the legislature did not intend to treat as criminal solicitation. Its application depends on the target felony’s text and related statutes.

Incapacity of the person solicited is not a defense

Subsection 3 says it is no defense that the solicited person could not be guilty because of lack of responsibility or culpability, incapacity, or another defense. A minor, undercover officer, person feigning agreement, or person with a personal defense can still be solicited within the statute if the other elements are proved.

Voluntary and complete renunciation

Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-06-05(3), it is an affirmative defense to solicitation that, under circumstances manifesting voluntary and complete renunciation of criminal intent, the defendant prevented commission of the crime solicited.

Stopping because police are approaching, detection has become likely, the crime has become harder, or the plan will be postponed does not qualify. Neither does choosing another victim or similar objective. The defendant must prevent the solicited crime, not merely regret the request.

Student immunity

Section 12.1-06-05(4) creates immunity under Chapter 12.1-06 when a student voluntarily and completely renounces criminal intent; the offense would harm covered students or school employees or damage covered school property; and the student reports the renunciation to specified law-enforcement or school officials before harm or damage occurs. Each condition matters.

Withdrawal after the overt act

Once the recipient has committed the overt act, simply saying “forget it” does not erase the completed offense. The affirmative defense requires prevention of the solicited crime under voluntary and complete circumstances. Preserve all efforts to stop the plan, warn the target, recover tools, return money, or contact authorities.

How Solicitation Differs From Attempt, Conspiracy, Facilitation, and the Completed Felony

Solicitation versus attempt

Attempt requires an intentional substantial step strongly corroborative of intent to complete the underlying crime. Solicitation requires persuasion of another plus that person’s responsive overt act. In some murder-for-hire cases, the same planning and payment evidence can support both theories, but their elements and grades differ.

Solicitation versus conspiracy

Conspiracy requires an agreement and an overt act to effect its objective. Solicitation can exist before an agreement: one person attempts to persuade another, and the recipient responds with an overt act. If the recipient agrees, prosecutors may allege conspiracy as well. The defense should determine whether there was actual agreement or only negotiation, refusal, or police pretense.

Solicitation versus facilitation

Facilitation under section 12.1-06-02 involves knowingly providing substantial assistance to someone already intending a felony, and that person must actually commit a contemplated or related felony using the assistance. Solicitation is persuasion intended to produce a particular felony and does not require completion of that felony.

Solicitation versus accomplice liability

Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-03-01, a person who intends that an offense be committed and commands, induces, procures, or aids another may be liable for the completed offense. If the solicited felony occurs, the State may pursue accomplice liability. It must still prove the culpability and connection required for the full offense.

Specific solicitation statutes

North Dakota separately criminalizes certain requests, including soliciting obstruction of proceedings and conduct involving minors, prostitution, controlled substances, or other subjects. Those statutes may not require the same felony, corroboration, or overt-act elements. The charging section must be read on its own terms.

Multiple convictions and same-elements analysis

State v. Smith, 2024 ND 127, ¶ 8, restates the same-elements test. Solicitation, attempt, conspiracy, accomplice liability, and the completed felony should be compared for included-offense, double-jeopardy, and sentencing issues.

State v. Cotton, 2025 ND 191, ¶¶ 5–8, discusses sentencing merger and recognizes that preparation or solicitation of another offense may share its criminal objective.

Classification and Penalties

Criminal solicitation is one class below the felony solicited. Under N.D.C.C. § 12.1-32-01, the maximums depend on that resulting class.

Solicitation of a Class AA felony

The next class below Class AA is Class A felony. A Class A felony carries up to twenty years’ imprisonment, a $20,000 fine, or both. Solicitation to commit intentional murder can therefore produce extraordinary exposure even though no killing occurs.

Solicitation of a Class A felony

This is a Class B felony, carrying up to ten years’ imprisonment, a $20,000 fine, or both.

Solicitation of a Class B felony

This is a Class C felony, carrying up to five years’ imprisonment, a $10,000 fine, or both.

Solicitation of a Class C felony

This is a Class A misdemeanor, carrying up to 360 days’ imprisonment, a $3,000 fine, or both.

The underlying grade must be proved

The State should identify facts that make the proposed crime a particular class: value, injury, weapon, age, protected status, quantity, location, prior record, or other enhancement. If the requested conduct would only be a misdemeanor, section 12.1-06-03 does not apply.

Sentencing consequences beyond confinement

Probation, no-contact orders, restitution for losses caused by the offense, firearm restrictions after felony conviction, employment and licensing effects, immigration consequences, and forfeiture may apply. Sex-offender registration or other specialized consequences depend on the target offense and disposition, not the word solicitation alone.

Evidence to Preserve and Defense Issues to Investigate

Original recordings and complete communications

Preserve native audio, video, texts, direct messages, email, call logs, attachments, group threads, platform exports, and surrounding conversations. A transcript can omit tone, pauses, overlap, corrections, and metadata. A screenshot can omit the remark that changes meaning.

Authentication

State v. Burton, 2025 ND 83, ¶¶ 20–26, explains authentication. A username, contact label, or displayed number is not conclusive proof of authorship. Device, provider, account, location, and witness evidence should connect the communication to the accused.

The alleged overt act

Obtain receipts, surveillance, travel data, search history, purchase records, messages, and the recipient’s explanation. Determine whether the act occurred, followed the solicitation, responded to it, and advanced the particular felony rather than an innocent objective.

Informant and cooperating-witness records

Preserve recordings before and after each contact, instructions to the informant, payments, benefits, criminal history, dismissed charges, immigration or custody incentives, prior reliability, and deviations from instructions. A recipient seeking a benefit may exaggerate or create details.

Business records and money

Bank, payment-app, hotel, rental, phone, platform, shipping, and retail records can corroborate or contradict a proposed payment or preparation. State v. Henderson, 2024 ND 42, ¶¶ 9–21, explains business-record foundation.

Digital searches

State v. Quam, 2026 ND 145, ¶¶ 9–18, addresses nexus for digital warrants. A reported conversation about one alleged felony does not automatically justify an unlimited search of every device, account, contact, and year.

Expert evidence

Voice identification, audio enhancement, device extraction, location analysis, image origin, translation, coded-language interpretation, and financial tracing may involve specialized opinions. State v. Doyle, 2024 ND 108, ¶¶ 5–11, addresses disclosure of expert opinions.

No persuasion

The recipient originated the plan, the accused merely listened, the statement described rather than advocated, or the alleged intermediary changed the words. Sequence and complete source evidence can defeat the instigation element.

No particular felony

The words were vague, general, conditional, metaphorical, or concerned at most a misdemeanor. The State cannot let jurors select from several crimes after the fact.

No intent or strong corroboration

The discussion was a joke, fantasy, performance, role-play, venting, fiction, or an effort to expose the recipient. There was no payment, target information, equipment, follow-up, secrecy, or operational detail.

No responsive overt act

The recipient refused, ignored the request, merely reported it, or acted for an independent reason. The prosecution cannot rely exclusively on the accused’s own later conduct for an element assigned to the person solicited.

Entrapment

Law enforcement or an informant induced the crime by persuasion or other means likely to cause normally law-abiding persons to commit it, rather than merely offering an opportunity. Recordings, contact frequency, pressure, vulnerabilities, and who introduced each detail matter.

Renunciation

The accused voluntarily and completely changed course and actually prevented the solicited felony. A developed record should show warnings, recovery of money or tools, cancellation, contact with authorities, protection of the target, and causation.

Unlawful search or interrogation

Evidence may be suppressed when officers lacked a valid warrant or exception, exceeded consent, searched beyond authorized scope, or obtained an unwarned custodial or involuntary statement.

North Dakota Appellate Principles

Every statutory limit matters

State v. Olson, 2026 ND 8, ¶¶ 18–29, discusses statutory construction and culpability. A solicitation instruction should preserve the particular-felony, persuasion, intent, corroboration, and responsive-overt-act requirements.

A plea needs a factual basis

State v. Haskins, 2026 ND 23, ¶¶ 22–28, addresses factual basis. A solicitation plea should identify the words or conduct, target felony, intended promotion, corroborative circumstances, recipient, responsive act, and classification.

Documents and value require foundation

State v. Ziegler, 2025 ND 78, ¶¶ 9–18, illustrates foundation for documentary and value evidence. Payment summaries, target photographs, maps, messages, and alleged contracts should be supported by competent evidence.

Published construction remains limited

North Dakota published opinions do not answer every question about what counts as an overt act “in response” or circumstances “strongly corroborative” of intent. The statutory text, official drafting history, reliable source evidence, and instructions tailored to the charged felony therefore lead.

Early Defense Work in a Fargo Solicitation Case

Create a communication-by-communication timeline. Record the first mention of the criminal objective, who introduced it, exact words, proposed victim and conduct, response, alleged agreement, payment, tools, planning, retraction, and every act by the recipient.

Preserve devices and accounts without altering them. Send prompt requests for platform data, surveillance, payment records, vehicle data, lodging, retail purchases, call recordings, and informant materials. Obtain source audio rather than relying on an officer’s transcript.

Do not contact the recipient or target, delete messages, move money, recover property secretly, or create a new explanation online. Those actions can violate release terms, generate tampering allegations, or destroy context.

At the first appearance, address counsel, release, no-contact provisions, travel, employment, device conditions, and firearm restrictions. Discovery should include all recordings, source messages, recipient statements, informant instructions and benefits, overt-act evidence, warrant materials, expert reports, and proof of the target felony’s grade.

Motions may concern suppression, entrapment procedure, authentication, completeness, hearsay, informant disclosure, expert testimony, First Amendment limits, statutory sufficiency, multiple counts, jury unanimity, included offenses, and renunciation evidence.

Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Solicitation

What is criminal solicitation in North Dakota?

It is intentionally trying to persuade another person to commit a particular felony as principal or accomplice, under strongly corroborative circumstances, when that person commits an overt act in response.

Is talking about a crime enough?

No. The State must prove real persuasion, a particular felony, intent to promote or facilitate it, strongly corroborative circumstances, and a responsive overt act.

Must the requested crime be a felony?

Yes under section 12.1-06-03. Requests involving misdemeanors may fall under specific statutes but do not satisfy this general solicitation offense.

What is a particular felony?

The proposed crime must be sufficiently identified by conduct, objective, victim or property, and felony grade. General advocacy or vague anger is not necessarily enough.

What is an overt act in response?

It is an act by the person solicited that objectively responds to the request and moves beyond speech. The act need not complete the target felony.

What if the person refuses?

If the recipient refuses and takes no responsive overt act toward the felony, section 12.1-06-03 may be incomplete, though another offense can be investigated.

Must the target felony actually occur?

No. Solicitation allows intervention before completion. The recipient must commit the responsive overt act, not the felony itself.

Can an undercover officer be solicited?

Yes. The solicited person’s incapacity or defense is generally no defense. Intent, persuasion, corroboration, overt act, and entrapment remain important.

Can a joke or angry outburst be solicitation?

Not automatically. Tone, context, specificity, follow-up, payment, preparation, and whether the recipient acted help determine intent and strong corroboration.

How is solicitation different from conspiracy?

Conspiracy requires agreement and an overt act. Solicitation can occur before agreement when one person tries to persuade and the recipient responds with an overt act.

How is solicitation different from facilitation?

Facilitation involves substantial assistance used in a completed felony. Solicitation involves persuading another and does not require the felony to be completed.

What are the penalties?

Solicitation is one class below the felony solicited, ranging from a Class A misdemeanor for solicitation of a Class C felony to a Class A felony for solicitation of a Class AA felony.

Can renunciation be a defense?

Yes, if it is voluntary and complete and the accused actually prevents the solicited crime. Fear of detection, postponement, or changing victims does not qualify.

Can digital messages prove solicitation?

They can, but the State must authenticate them, prove authorship, provide context, and establish every statutory element. Account ownership alone may be insufficient.

Can police search all of my devices?

A search generally requires a valid warrant, consent, or another exception. A digital warrant needs probable cause, nexus, particularity, and a supported scope.

What evidence should be preserved immediately?

Preserve complete messages and recordings, devices, platform and provider data, payment records, overt-act evidence, surveillance, informant contacts, and proof concerning the target felony.

Official Authorities

Speak With a Fargo Criminal Solicitation Defense Lawyer

Solicitation cases often turn on context: who first proposed the crime, whether the words were serious, what felony was identified, and whether the recipient truly acted in response. The source recording and timeline can be more important than the accusation’s label.

Bring the charging papers, release order, warrant materials, devices, full communications, payment records, recordings, recipient information, and evidence of any withdrawal or prevention effort to a confidential consultation. Do not contact the recipient or target and do not alter evidence.


Call nowChoose a time